Schlenker suggested Jennifer put half her daughters» RESP money in a Canadian bond index fund, 20 % in
a Canadian equity index fund, 15 % in a U.S. equity index fund, and 15 % in an international stock index fund.
With a management fee of just 0.12 % (the MER will be a few basis points higher), VCN is now the cheapest broad - market
Canadian equity index fund available.
Canadian equities: You should expect
a Canadian equity index fund's tracking error to be about as large as its MER — perhaps a few basis points more.
If you buy a cap - weighted
Canadian equity index fund, you're investing 30 % of your money in the financial sector and just 3 % in consumer staples.
We replaced the balanced fund with individual asset class securities (index funds):
a Canadian equity index fund, a U.S. equity index fund, an international equity index fund, a bond index fund, etc..
For instance, how many
Canadian equity index funds consistently outperformed, say, the Mawer New Canada fund over the last 20 years?
Not exact matches
I also hold additional
equity assets via
Canadian index ETFs and mutual
funds.
Only 8 % of actively managed U.S.
equity funds outperformed the S&P 500 in
Canadian dollar terms, while less than 5 % of actively managed International
equity funds outperformed their respective
index return.
But the
Canadian Equity Eseries is has only returned 5.4 % versus 8.5 % for the normal
index fund.
53.2 % of
Canadian Equity active
funds outperformed the S&P / TSX Composite
Index.
In addition, these
funds must invest at least 50 % of their non-cash assets in income - generating securities such that the 3 - year weighted average yield on the
equity component of the fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity
equity component of the
fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity In
fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the
Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity
Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity In
Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX
Equity Equity Index.
However,
Canadians already have significant holdings in local markets through
index funds, ETFs, mutual
funds or direct stock holdings and need to calibrate their allocation to
Canadian equities to account for the additional exposure through VEU, which at present is 5.5 %.
You can invest in a particular
fund (e.g. a
Canadian equity fund) that underperforms its benchmark (e.g. the S&P / TSX Composite
Index) for the period that you've invested in it.
That makes the $ 1.37 billion (AUM)
Canadian equity fund arguably the lowest - fee ETF or mutual
fund in the country: the previous claim for lowest MER was the Horizons S&P / TSX
Index ETF (HXT / TSX).
For example, our
Canadian equity fund's benchmark would be the S&P / TSX Composite
Index.
For example, if you have a
Canadian equity fund that focuses on small companies, you may want to compare it to the S&P / TSX Small Cap
Index.
Canadian equity iShares Core S&P / TSX Capped Composite
Index ETF [TSX: XIC] TD
Canadian Index Fund [TDB900]
iShares uses cap - weighted
indexes for almost all of its
equity ETFs, including its
Canadian Composite
Index Fund (TSX: XIC) and the
Canadian S&P 500
Index Fund (TSX: XSP).
For example, instead of tracking the S&P / TSX Composite, the
Canadian equity fund will now simply hold shares in the BMO Dow Jones Canada Titans 60
Index ETF.
Let's say an investor allocates equal amounts to
Canadian, US, and international
equity index funds, and that she contributes $ 1,000 a month to her account.
The
Canadian equity component of the Streetwise Balanced
Fund is pegged to the S&P / TSX 60
Index, which includes large - cap stocks only.
The table below shows the tracking error of
Canadian equity ETFs and
index funds in -LSB-...]
My FAQ page points out triumphantly that 92.6 % of actively managed
Canadian equity funds have trailed the S&P / TSX Composite over the last five years, according to Standard & Poor's, which issues a quarterly report on active
funds versus the
indexes.
In fact, between 2008 and 2012, only 9.84 % of
Canadian equity fund managers beat the S&P / TSX Composite
Index.
Say, for example, a
Canadian equity fund beats the S&P / TSX Composite
Index over some period, and the manager takes credit for her superior stock - picking skills.
