Ronald K. Hambleton, University of Massachusetts at Amherst, How Can We Make NAEP and
State Test Score Reporting Scales and Reports More Understandable?
Not exact matches
After months of aggressive advocacy explicitly aimed at protecting and growing the
state's charter sector, the group sent out a
report detailing
test scores at some of New York City's worst district schools.
The NY Post says the teachers union «broke» the governor, thanks to
reports that he plans to abandon the effort to use student
scores on
state tests to help judge teacher performance.
The
report is the latest step in the
state's retreat from the Common Core school standards, national benchmarks that New York adopted in 2010, and especially from using student
test scores in teacher evaluations.
7:15 pm: Juan asks DioGuardi: The NYC Department of Education is poised to release to the public in the coming weeks Teacher Data
Reports, which are based on student
scores on
state tests.
That
report's recommendations, many of which were adopted into
state law and regulations, included a ban on
state testing for students before third grade and a restriction against including
scores from new Common Core
tests on students» permanent records.
The latest round of
state standardized academic test scores showed gains both across New York State and locally.But rather than celebrate the largest bump since New York adopted new tests tied to the Common Core Learning Standards, education officials reported the increases with cau
state standardized academic
test scores showed gains both across New York
State and locally.But rather than celebrate the largest bump since New York adopted new tests tied to the Common Core Learning Standards, education officials reported the increases with cau
State and locally.But rather than celebrate the largest bump since New York adopted new
tests tied to the Common Core Learning Standards, education officials
reported the increases with caution.
The
state was prepared to use part of its federal Race to the Top money to pay Wireless Generation to develop software to track student
test scores, achievement and so on, creating a system similar to the Achievement
Reporting and Innovation System, or ARIS, that it developed for the city schools.
Requiring private schools that receive public money to
report student
test scores improves academic achievement and ultimately enhances school choice, a Michigan
State University scholar argues.
Drawing from math
test scores from PISA 2009 in which the United
States performed lower than the OECD average, the
report argues that while demand for STEM labor is predicted to increase over the next few decades, a shortage of STEM labor in the United
States, along with inadequate performance in science, math, and reading compared to other countries, endangers U.S. future competitiveness and innovation.
then it's going to be tough for a single «
score report» from a distant
state test administered months earlier to convince us otherwise.
The measures used in the NEPC
report — whether schools make AYP,
state accountability system ratings, the percentage of students that
score proficient on
state tests, and high - school graduation rates — are at best rough proxies for the quality of education provided by any school.
The NEPC
report paints a dismal picture of student learning at K12 - operated schools, but the fatal flaw of the
report is that the measures of «performance» it employs are based primarily on outcomes such as
test scores that may reveal more about student background than about the quality of the school, and on inappropriate comparisons between virtual schools and all schools in the same
state.
«Nearly all
states are building high - tech student data systems to collect, categorize and crunch the endless gigabytes of attendance logs,
test scores and other information collected in public schools,»
reported the New York Times in a front - page story last May, confirming the scope of the trend.
In a significant concession,
states would not be required to
report scores for those students taking the field
test.
NCLB required
states to
test ELLs and
report their subgroup
scores, increasing pressure on schools to move students to English fluency and raise reading and math
scores.
He contends that it is «abundantly clear» that Florida's aggregate
test -
score improvements are a mirage caused by changes in the students enrolled in the 4th grade after the
state began holding back a large number of 3rd - grade students in 2004 (all school years are
reported by the year in which they ended).
To Florida's list of reforms, more about which here, I'd add one more:
States should ensure that
test score reports actually reach parents.
The
report in question, authored by Arizona
State University researchers Audrey Amrein and David Berliner, purported to examine student - performance trends on national exams in
states where legislators have attached «high stakes» to
test scores.
Test scores in many of America's urban school districts are inching upward at rates that often outpace those of their
states as a whole, according to a
report released here last week by a national advocacy group for city schools.
Each
state's
score (averaged across the
tests in math and reading in the 4th and 8th grades) is
reported in months of learning, compared to an overall average adjusted
score of zero.
