How blurred is the line between the two, and
if evil is necessary for good to prevail, has good actually won out in the end?
========== @LinCA: «
If evil is the result of free will, and your god created free will, then your god is directly responsible for evil.
If an evil is the foreseeable consequence of my action, but indirectly intended, it is morally licit to cause the evil.
After all,
if evil is the foreseeable consequence of my action it is intended in the broad sense of (1).
If all evil is seen as good in God's eyes, what's the difference what we do?
If evil is a lack of direction, good is a finding of direction, of the direction toward God.
If evil is the predominance of I - It, good is the meeting with the Thou, the permeation of I - It by I - Thou.
If evil is relative, it's not simply relative OUTSIDE of humanity, but also within (across races, gender, ages, etc.).
None of the goods humans cherish, including the free exercise of religion, can flourish without a measure of civic peace and security
If evil is permitted to grow, good goes into hiding.
2)
if evil is relative, then compassion must be also.
It follows that
if evil is nonetheless real, then atheism» i.e., the idea of the nonexistence of that evaluator or standard of evaluation» is not only an extraordinarily unappetizing prospect, it is also fundamentally untrue.
For instance,
if evil is just the absence of good, like darkness is the absence of light, your argument bursts immediately.
It may very well be the intent of God to wipe all existence of evil from reality, even
if that evil is man.
If evil is loose in the world, it is up to us to put a stop to it.
Thus in each case good and evil are bound together as they could not be
if evil were an independent substance with an existence of its own.
If evils were not preserved as such, we would not be subject to their continuing destructive influences.
Not exact matches
But the reality
is an ugly one, and even — and especially
if — it complicates the picture some progressives have drawn of Israel as the
evil oppressor, we should not ignore the truth.
Whether you
are a master negotiator or think negotiation
is a necessary
evil, one thing holds constant —
if you don't understand the basic components of an offer to buy a business, you'll
be at a disadvantage.
Peikoff also helpfully answers the burning pop - culture question:
If the movie E.T.
is anti-adult and anti-science — as, by objectivist philosophy, it clearly
is — does that make it inherently
evil and irrational?
And it
's much easier to do that than to say, «Well listen, we have free markets and we have democracy and both those things
are incredibly messy and no one
is really controlling it,» but
if I give you a few symbols and attach a name to it, all of a sudden you have an
evil villain that you can pin the blame on.
In a related issue, Google had to remove one of its «auto - complete» suggestions last year because a number of users found that
if they started typing the words «
Are Jews» into the search box, one of the recommendations
was «
Are Jews
evil?»
Outside of
being evil, of course, it doesn't really matter what
if it
is work, fitness, collecting stamps, gardening or almost anything.
If you think Wall Street banks
are the essence of
evil, reading his letter probably won't change your mind.
«
If someone says something you disagree with, discuss the idea and fall short of discussing why the person who voiced the idea
is dumb, selfish, mad, or
evil.
So the next time you go over your paystub and see how far your gross pay has
been adjusted to your take - home amount, take heart that it
's probably the lesser of all
evils, even
if it doesn't feel like it.
«The widely shared
if unvoiced assumption,» writes Tony Hiss, «
is that the time we spend moving around, except during vacations and getaways,
is a burden, a necessary
evil, a delayed goal, something we have to put up with.»
But
if you
're seeing this strictly as a public relations move meant to distract us from the
evils of Facebook, you need to turn off your computer for a while and go for a walk.
In most of business history, customer service
was viewed as a necessary
evil that didn't have a lot of repercussions
if it
was done poorly, or not at all.
But
if this article
was meant to convey an opinion (i.e. «We shouldn't export oil because higher pump prices
are an unstoppable
evil») then you might as well argue that we shouldn't export ANY goods because that causes the price of those good to go up at home.
If dual class structures
are so
evil, why doesn't; t that apply to companies regardless of country.
Sometimes that
's a necessary
evil if you
're getting much better financing, but it
's not necessarily the most cost - effective option.
So go ahead and dump those BadCoins... but
if there
is a chance the BadCoin developers
are sophisticated and
evil, move your GoodCoins first.
The carry trade, derivatives and massive injections of money created out of thin air
are but nails in our coffins and
if we do not stop these
evil people it will mean destruction.
That may, however,
be the lesser of two
evils if the alternative
is seeing your Social Security check shrink.
22:22
If a man
be found lying with a woman married to an husband, then they shall both of them die, both the man that lay with the woman, and the woman: so shalt thou put away
evil from Israel.
Essentially, Clive Palmer
is what most of us would
be like
if we
were billionaires five times over (he
's working on a recreation of the Titanic too) and has decided to use his money neither for good or for
evil, but for fun.
I see no way that ignorance and truth can
be placed side by side, nor do I believe that
evil is somehow less
evil if the Bible
is quoted to justify it.
If you
are looking for
evil types of atheist, go after the Ayn Rand followers.
If any movie in 3 parts can
be generalized as Good -
Evil - Good, then it must
be about the triumphant resurrection of Heebuh - Jeebus!
Stone reminds us that violence
is not always, absolutely
evil, concluding that «the transformation of the motive» toward an increasingly virtuous object reframes the story, making the violence more «meaningful,
if not fully justified.»
Maybe
evil is the work of the devil, but
if god
is so great and powerful, why can't he stop all the madness?
Because
if god
was «only goodness and light» then all the
evils he lets happen make him a even more sadistic
being then the worst «sinner» on earth.
Even
if we
're only talking «
evil» on a less horrific level — incarcerated criminals — we find the number of atheists and agnostics well below their demographic percentage of the population as a whole.
Well, I don't know
if Obama has any tattoos, or skims money off the collection, or told anyone lately that they
're evil and going to hell just because they disagreed with them, or has ever cheated on his wife with another woman, or man, so maybe he isn't your typical pastor,
is that what you
're saying?
Even
if international tribunals, especially the ICC,
were to meet with greater success in arresting arch-human-rights violators, deterring future violators, and bolstering the rule of law, they would remain morally unsatisfying as a response to massive
evil.
think about this:
if God
were to remove all
evil from this world, he would have to remove free will.
The hypocrisy of the religious zealots
is revolting, they speak as
if their history
is pure as the driven snow and that people like me
are the
evil ones.
This
is all about control with religion and it has to stop.Gay people getting married doesn't have anything to do with straight people getting married.People
are so full of hatred and disrespect it isn't funny.I
'm glad this has come out now, because it really shows how
evil people really are.But these people who are so into GOD, the Bible, Church, and the only way of life they live 4 god, by god are the 1s who prmote going around the world starting WARS, killing innocent women, men, children and families because Jesus guides them in everything they do.That is a crock of B.S. if I ever heard it.They will continus to use GOD and continue their EVIL ways to get whatever they want and CONTROL who ever they
evil people really
are.But these people who
are so into GOD, the Bible, Church, and the only way of life they live 4 god, by god
are the 1s who prmote going around the world starting WARS, killing innocent women, men, children and families because Jesus guides them in everything they do.That
is a crock of B.S.
if I ever heard it.They will continus to use GOD and continue their
EVIL ways to get whatever they want and CONTROL who ever they
EVIL ways to get whatever they want and CONTROL who ever they can.
Even
if a «Christian» folks committed aweful acts, which they did, do, and will, that
's a far cry from all Christians
being evil.