From the advent of third - party platforms like Avvo (including UpCounsel and others), one big issue has been how to pay the service without implicating
fee splitting rules.
Fee splitting rules in each jurisdiction must be followed.
Not exact matches
Although the justices heard a case to resolve the question in January 2016, Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association, and appeared likely to overrule Abood and end agency
fees in public sector unions, Justice Antonin Scalia's unexpected death the next month left the court
split 4 — 4 — a
ruling that kept the agency
fees permitted for the time being.
RAN Random walk theory Real Estate Investment Trust Real Estate Mortgage Investment Conduit Reallowance Recession Record date Recourse loan Recovery Redeemable security Redemption
fee Redemption price Red Herring Reference security Refunding Regional exchanges Registered bond Registered Options Principal Registered Options Trader Registered representative Registrar Registration Regressive tax Regular way settlement Regulated investment companies Regulation A offerings Regulation D Regulation M Regulation S Regulation T Regulation U REIT REMIC Re-offering scale Representative Repurchase agreement Reserve requirements Resistance Restricted account Restricted securities Retention Revenue Anticipation Note Revenue bond Reverse
split Reversionary working interest Rights Rights of accumulation Rights offering Riskless transaction Rollover Rollup of a DPP ROP ROT Roth IRA Round lot Royalty
Rule 134 Communication
Rule 144
Rule 144 A
Rule 147
Rules of Fair Practice
The fact that there is a separate transaction in which the service is paid does not mean that the arrangement is not
fee splitting as described in the
Rules of Professional Conduct.
Further, in a
rule - interpretation only a lawyer could truly love,
fee -
splitting rules also extend to non-lawyers owning law firms because owners share in the profits of an entity and all law firm profits come from legal services.
However, as the
rules have developed, they've also been expanded to include other activities that don't necessarily involve people who aren't lawyers practicing law (such as
fee -
splitting).
Of course be mindful of
splitting fees and partnering up with a non-law firm so you don't break any
rules of professional conduct, but this is easy to avoid.
Rewrite the ethics
rules to allow
fee -
splitting between lawyers and non-lawyers, but bring those non-lawyers within the scope of the applicable ethics
rules, including confidentiality and conflicts of interest.
Courts from California to Michigan have
ruled that referral or
split fees can not be collected in full if there is not full documentation from either the client or the attorney side.
Some States Look to Modernize
Fee -
Splitting Rules.
North Carolina and Oregon are taking different approaches, but both have proposed amendments to their
fee -
splitting rules that should take effect before the end of 2017.
Rule 5.4 of the ABA Model
Rules prevents lawyers from
splitting fees with non-lawyers.
In the
ruling, the court said the RESPA provision very clearly applies only to
fees that are
split with another provider (for more on this case, see this issue's ethics column).
But the borrower successfully appealed the
ruling, with the Court of Appeals deciding that an overcharge is not required to bring a RESPA action; a consumer can bring a lawsuit for any charge that allegedly involves a kickback or
fee split that violates RESPA.
Today, in light of the unanimous Supreme Court
ruling, such
fees do not violate Section 8 (b) of RESPA unless the broker who is paid the
fee splits it and pays a portion of it to a third person outside of the brokerage firm who provides no services in exchange for the
fee.
Resolving a circuit
split in the manner urged by NAR, the Supreme Court
ruled that RESPA requires a
fee split of a settlement - service
fee for a § 2607 (b) violation.
Creating a circuit
split between federal appellate courts, the Second Circuit has
ruled that courts are required to defer to United States Department of Housing and Urban Development's («HUD») interpretation of section 8 (b) of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act («RESPA») regarding a lender's mark - up of a third party's
fees when no additional...
Eventually, the trial court
ruled that New York law barred from claiming a commission or any other compensation because the Broker had entered into an illegal
fee splitting arrangement with the Bank.
(Under Freeman vs. Quicken Loans, the court
ruled that the prohibition in RESPA of unearned
fees referred to
fees that are
split with another service provider for which no service is provided — a kickback.