[280] He suggested the party's
MPs vote on the matter rather than party members as currently required by party rules.
The Prime Minister has called on the Labour leader to make clear whether he would support measures to stop Scottish
MPs voting on matters that only affect people in England.
Not exact matches
MPs from outside of England are able to
vote on matters that affect only England, while
MPs from England are unable to
vote on matters that have been devolved to the Northern Ireland Assembly, the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly.
Sandford rightly notes that — at present — asymmetric regional devolution would therefore not lead to any restrictions
on MPs» ability to
vote on English - only
matters in the House of Commons.
Knocking
on doors all the time people say it is outrageous that Scottish
MPs, Welsh
MPs - whatever it is -
vote on matters that only affect South Derbyshire.
No doubt they were given added impetus by Nicola Sturgeon's announcement of a change in SNP policy, which would see their
MPs vote on English health
matters that affected the NHS in Scotland.
But he also vowed to use the opportunity to secure English
votes for English laws, raising the prospect of Scottish
MPs being excluded from
voting on English - only
matters — a key demand of many Conservatives.
A: There is a real anomaly in the way Scottish
MPs vote on English
matters - but it is only one of countless anomalies in our electoral system, and they all need to be addressed together as part of a new constitutional settlement.
If Parliament
votes on a
matter agreed as a «non party political»
vote, where no party has a policy
on the
matter, the system of
MPs party
vote values does not apply.
The party leadership wants to accompany enhanced devolution for Scotland with a new rule that Scottish
MPs can not
vote on matters that only affect people in England.
But their caveat about Welsh
MPs remaining free to
vote on matters that do have implications for Wales touches
on the difficult issue (which the manifesto does not talk about explicitly).
«Why should Scottish
MPs be able to
vote on what is taught in English schools, to reduce spending
on English hospitals, or even vary English or Welsh income taxes, when under the new settlement English or Welsh
MPs would have no say in such
matters in Scotland?»
The Tory Party Chairman has said it «can't be right» for Scottish
MPs to
vote on English
matters if powers are devolved across the border.
The report will now go to Ipsa for consideration without
MPs themselves being able to
vote on the
matter.
Meanwhile, as part of his proposals for a «new and fair» constitutional settlement, David Cameron has pledged that English
matters will only be
voted on by English
MPs, a proposal that could effectively undermine a future Labour majority in the House of Commons.
Last month Cameron played straight into Nicola Sturgeon's hands by threatening, rather oafishly, to somehow prevent the SNP's
MPs voting on English - only
matters.
Many Conservatives feel this just doesn't provide a satisfactory answer to the West Lothian Question, which sees Scottish
MPs vote on English
matters but English
MPs prevented from having a say
on issues affecting Scotland.
«There is a feeling that England is at a disadvantage, and that it's not right that
MPs representing the devolved nations should be able to
vote on matters affecting England.
Critics of devolution often cite the West Lothian question, which refers to the
voting power of non-English
MPs on matters affecting only England in the UK Parliament.
When the
MPs resumed sitting
on the
matter on Wednesday, the approval was done through a voice
vote, giving Finance Minister Seth Terkper the green light to go back to the international market to issue another Eurobond.
As such, the formation of a coalition government
on English - only legislation was a consequence of the ability of Scottish
MPs to
vote on English
matters but English
MPs unable to
vote on Scottish
matters.
He asked delegates whether they thought Scottish
MPs should be banned, or not, from
voting in Westminster
on matters that only affect England.
Cameron is clear that Scotland can have these powers but they will need to be accompanied by balancing reforms elsewhere, in particular provisions to ensure that
MPs for non-English seats can not
vote on matters only impacting England.
It has defeated the Lords
on a number of issues, giving
MPs the chance to
vote again
on key
matters.
He rejected the idea of only allowing English
MPs to
vote on English
matters, saying that would create two classes of
MPs.
The proposals will, ministers say, address the long - standing anomaly - known as the West Lothian Question - by which Scottish
MPs can
vote on issues such as health and education affecting England, but the House of Commons has no say
on similar
matters relating to Scotland, where such policies are devolved.
«It is the combination of the two proposals — to devolve 100 % of income tax and then to remove the right of Scottish
MPs to
vote on the
matter at Westminster — that is absolutely lethal for the constitution.
«What makes for a lethal cocktail
on this is that the Conservative party wants to devolve 100 % of income tax to the Scottish parliament and then immediately end the right of Scottish
MPs to
vote on income tax
on a
matter as substantial as the budget in this parliament of the UK.
But, following cross-party agreement that Scotland should be handed sweeping new powers, party leaders are now under intense pressure to bar Scottish
MPs from
voting on purely English
matters at Westminster.
She insisted SNP
MPs would be prepared to
vote on English
matters, such as the NHS and education — breaking the party's previous commitment not to
vote on issues which are controlled by the Scottish Parliament.