Additional benefits of
this observational system include improvements in weather forecasting, marine resource management, and maritime navigation.
But it's important to note that the NCEP re-analysis and other re-analyses (e.g. ERA40) are not regarded as being appropriate for trend studies due to changes in
observational systems (new satellites coming in etc).
Although, whether in fact the systems have actually been reformed is also of debate in that states are still using many of the same
observational systems they were using prior (i.e., not the «binary checklists» exaggerated in the original as well as this report, albeit true in the case of the district of focus in this study).
In fact, one
observational system of which I am aware (i.e., the TAP System for Teacher and Student Advancement) is marketing its proprietary system, using as a primary selling point figures illustrating (with text explaining) how clients who use their system will improve their prior «Widget Effect» results (i.e., yielding such normal curves; see Figure below, as per Jerald & Van Hook, 2011, p. 1).
Accordingly, this report was widely publicized given the assumed improbability that only 1 % of America's public school teachers were, in fact, ineffectual, and given the fact that such ineffective teachers apparently existed but were not being identified using standard teacher evaluation /
observational systems in use at the time.
Disaggregated student performance and behavior data, reading plan, strategic plan, school improvement plans, professional learning needs, assessment data, and data from the district's educator
observational system were used to design a continuous, flexible professional development program.
She also notes that if her system contradicts teachers» value - added scores, this too should «raise red flags» about the quality of the teacher, although she does not (in this article) pay any respect or regard for the issues not only inherent in value - added measures but also
her observational system.
He did not, however, testify as to how value - added output gave him this information, as the information about which he spoke was primarily about
the observational system now in place, and the conversations surrounding such data, although districts also used similar observational systems prior.
Researchers, as situated in the federal context surrounding these systems (including more than $ 4 billion now released to 19 states via Race to the Top and now 43 NCLB waivers also granted), examined
the observational systems, rather than the VAMs themselves, as these observational systems typically accompany the VAM components in these (oft - high - stakes) systems.
For all DC teachers, this is
THE observational system used, and for 83 % of them these data are weighted at 75 % of their total «worth» (Dee & Wyckoff, 2013, p. 10).
Researchers do note, however, that «improvements are needed» if such
observational systems are to carry the weight for which they are currently being tasked, again provided the above and their findings below:
In this case,
observational systems were the only real «hard data» available for the other 78 % of teachers across school sites.
If interested, see the Review of Article # 1 — the introduction to the special issue here; see the Review of Article # 2 — on VAMs» measurement errors, issues with retroactive revisions, and (more) problems with using standardized tests in VAMs here; see the Review of Article # 3 — on VAMs» potentials here; and see the Review of Article # 4 — on
observational systems» potentials here.
While in the conclusions section of this article authors stretch this finding out a bit, writing that «Overall, this study finds that there is promise in teacher evaluation reform in Chicago,» (p. 114) as primarily based on their findings about «the new observation process» (p. 114) being used in CPS, recall from the Review of Article # 4 prior (i.e., # 4 of 9 on
observational systems» potentials here), these
observational systems are not «new and improved.»
If interested, see the Review of Article # 1 — the introduction to the special issue here; see the Review of Article # 2 — on VAMs» measurement errors, issues with retroactive revisions, and (more) problems with using standardized tests in VAMs here; see the Review of Article # 3 — on VAMs» potentials here; see the Review of Article # 4 — on
observational systems» potentials here; see the Review of Article # 5 — on teachers» perceptions of observations and student growth here; see the Review of Article (Essay) # 6 — on VAMs as tools for «egg - crate» schools here; see the Review of Article (Commentary) # 7 — on VAMs situated in their appropriate ecologies here; and see the Review of Article # 8, Part I — on a more research - based assessment of VAMs» potentials here and Part II on «a modest solution» provided to us by Linda Darling - Hammond here.
See, for example, Table 1 on p. 98 of the article to see if what they have included within the list of components of such new and «complex, elaborate teacher observation systems systems» is actually new or much different than most of
the observational systems in use prior.
If interested, see the Review of Article # 1 — the introduction to the special issue here; see the Review of Article # 2 — on VAMs» measurement errors, issues with retroactive revisions, and (more) problems with using standardized tests in VAMs here; see the Review of Article # 3 — on VAMs» potentials here; see the Review of Article # 4 — on
observational systems» potentials here; see the Review of Article # 5 — on teachers» perceptions of observations and student growth here; see the Review of Article (Essay) # 6 — on VAMs as tools for «egg - crate» schools here; and see the Review of Article (Commentary) # 7 — on VAMs situated in their appropriate ecologies here; and see the Review of Article # 8, Part I — on a more research - based assessment of VAMs» potentials here.
Rather, these are the same
observational systems that, given their levels of subjectivity featured and highlighted in reports like «The Widget Effect» (here), brought us to our now (over) reliance on VAMs.
But to suggest that because these observational indicators (artificially) correlate with teachers» value - added scores at «weak» and «very weak» levels (see Notes 1 and 2 below), that this means that
these observational systems might «add» more «value» to the summative sides of teacher evaluations (i.e., their predictive value) is premature, not to mention a bit absurd.
