On average, sea levels were between 50 and 82 feet higher the last time
CO2 levels were at 400ppm.
It did so when
CO2 levels were at least 800ppm.
Corals evolved during the Cambrian era when atmospheric
CO2 levels were at 6,000 - 7,000 ppm, around 4,000 percent or 20 times higher than today's «CO2 - starved» environment of 400 ppm.
And CO2 is not the cause, as determined by scientists for the 300 - year drought that ended the Bronze Age (
CO2 levels were at pre - industrial / consumer levels).
CO2 levels were at about 400 ppm.
Empirical evidence tells us that the last time
CO2 levels were at 400 ppm, the oceans were considerably higher, perhaps in the neighborhood of 85 feet.
By the mid-18th century,
CO2 levels were at 280 ppm.
The problems with associating sensitivity with a temperature in 2100 are twofold: first, at the time we reach CO2 doubling, the temperature will lag behind the equilibrium value due to thermal inertia, especially in the ocean (thought experiment — doubling CO2 today will not cause an instant 3C jump in temperatures, any more than turning your oven on heats it instantly to 450F), and secondly,
the CO2 level we are at in 2100 depends on what we do between now and then anyway, and it may more than double, or not.
tallbloke (05:52:23): According to the Scotese et al graph posted by Anthony on the Hansen thread, the temperature was about 10C higher when
the co2 level was at 8000ppm 550M years ago.
According to the Scotese et al graph posted by Anthony on the Hansen thread, the temperature was about 10C higher when
the co2 level was at 8000ppm 550M years ago.
AND temperatures start climibing when
CO2 levels are at their LOWEST, and start falling when
CO2 levels are at their HIGHEST, all of which which firmly erases ANY notion that CO2 «drives» temperature.
Not exact matches
Allen notes that there
are lots of consumer - friendly carbon dioxide detectors on the market, adding that the research found that people performed best
at CO2 levels of 500 to 600 ppm.
at risk of not helping, the AR4 WG3 carbon price range of 30 - 50 USD
is based on stabilizing
CO2 at 450ppm, a
level more recent work has determined to
be very dangerous.
Reached by phone and asked of the possibility that
CO2 levels aren't
at 400, a spokesman for the agency laughed.
At that time,
CO2 levels are thought to have
been close to current
levels — around 390 parts per million — but global temperatures
were warmer.
When the fish grew up in fresh water and seawater with high concentrations of
CO2, they lost weight
at double the rate of fish that
were only exposed to salt water with higher
CO2 levels.
Part of the reason it took longer to recognize the impact of
CO2 is because adult fish tend to
be more capable of handling higher
levels of acidity, said Colin Brauner, a zoology professor
at UBC and co-author of the study.
Ou and her colleagues
at UBC created an experiment to test how fish
were responding not only to ambient
CO2 concentrations but also to acidity
levels expected by 2100.
A new climate change modeling tool developed by scientists
at Indiana University, Princeton University and the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration finds that carbon dioxide removal from the atmosphere owing to greater plant growth from rising
CO2 levels will
be partially offset by changes in the activity of soil microbes that derive their energy from plant root growth.
In the report, an international team of climate scientists warns policy - makers that
levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere
are at the extreme end of predictions made only in 2007, and that natural
CO2 sinks such as oceans
are becoming saturated.
At a global
level, the excess of atmospheric
CO2 is absorbed by ocean waters and it causes changes in water chemistry (pH decrease or ocean acidification).
So, we
're talking about this period 3.5 million years ago, this
is the middle Pleistocene, and that
's where the
CO2 concentrations
were round about 400 ppm; and if we want to look
at CO2 concentrations considerably higher than that, we
're going to go much deeper in time, and then we
're really going into periods where sea
level was even higher.
In this study in Timothy grass, researchers led by environmental health scientist Christine Rogers of the UMass Amherst School of Public Health and Health Sciences (SPHHS) determined the interactive effects of
CO2 and ozone
at projected higher
levels on pollen production and concentrations of a Timothy grass pollen protein that
is a major human allergen.
Among the most pressing questions
is how fish react to rising
levels of
CO2, said Tom Bigford, policy director
at the American Fisheries Society.
Climate models suggest that widespread glaciations couldn't take place
at that time unless
CO2 levels dropped to about eight times what they
are at present, says Tim Lenton, an earth scientist
at the University of Exeter in the United Kingdom.
