Rhetoric Versus Reality — What We Know and What We Need to Know
About Vouchers and Charter Schools (Santa Monica, Calif.: RAND Corporation).
Rhetoric Versus Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know
About Vouchers and Charter Schools
Lead author of Rhetoric vs. Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know
About Vouchers and Charter Schools, he has published in the Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, Behavioral Science and Policy, Statistics and Public Policy, the Journal of Labor Economics, Economics of Education Review, Education Finance and Policy, American Journal of Education, Teachers College Record, Peabody Journal of Education, Education Next, the Handbook of Research on School Choice, and the Encyclopedia of Education Economics and Finance.
Not exact matches
The assault on
charters (
and school
vouchers or tax credits for Catholic schools) is not
about the kids» education.
And by the end of the legislative session, he got just about everything he wanted in a school reform plan: expansion of charter schools, private school vouchers, and college scholarships for students who graduate high school ear
And by the end of the legislative session, he got just
about everything he wanted in a school reform plan: expansion of
charter schools, private school
vouchers,
and college scholarships for students who graduate high school ear
and college scholarships for students who graduate high school early.
The poll results that Education Next released Tuesday carry mildly glum news for just
about every education reformer in the land, as public support has diminished at least a bit for most initiatives on their agendas: merit pay,
charter schools,
vouchers,
and tax credits, Common Core,
and even ending teacher tenure.
The 2017 EdNext Poll — including the Trump Effect on public opinion
about education
Charter schools lose favor but opposition to
vouchers declines; Opposition to Common Core plateaus
and support for using the same standards across states gains ground
Hardly anyone talks
about how the growing movement toward parental choice
and competition, in the form of
vouchers and charter schools, will affect the teaching profession.
Concerns
about charter schools include them challenging the long - existing status quo (there are more than 4,000 in the U.S.); adding fuel to the debate of
vouchers, markets,
and choice;
and affecting the funding of traditional schools, seemingly pitting
charter activists against traditional school educators.
As reported elsewhere, the survey asked
about school spending,
charters,
vouchers, teacher unions, bilingual education, digital learning, state take - overs of troubled district schools, teacher unions, merit pay, teacher tenure,
and many other matters.
Information
about local district rankings increases public support for school choice programs, including
charter schools, parent trigger mechanisms,
and, especially, school
vouchers for all students.
For those who think
about school choice,
vouchers and charter schools are canonical.
She makes clear that she does not understand the purpose of profit when she scoffs
about voucher programs
and charter schools that «divert... taxes to pay profits to investors»
and «turn a profit off their children, in order to reward their shareholders.»
But «when you talk
about charters and vouchers, it's disruptive, so people have stronger feelings
about them,» he says.
To support my case, I presented three categories of evidence: (1) the fact that national reform groups seem deeply concerned
about Detroit; (2) the similarity in performance between the city's
charter and traditional public schools;
and (3) the large negative effects of two statewide
voucher programs on student outcomes.
Ryan is more positive
about the varieties of school choice — whether within school districts, or by way of
charter schools
and vouchers,
and of course he favors interdistrict choice — but the legislative
and judicial obstacles (not to mention practical ones) to the expansion of this route are clear.
What does the evidence say
about a free market approach to school reform that relies on school
vouchers and unregulated forms of
charter schooling?
As of the spring of 2001, the Center for Education Reform estimated that 1,750
charter schools were educating
about 520,000 students in 36 states
and the District of Columbia, more than seven times the number of students in all the public
and private
voucher programs combined.
Much has been said
about charter schools in Michigan
and Detroit,
about accountability for
voucher programs,
and even the views of DeVos's family members!
«What's important when you're embracing a new approach to education, like
charters and vouchers, is to think
about how those impact all the children, not just those who get the
vouchers or get into the
charters,» Russakoff said.
Russakoff: What's important when you're embracing a new approach to education, like
charters and vouchers, is to think
about how those impact all the children, not just those who get the
vouchers or get into the
charters.
«Although the current dialogue
about school choice is generally focused on
charter schools,
vouchers,
and the overall diversion of taxpayer monies to private entities, it misses a fundamental reality: Most public school districts already offer a wide range of choices to their students.»
According to Diane Ravitch, «they commit
about $ 160 million each year for
charters,
vouchers, Teach for America, think tanks,
and media.
The President's budget would cut federal education programs across the board
and use the money to spend
about $ 400 million to expand
charter schools
and vouchers for private
and religious schools,
and offer another $ 1 billion to push public schools to favor
charter and private schools.
Sept / Oct 2017: Public Schools & Choice — Amidst the national conversation
about charter schools
and vouchers, this issue will provide a primer on choice models.
Lawmakers continue to rely on parents to regulate the
voucher /
charter industry while evidence points to the fact that parents possess imperfect information
about the private
and charter school market at the outset.
Our research indicates that continued growth in
charter,
voucher and tax - credit scholarship programs across the country could propel innovation to new heights, bringing
about broader positive change
and particularly impacting traditionally disadvantaged students,» Wolf
and Egalite said.
Listen to Dropout Nation Editor RiShawn Biddle chat with Roland Martin on his show
about why black families are embracing the expansion of
charter schools,
vouchers and other forms of...
