At oral arguments about whether public prayers at a New York town's board meetings are permissible, the high court took a broad look at the country's church - state history and even the Supreme Court's own traditions.
Not exact matches
At Wednesday's
oral arguments, the court's conservative majority appeared to have the votes to allow the public prayers to continue in some form, but both sides expressed concerns
about the level of judicial and government oversight over prayers presented by members of a particular faith.
The weekly posts here offer an insider's perspective on
oral arguments in major cases
at the federal appellate level and news stories
about sitting Supreme Court justices.
Justice Kagan said that
oral argument is
about «the justices talking to each other with some helpless person standing
at the podium who you're talking through.»
He notes that
at the
oral argument of the case, one of the plaintiffs» lawyers proudly described himself as a «bounty hunter,» to which the court in its opinion remarked, «We will have more to say
about exactly who Proposition 65 was created for later, but it wasn't bounty hunters.»
I think one of the things that has come
about for me in doing this over the last 10 or 15 years is that I really noticed and heard a lot of more experienced attorneys complaining to me that they think younger attorneys are less adept
at oral arguments because they don't practice formulating their SOPs.
As Linda Greenhouse and others have noted, CJ Roberts» vote is perhaps the biggest SCOTUS - watcher aspect of Cunningham, especially given his apparent hostility to Apprendi expressed
at the Cunningham
oral argument and Jeff Rosen's recent article in the Atlantic Monthly
about CJ Roberts» eagerness for greater consensus.
Barry «is a very active judge
at oral argument, which is usually a sign a judge has already read the briefs and is very actively thinking
about the case,» said David Fine, an appellate lawyer based in Harrisburg, Pa. «She is very polite in questioning and
at the same time also direct.»
Carolyn Elefant stated, «[I'm excited
about] new legal research products like CaseText's CARA that take a new approach to legal research — I can't wait to have it scrape the cases from a brief so I can have them all
at my fingertips
at oral argument.»