Gershoff reports that Straus and Stewart (1999) found that 94 % of American
parents spank their children by the ages of 3 or 4.
While it may be that corporal punishment leads to decreased aggression, it is also technically possible that decreased aggression in children leads parents to spank (perhaps
parents spank because the children are not aggressive enough?)
New research finds that
parents spank or hit more often and for more mundane reasons than researchers previously thought.
[George W. Holden, Paul A. Williamson and Grant W. O. Holland, Eavesdropping on the family: A pilot investigation of corporal punishment in the home] Previous studies using parental self - reports have estimated that
parents spank about 18 times per year.
The child welfare system is more likely to intervene in households in «less neighborly» neighborhoods and in which
parents spank their kids, a new study shows.
So why do
parents spank their children, if it is risky and harmful to kids?
Yeah
some parents spank their children because of those reasons but not every parent that does it.
After reading the responses to the article Should
Parents Spank Their Children?
However, it was reported that as may as 90 % of
parents spank their children.
Many
parents spank only as a last resort and say they feel horrible about it afterward.
When
parents spank, it «works» because the kids are scared of the parent.
Many
parents spank because they are exasperated with their child's behavior and want it to stop but don't know what else to do.
Sometimes
parents spank their children out of desperation.
Another common reason
parents spank is out of exasperation.
While it may be that corporal punishment leads to decreased aggression, it is also technically possible that decreased aggression in children leads parents to spank (perhaps
parents spank because the children are not aggressive enough?)
Gershoff reports that Straus and Stewart (1999) found that 94 % of American
parents spank their children by the ages of 3 or 4.
I just wanted to point out that many
parents spank, not because they can not control their temper, but because they have thoughtfully decided that it is an effective way to discipline their children.
In the fundamentalist church of my childhood,
parents spanked their children until the «will was broken.»
I suppose it is possible that love and violence can coexists, such as when
a parent spanks a son or daughter to discipline them.
These aren't the ones that say, «Oh,
my parents spanked me and look how awesome I turned out ``.
What that means is that the more
a parent spanks a child, the more likely he or she is to cross over into abusing his or her child.
My parents spanked me and we spanked out children when they were small and unable to reason about natural consequences now that they are somewhat older, we have more or less stopped.
Grandparents and even older parents whose
parents spanked them appropriately indicate they remember the experience, and as a result, effectively learned to not repeat the same inappropriate child action again.
And, if
your parents spanked you on occasion but you adamantly oppose it with your child, don't just assume the child's grandparents will just know your position.
Kelly said, «
My parents spanked me and I did fine in life and I feel fine about it.
But in recent years, widely circulated videos of
parents spanking or striking their children with repeated blows have sparked angry public debates about the practice.
I was raised in the era where it seemed
all parents spanked - or used the belt as my father did.
Before that time if you were bitten by a dog
your parents spanked you because you must have done something to agitate the dog.
Today, I invite you to accept my humble invitation to participate in the third annual Peaceful
Parenting No Spank Challenge, hosted by Amy Bryant of Parenting Beyond Punishment -LSB-...]
Not exact matches
Fewer rescuers than non-rescuers reported being slapped,
spanked, kicked, and beaten or having their hair pulled by
parents; 3) Many more non-rescuers than rescuers perceived punishment as gratuitous — a cathartic release of aggressiveness by
parents; and 4) Rescuers most frequently used the word explained to describe parental approaches to correction and discipline.
I'm always frustrated by the conflation of «
spanking» with the idea of discipline as if there is no other way to
parent a child than hitting them.
The ties between Christianity and corporal punishment are so strong that a large number of conservative Christians
parents simple deny studies that suggest
spanking does more harm than good.
To achieve this,
parents started
spanking their babies at 6 months old.
This is a record of a child, odd and difficult from birth, in the grip of senseless obsessions, controlling the family with rigid rules and prohibitions, tearing through the house as fast and destructive as a tornado, grunting instead of talking, unresponsive to his
parents» loving concern, their urging, coaxing, their vain attempts at discipline, their anger and
spanking.
Is a
parent a monster for having a child when the
parent knows that the child will not be perfect and will have to be taught and disciplined (perhaps with the violence of a
spanking).
You're told to shake hands with strangers your
parents meet, and if you refuse, you're probably going to be
spanked for being rude and disobedient.
How
parents gave me permission to
spank their kids if I needed to when I babysat, how other
parents promised to come straight home from their prescribed weekly date night and
spank their kids if they gave me any trouble.
Burns played the stern
parent — pulling ears, administering verbal
spankings — and the Baby B's added 30 points to their NHL - worst 1996 - 97 total of 61.
Ultimately I believe every
parent needs to decide what works best for their children and their family, but to imply — as the «Likey» did on Facebook — that if you
spank your child he / she is not going to go to jail, that just seems ridiculous.
Not only b / c it glorifies
spanking, but because of the judgment in blatantly makes about
parents who DO N'T
spank their children.
Further, I agree with Sarah who mentioned the judgment passed on
parents that don't
spank — as if they are responsible for the dregs of society.
do the children of
parents who use controlled
spanking accept their punishment and offer up their hand or rear to be swatted?
This gave me a chuckle, because I've had
parents in our area say the same thing about me — but they
spank and I no longer do.
I completely agree that
spanking should never be done if the
parent is in a temper, and I think that most people who resort to
spanking do so in a damaging way.
Like I said earlier, ultimately it is up to the
parent to decide the best way to discipline his / her child, but there are alternatives to
spanking for those who desire them.
I've raised my voice and not always
parented the way I planned to but I can not imagine a situation where I'd ever conceive
spanking a 1 - year - old — especially more than twice per week on average!
On the Attachment
Parenting Blog API Speaks, Sarah wrote about the one and only time her now 7 - year - old son was
spanked (back when he was 18 months old and by the hand of her mother - in - law) in her post His Only
Spank.
I am by no means a perfect
parent (if such a thing even exists) and I've definitely felt the urge to
spank my kids on occasion.
(Speaking of nonviolent
parenting, I found it interesting to learn that in Sweden it is against the law to
spank a child.)
Some people have the mistaken idea that a
parent who does not
spank simple lets their kids run wild without correcting or guiding them.