Washington —
About 85 percent of renowned teachers disagree that the federal government should provide greater school choice through
vouchers, a new survey finds -
and almost all of the surveyed teachers believe that
charter schools
and private schools that receive federal funds should be subject to the same accountability measures as public schools.
Private school choice programs, such as
vouchers, are legal in only
about half of states,
and seven states still prohibit
charter schools.
Teaching is beginning to encounter a push toward a market approach, as evidenced by debates
about charter schools, school choice,
and school
vouchers.
The investigative juggernaut came out with a story headlined «Failing
Charter Schools Have a Reincarnation Plan,» about failing charter schools converting to privates in search of voucher and tax credit r
Charter Schools Have a Reincarnation Plan,»
about failing
charter schools converting to privates in search of voucher and tax credit r
charter schools converting to privates in search of
voucher and tax credit revenue.
Education advocacy —
and I'm talking mainly
about the debate on
charter schools,
vouchers,
and tracking school progress (aka accountability)-- deserves your attention.
After three decades of competition, Milwaukee schools — public district,
voucher,
and charter collectively — perform
about as well as similar high - poverty
voucher - free urban districts like Detroit, Memphis
and Buffalo.
Dale Kildee (MI), the committee's ranking Democrat, expressed skepticism
about the effect of
charter school access
and vouchers on parental engagement
and stressed that the two options do not serve all children: «As we explore strategies for comprehensive school reform, including parent engagement,» he cautioned, «we should never lose sight of our commitment to equal access for all students, not just those who receive a
voucher or attend a
charter school.»
Ravitch frequently writes
about topics including Common Core,
charter schools,
vouchers,
and standardized testing
and is well respected across partisan lines.
And while her supporters say she has deep knowledge when it comes to vouchers, charter schools, and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing about other areas of education policy, including special educati
And while her supporters say she has deep knowledge when it comes to
vouchers,
charter schools,
and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing about other areas of education policy, including special educati
and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing
about other areas of education policy, including special education.
Arne Duncan, education secretary under President Barack Obama, was a supporter of
charter schools (though not
vouchers) but still spoke
about the need for —
and the aspirational goals of — public education.
They want the media talking
about anything other than
vouchers,
charters,
and the federal funding of them through ESSA (the Every Student Succeeds Act)
and tax laws.
Are billionaires like Eli Broad suddenly hitting the brakes on ed reform because they care
about pubic school budgets, or are they just upset that
vouchers and religious school tax credits will be horning in on the lucrative
charter school racket?
School choice proponents may have had their biggest success in Indiana, where Republican Governor Mitch Daniels signed legislation that removes the
charter cap, allows all universities to be
charter authorizers,
and creates a
voucher program that enables
about half the state's students to attend public or private schools.
Insist on an evidence - based debate
about charter schools
and vouchers.
Last year, JPS was under - funded by
about $ 11.5 mil during the last school year, while the conservative state leaders have continually changed laws
and regulations to make it easier to privatize public dollars (i.e.
charter,
vouchers, tax credits), starting with 3
charter schools in Jackson.
You're inspired, you're passionate, you've just received your invitation for an in - depth interview
and you're ready to sell your experience
about why you're going to make an exceptional Fellow, but... BUT you're not really sure why Betsy DeVos was a controversial choice for Secretary of Education, the argument between
charter school vs traditional public school vs school
vouchers alludes you,
and you once thought Common Core was a pilates ab workout.
Look: if we had clear, repeatable,
and compelling empirical data
about the virtues of
charter schools, or private school
vouchers, or the negative effects of public school unions on student performance, then we'd have hard choices to make as a society — particularly considering that the right of teachers to organize is precisely that, a right that can't be taken away whenever it is convenient.
And given the problems faced in the charter schools sector — including news stories about charter school operators that have woefully managed their financial operations (and ultimately, the taxpayer dollars with which they are trusted), and the religiously - bigoted, xenophobic suspicions about the Cosmos Foundation charter schools — voucher supporters must step up their own efforts to defend school choi
And given the problems faced in the
charter schools sector — including news stories
about charter school operators that have woefully managed their financial operations (
and ultimately, the taxpayer dollars with which they are trusted), and the religiously - bigoted, xenophobic suspicions about the Cosmos Foundation charter schools — voucher supporters must step up their own efforts to defend school choi
and ultimately, the taxpayer dollars with which they are trusted),
and the religiously - bigoted, xenophobic suspicions about the Cosmos Foundation charter schools — voucher supporters must step up their own efforts to defend school choi
and the religiously - bigoted, xenophobic suspicions
about the Cosmos Foundation
charter schools —
voucher supporters must step up their own efforts to defend school choice.
The report is part of a multiyear study examining the performance of
charter schools in New York City by Caroline M. Hoxby, a Stanford economist who has written extensively
about her research on
charter schools
and vouchers.
ProPublica Reporter Annie Waldman has written an amazing piece
about how failing
charter schools are finding new life by converting to private schools
and accepting
vouchers.
We are encouraging folks to organize a delegation to attend local opportunities to meet with members of Congress, to ask questions
about the budget
and to demand no cuts to the federal education budget, no expansion of
charter schools,
and no
vouchers!
USA Today quoted Sen. Susan Collins as saying that DeVos» «concentration on
charter schools
and vouchers... raises the question
about whether or not she fully appreciates that the secretary of education's primary focus must be on helping states
and communities... strengthen our public schools.»