But can it possibly be true, as
reported in his recent post, that the Regents and the New York
State Department of Education went to court with the teachers union over whether
test scores would count as 20 percent or 40 percent of a teacher's annual evaluation?
And, as if to rebut Ravitch directly, Kemple
reported that «the improvement trend continues even taking into account New York
state's recent recalibration of
test scores.»
Additionally, two
states — Florida and Wisconsin — had yet to
report test -
score performances at the time the data for this
report were prepared.
The council's Beating the Odds VI
report, a city - by - city analysis of student performance, recently revealed that urban students»
scores on
state assessments in reading and math as well as on the more rigorous federal
test — the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)-- are rising, with urban students making the most gains in mathematics.
States should
report how a school's
test scores and
test -
score gains compare with the
scores and gains of demographically similar schools across the
state and locally.
The
report, conducted by the Center on Education Policy, a Washington - based research organization that tracks implementation of the federal law, found that schools and districts are better aligning instruction and
state standards, that
test scores are rising, and that the number of schools labeled «in need of improvement» is holding steady.
Virginia's Maggie Walker Governor's School eases «brain drain» angst by
reporting each student's
test scores to his or her «home school,» where they get included in the school's
state report card.
The
reports show educators at all levels struggling to implement a dramatic and extremely complex change in federal education policy, which radically alters the role of federal and
state governments while imposing unprecedented responsibilities and accountability for
test score gains.
Student
scores on basic - skills
tests have improved in 12 of 17 New Jersey schools experimenting with the «effective schools» program, according to a new
state report.
The GAO's
report estimates that the total cost to
states of developing, administering,
scoring, and
reporting tests of the type currently administered would have been $ 442 million in fiscal year 2003, or roughly $ 9 per student
tested.
For each school,
states must
report their standardized
test scores, college entrance exam
scores, graduation rates, and student attendance.
Using the
state test data and the full randomized sample, the evaluators
report negative impacts for reading, math, and science
scores at the end of third grade for children assigned to TVPK.
The
state publishes school
report cards containing student - achievement data and assigns ratings to schools based, in part, on
test scores.
• Two
states had yet to
report test scores for 2015 at the time of the preparation of the data for this article: Florida and Wisconsin.
In fact,
state - and district - level evaluation systems that incorporate
test -
score growth also typically
report test -
score levels and include them in schools» overall ratings.
On the Nation's
Report Card's main
tests, 4th and 8th grade reading and math
scored gains in 49 of 50
states.
In this
report, we use 2007
test -
score information to evaluate the rigor of each
state's proficiency standards against the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), an achievement measure that is recognized nationally and has international credibility as well.
In a study first
reported in the Brookings Institution's Brown Center
Report on American Education in September 2000, we compared the
test scores of Blue Ribbon schools with those of an average school in several
states.
And California's
state testing system will not
report scores next year because of the transition to Common Core standards, which will make it even harder to track progress.
Notes: • We
report ACT or SAT
scores only if they are a
state's only mandated high school
test.
States already
report how many students
score at multiple levels on their
tests, usually in the categories «below basic,» «basic,» «proficient» and «advanced.»
In the
state's annual
reports on
test score gains, the researcher has repeatedly taken note of the lower average income for scholarship students.
While NAEP, the Nation's
Report Card,
scores are the gold standard for measuring student achievement and serve as a yardstick for
state comparisons, NAEP results are generally not known by students and their families, who rely on their
state test results to know how they are performing.
The legislation also, as Layton
reported, «require
states to intervene with «evidence - based» programs in schools where student
test scores are in the lowest 5 percent, where achievement gaps are greatest, and in high schools where fewer than two - thirds of students graduate on time.»
The Hechinger
Report, USA TODAY and several other news outlets partnered to investigate the standardized
test scores of millions of students in six
states and the District of Columbia.
The law required that
states report more than just average
test scores.
In some
states, schools must
report the
test scores only to parents.
Since it was one of the first
states to
report Common Core results, New York's
test scores made news across the country.
Of particular interest are the
report's points about the variation in
state cut
scores for licensure
tests (like Praxis), the need for smarter recruitment efforts for potential school leaders, and the teacher - prep path taken by Finland.