CO2 levels are projected to
be 2.5 times higher in the oceans by the end of this century, which
is causing the ocean to acidify
at a rate unprecedented for 300 million years.
The IPCC has mapped out possible futures in which
CO2 levels would
be stabilised
at anything from current
levels to 1.6 trillion tonnes, to
be reached
at various times over the next 200 years.
The amount of carbon dioxide (
CO2) in the air
is now
at its highest
level in human history, largely because of coal - burning power plants and vehicle emissions.
The ice core data also shows that
CO2 and methane
levels have
been remarkably stable in Antarctica — varying between 300 ppm and 180 ppm — over that entire period and that shifts in
levels of these gases took
at least 800 years, compared to the roughly 100 years in which humans have increased atmospheric
CO2 levels to their present high.
That amounts to about 50 percent more
CO2 than
was in ambient air
at the experiment's beginning, and double preindustrial
levels.
In climate science, for example, where we don't need an elaborate climate model to understand the basic physics and chemistry of greenhouse gases, so
at some
level the fact that increased
CO2 warms the planet
is a consequence of very basic physics and chemistry.
Once atmospheric
CO2 levels rise and plants begins to photosynthesise
at a higher rate, the fungi may not
be able to provide nitrates quickly enough to meet the plants» demands.
When the Kyoto protocol
was drawn up in 1997, the
CO2 level had reached
at 368 ppm.
«This does not necessarily mean that a similar response would happen in the future with increasing
CO2 levels, since the boundary conditions
are different from the ice age,» added by Professor Gerrit Lohmann, leader of the Paleoclimate Dynamics group
at the Alfred Wegener Institute.
Looking
at strains of the plankton under varying
CO2 levels, researchers found that while some plankton had difficulties forming their shells when the water
was more acidic, others did not, causing researchers to speculate that the plankton might
be able to use another form of calcium to substitute in shell making.
Moreover, finding a self - contained lake of carbon dioxide
at a relatively shallow 4,600 feet below sea
level «
is highly suggestive that if you went down a further 4,900 feet you could actually inject liquid
CO2 and it would
be quite stable,» says Ken Nealson, a geobiologist
at the University of Southern California.
Before the industrial age, the
CO2 level was steady
at around 280 parts per million.
The researchers used predictions of the amount of
CO2 that would
be in the atmosphere
at the end of this century to set the
CO2 levels in these last five bags.
Co2 is.04 % of all green house gas and increased
levels are the result of the sun heating up, as evidence points to the other planets and moons heating up
at the same rate.
Published in the journal Oecologia, the study
is the first to show that even freshwater fish which only spend a small portion of their lifecycle in the ocean
are likely to
be seriously affected under the higher
CO2 levels expected
at the end of the century.
There
is hope, however, as
CO2 from burning fossil fuels and other human activities appears to have
leveled off in 2015
at roughly 40 billion metric tons of
CO2 liberated into the atmosphere.
«The atmospheric and oceanic
CO2 increase
is being driven by the burning of fossil fuels,» says Pieter Tans, a senior scientist
at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Earth System Research Laboratory, who leads the U.S. government effort to monitor global greenhouse gas
levels.
Their results showed that changes in key water - stress variables
are strongly modified by vegetation physiological effects in response to increased
CO2 at the leaf
level, illustrating how deeply the physiological effects due to increasing atmospheric
CO2 impact the water cycle.
But this also means that targets such as stabilizing atmospheric concentrations of
CO2 at 450 parts per million (nearly double preindustrial
levels) to avoid more than a 3.6 degree F (2 degree C) temperature rise
are nearly impossible as well.
Using the samples, Quinton analyzed them for chemical clues that can
be related to
CO2 levels at specific time periods.
Numerous groups around the world have
been conducting experiments in which plots of land
are supplied with enhanced
CO2, while comparable nearby plots remain
at normal
levels.
It
's also possible that the growth spurt
is partly due to a rise in
CO2 levels, which may «fertilise» forests, says Iain Robertson of the School of the Environment and Society
at Swansea University, UK.
The point they make
is that future climate change due to inertia has
been assessed by keeping
CO2 concentrations
at some predetermined
level, that
is, that there will
be no future increase in human input of
CO2 into the atmosphere.
This
is the warming you get if we keep
CO2 (and other GHG and pollutant
levels) constant
at today's values.
Recent findings, however, suggest that the rate
at which
levels of
CO2 are increasing today far exceeds that of the PETM era.