Canadian investors who want to passively track our
equity markets through ETFs have two choices — the iShares CDN Large Cap 60
Index Fund (XIU) or the iShares CDN Capped Composite
Index Fund (XIC).
But the
Canadian Equity Eseries is has only returned 5.4 % versus 8.5 % for the normal
index fund.
In addition, these
funds must invest at least 50 % of their non-cash assets in income - generating securities such that the 3 - year weighted average yield on the
equity component of the fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity
equity component of the
fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity In
fund's portfolio is at least 1.5 times the average yield of the
Canadian Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity
Equity Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX Equity In
Fund benchmark, defined as the S&P / TSX
Equity Equity Index.
If you're paying 2 % or more for a
Canadian equity fund that just holds the big banks and energy producers that dominate
index funds, your chance of beating the market is virtually zero.
Although U.S. stocks have risen in value in their native currency over that period, U.S.
equity index funds saw negative returns when measured in
Canadian dollars.
But as a long - term strategy, I believe
Canadian investors should use unhedged
index funds for their U.S. and international
equities.
Apart from
Canadian equities, which will be in direct holdings in a handful of stocks, all new money will be invested in ETFs or
index funds.
The BMO US
Equity ETF is significantly more expensive than the Vanguard Total Market ETF (VTI) but is likely to be a significant competitor to the iShares CDN S&P 500 Hedged to
Canadian Dollars
Index Fund (XSP).
Let's turn our attention to the «evidence» presented in a chart yesterday that shows 9 out of 10 largest
Canadian equity mutual
funds outperform the blended
index.
One portion of the portfolio is not an
index fund; it is a
Canadian Equity mutual
fund where the MER is 2.05.
Although TD does indeed have lower MER's with its E-Series
funds, upon closer examination, RBC's
index funds for
Canadian Equity and
Canadian Bond have both consistently demonstrated higher returns over YTD, 1 yr, 3 yr, 5 yr, and earlier.
Unfortunately,
Canadian index funds and ETFs holding foreign
equities often have large tracking errors.
In the
Canadian Equity category, for example, we find that
Canadian fund investors earned an aggregate return of — 10.42 % in 2011, compared with the
index return of — 8.71 %.
«All of our investments are in low - fee ETFs or
index funds in a couch potato portfolio split 20 % U.S.
equities, 20 % international
equities, 20 %
Canadian equities, and 20 % fixed income.
To find
funds that truly are value investors, I conducted a similarity analysis of historical returns and measured the statistical correlation between the monthly returns from various
Canadian equity funds and the monthly returns from value and growth
indexes.
If you side with the optimists, you can gain exposure to
Canadian and global
equity markets via a number of ETFs and
index funds, such as:
An astonishing 93 % of
Canadian equity funds failed to keep up with the S&P / TSX composite
index.
In the second half of 2008, for example, a majority of actively managed
Canadian equity funds beat the
index.
So if the blended
index is denominated in
Canadian dollars and contains a chunk of US
equities, that chunk will have suffered a currency drop that
Canadian Equity funds did not.
I agree with MCF's point that
Canadian equity funds should be compared with TSX Composite
Index instead of a blended i
Index instead of a blended
indexindex.
The broader TSX
index and almost all
Canadian Equity Mutual
Funds are dominated by the Big 5 Banks, Big 3 Insurance names, a couple of Utilities and a couple of Oil & Gas companies.
I think that a
Canadian index is the only appropriate comparison for a
Canadian equity fund.
9 of 10 Largest
Canadian equity mutual
funds have lower volatility than the
index.
There were no ETFs that tracked the TSX Composite in July 2004 but the TD
Canadian Equity Index e-Series
fund was available back then.
Starting Oct. 1, 2015, it says the effective annual management fee on its leading
Canadian equity fund, Horizons S&P / TSX 60
Index ETF (ticker HXT) will be just 0.03 % or three basis points (plus taxes, down from the previous 0.05 %.