Directly related to the Review of Article # 4 prior (i.e., # 4 of 9 on
observational systems» potentials here), these researchers found that Chicago teachers are, in general, positive about the evaluation system, primarily given the system's observational component (i.e., the Charlotte Danielson Framework for Teaching, used twice per year for tenured teachers and that counts for 75 % of teachers» evaluation scores), and not given the inclusion of student growth in this evaluation system (that counts for the other 25 %).
Likewise,
these observational systems have not really changed since 2009, or 1999 for that matter and not that they could change all that much; but, they are not in their «early stages» (p. 2) of development.
After I posted about «
Observational Systems: Correlations with Value - Added and Bias,» a blog follower, associate professor, and statistician named Laura Ring Kapitula (see also a very influential article she wrote on VAMs here) posted comments on this site that I found of interest, and I thought would also be of interest to blog followers.
But it's important to note that the NCEP re-analysis and other re-analyses (e.g. ERA40) are not regarded as being appropriate for trend studies due to changes in
observational systems (new satellites coming in etc).
It's not just
the observational systems, but also the fact that we often can identicfy in weather forecasts (model simulations) conditions that are favourale for such storms, so that we know in advance when too keep a watchful eye.
It provides an operational framework for integrating and enhancing
the observational systems of participating countries and organizations into a comprehensive system focused on the requirements for climate issues.
Gavin Schmidt's expositions are just that, reflecting his belief system, modeled to be sure, just not integrated into
any observational system.
In 2004
an observational system was put in place to provide the first continuous measure of the AMOC (Cunningham et al., 2007).
Pekka, now that we have better
observational systems and nature was kind enough to gives us a weak sun we should be able to do better attributions.
This is usually done by evaluating climate model data only where and when observations are available, in order to mimic
the observational system and avoid possible biases introduced by changing observational coverage.
Advancements have led to improved assessment methods (i.e., diagnostic interviews,
observational systems, child - report assessments, psychophysiological tests) that reduce sole reliance on parent reports and increase diagnostic validity and reliability.
More research is needed to improve integration of data from
observational systems, clinical interviews, child - report assessments and measures of child and family impairment.
Families completed questionnaire data and participated in problem - solving interactions, which were coded using a microsocial
observational system.
Not exact matches
While they are theoretically predicted to surround giant planets at birth, there has been little
observational evidence to date for circumplanetary disks outside the solar
system.
Moon et al. used an innovative
observational and modeling method to produce a freshwater flux budget for the Helheim - Sermilik glacier - fjord
system in Greenland.
Currently extensive
observational programs are being developed all over the world, with the aim to detect planets outside our solar
system that are able to accommodate life — a sheer impossible task.
THE AUTHORS REPLY: Farson is right that analogues to our solar
system can not be discovered yet, given the limitations of our current
observational techniques.
The new findings are
observational evidence supporting the idea that icy bodies are also present in other planetary
systems, and have survived throughout the history of the star's evolution.
And if
observational astronomers were able to identify a few dozen of the sun's relatives, Portegies Zwart says, it would bring a sea change in our understanding of how the solar
system formed and evolved.
Recently, Narayan and his colleagues found the most direct
observational evidence of this process: they identified four star
systems where radiation seems to be disappearing into the maw of a black hole.
Co-author of the study Professor Ian Hall, from the School of Earth and Ocean Sciences, said: «Our results highlight the challenge of basing our understanding of the climate
system on generally short
observational records.
The new postulate relates quantum theory to
observational facts but does not directly concern the tested microscopic
system.
Although many
observational efforts aimed at understanding planetary -
system formation have been made, this study is novel in focusing on the chemical change.
Someday in the coming years, if astronomers finally succeed in locating a virtual Earth twin outside the solar
system — a tiny dot of a world at a temperate, life - enabling distance from a sunlike star — the achievement will hardly be cause for resting on
observational laurels.
This «
observational intensity» suggested diagnosis is not solely an attribute of underlying disease burden, but could also reflect how often patients encounter the health care
system.
Discounting false positive sources based on
observational or instrumental artifacts or produced by statistically possible coincidences of noise - features in low - amplitude detections, such sources are all related to eclipsing
systems.
«We're looking forward to longer - term results to come in the next five years from various ongoing
observational studies,» Dr. Arterburn said: The Utah Obesity Study, the Michigan Bariatric Surgery Collaborative, and large cohorts from Veterans Affairs health
system and the HMO Research Network (including Group Health) and should yield important long - term information comparing the efficacy, safety, and costs of surgical and non-surgical care for severe obesity.
This session examined the biogeochemical processes that are likely to affect the evolution of the Earth
system over the coming decades, with a focus on the dynamics of marine and terrestrial ecosystems and the development of improved understanding through (a) fieldwork and laboratory experiments, (b) development of new
observational datasets, both modern and palaeo, and (c) simulations using numerical models.
By combining
observational data from OGLE and Hubble, astronomers have been able to work out the nature of the star
system, which is located around 8,000 light - years away, to great precision The star
system consists of two red dwarfs orbiting one another only 7 million miles apart (as a comparison, this is only 14 times the Earth - moon distance).
At NSF, we are funding research into the
observational characterization of planetary properties, measurements and models of exoplanet atmospheres, and the theory of the formation and evolution of planetary
systems.
Dr. Paul Anthony Wilson +
Observational Astronomer + Interested in + Exoplanets + Planetary
Systems + Exocomets + Brown Dwarfs