Not exact matches
«Having
concluded that the Commissioner's implementation and usage
of Education Law... is not unconstitutional under either Due Process Clause, the
Court obviously must
conclude that the statute is not unconstitutional on its face,» Acting
Supreme Court Justice Roger D. McDonough wrote in his ruling.
Kyllo v. U.S. (2001):
Justice Antonin Scalia, in a 5 - 4 decision
of the U.S.
Supreme Court,
concluded that thermal imaging was a search within the fourth amendment.
Supreme Court Dec. 29, 2016)-- 4 - 3 decision, majority opinion by
Justice Cuellar and dissent by
Justice Werdegar; discussed in our Dec. 29, 2016 post: Attorney - client privilege does not categorically shield from California Public Records Act disclosure billing invoices sent by clients in
concluded, non-active cases because legal consultation was not the purpose
of the invoices; however, the privilege did protect billing invoice entries in active, pending cases.
«I
conclude that all the claims
of Imperial [Tobacco] and the other tobacco companies brought against the government
of Canada are bound to fail,»
Supreme Court Chief
Justice Beverley McLachlin wrote in the long, complex, and unanimous 9 - 0 judgment.
However,
Justice Vickers
concluded that it was reasonable for the plaintiff to have brought her claim in
Supreme Court for two reasons: (1) when the action was commenced, the plaintiff believed she was suffering from the accident and her pleadings included a claim for loss
of earning capacity and disruption
of the ability to earn income; and (2) ICBC put her credibility seriously in issue when it took the position that she had not suffered from any injury or any significant injury.