The sometimes conflicting accounts of the facts sustain a great deal of interest, as do the unsolved mystery aspect of the case and the abundant use of evidence photos, location visits, and archival video clips. (dvdizzy.com)
Jennifer Aniston also delivers a fantastic performance, but the film's mystery aspect proves to be a hindrance. (collider.com)
As if aware of the limitations of its derivative witchcrafting (complete with rote Pendereckian orchestral screeching), the film gets bogged down in its equally boring mystery aspect. (thecriticalcritics.com)