Student achievement tests as tools of educational policy: Practices and consequences.
Not exact matches
In contrast, parents who value a performance orientation, focus on their
student's
achievement as mainly measured by grades and
test scores — the need to score better than others in order to succeed.
«Two days of
testing is a natural next step,
as long
as the assessments continue to cover the material needed to truly measure every
student's strengths and challenges, and the changes are implemented carefully and with the input of educators and communities,» High
Achievement New York, which advocates for higher standards, said in a statement.
Betty Rosa, the Regents chancellor and a former New York City school administrator, noted the current evaluation law has created a situation under which teachers in fields not covered by state
tests, such
as physical education, often find themselves rated on the basis of
student achievement in areas that are
tested, such
as English and math.
«Over the past decade we've been able to identify a growing number of educational interventions that have managed to have notable impacts on
students» academic
achievement as measured by standardized
tests,» West says.
The public release of these ratings — which attempt to isolate a teacher's contribution to his or her
students» growth in math and English
achievement,
as measured by state
tests — is one important piece of a much bigger attempt to focus school policy on what really matters: classroom learning.
Test - based incentive programs,
as designed and implemented in the programs that have been carefully studied, have not increased
student achievement enough to bring the United States close to the levels of the highest achieving countries.
Results of the study indicate that LTTA
students perform better on math computation and estimation (
as measured by the Canadian
Achievement Test, CAT · 3) compared to
students in similar non-LTTA schools.
For instance, in an April 28, 2004, column, Winerip described a school in Florida
as unfairly penalized by NCLB, but he failed to mention that the school reported low overall
test scores and had significant
achievement gaps between white and minority
students.
While the word «accountability» never appears in Risk, its call for higher academic standards and its focus on
student achievement as the main barometer of quality laid the intellectual groundwork for the rigorous curricula and
tests envisioned by the promoters of standards - based -LSB-...]
As the Department of Education's research chief, Sharon Robinson watched almost 5 percent of her office's budget go to the Educational
Testing Service to write and analyze a
student -
achievement test in 45 states.
In its report, Incentives and
Test - Based Accountability in Education, the committee says that NCLB and state accountability systems have been so ineffective at lifting
student achievement that accountability
as we know it should probably be dropped by federal and state governments alike.
Tenth - grade earth science
students who engaged in PBL earned higher scores on an
achievement test as compared to
students who received traditional instruction (Chang, 2001).
After years of stagnation in the late 1980s and early 1990s,
achievement began to rise again in the late «90s — particularly in the earlier grades and most notably in math —
as states set new academic standards, started
testing their
students regularly, and installed their own versions of «consequential accountability» systems.
Second, math and reading
achievement tests are not designed to capture what we expect
students to learn in other subjects, such
as science, history, and art.
Coleman found that variation in school resources (
as measured by per - pupil spending and
student - to - teacher ratios) was unrelated to variation in
student achievement on standardized
tests.
In Australia, for example, writing is included
as one of four core areas assessed in the nationwide
tests of
student achievement (National Assessment Program — Literacy and Numeracy [NAPLAN]-RRB-, and
students are expected to know how to write within diverse creative, informative, and persuasive genres.
Since the 1970s, policymakers have relied on
test - based accountability (TBA)
as a primary tool for improving
student achievement and for reducing racial and socioeconomic
achievement gaps.
Who is most likely to be willing to abandon control over their admissions, accept tiny voucher amounts
as payment in full for serving the lowest achieving
students, and be willing to take the state
achievement tests?
Importantly, the schools attended by
students in our sample include both open - enrollment public schools operated by the local school district and five over-subscribed charter schools that have been shown to have large, positive impacts on
student achievement as measured by state math and English language arts
tests.
As with many other successful data - driven schools, at Elm City the work begins before school starts, when teachers and principals — both Dale Chu, who heads up the elementary grades, and Marc Michaelson, who oversees the middle school — use a variety of diagnostic
tests to understand the ability and
achievement levels of their incoming
students.
To the extent the program involves
student achievement, it bases awards on «
student learning objectives»
as «created by individual teachers, with the approval of site - based administrators»; these objectives «will be measured by a combination of existing assessment instruments, and teacher designed tools,»
as well
as by state standardized
tests.
Students who attend middle schools at risk of dropping out of high school As compared to students in K - 8 elementary schools, middle school students also score lower on achievemen
Students who attend middle schools at risk of dropping out of high school
As compared to
students in K - 8 elementary schools, middle school students also score lower on achievemen
students in K - 8 elementary schools, middle school
students also score lower on achievemen
students also score lower on
achievement tests.
In implementing READS, districts must adopt a set of data use strategies that inform decision - making and help to improve
student achievement, such
as examining spring to fall
achievement gains or losses and using the results of
student surveys and
achievement tests to select books that are well matched to
students» reading skills and interests.
Amrein and Berliner concluded,
as announced in their press release, «High - stakes
tests may inhibit the academic
achievement of
students, not foster their academic growth.»
As is well known, the economic benefits of a college education have risen dramatically during the past quarter century, and substantial evidence shows that
students with good grades or high scores on
achievement tests tend to pursue more education.
The K - 20 EDW includes detailed enrollment, demographic, and program participation information for each
student,
as well
as reading and math
achievement test scores.
Recalling that black
students have the lowest scores on both the reading and math
tests, one can see that these results can be interpreted
as the effects of peer
achievement.
The
achievement gap between middle - school
students and K — 8
students is put in stark relief in Figure 1, which displays our estimates of the impact of attending a middle school on
student achievement as measured by standardized
tests in math and English Language Arts.
In the 2001 reauthorization of ESEA
as the No Child Left Behind Act, states were required to
test students in grades 3 — 8 and disaggregate results based on
student characteristics to make
achievement gaps visible.
In the specific year when
students move to a middle school (or to a junior high), their academic
achievement,
as measured by standardized
tests, falls substantially in both math and English relative to that of their counterparts who continue to attend a K — 8 elementary school.
In Phase 2 Validation, the evaluator will a) conduct an experimental
test of the cumulative effects (across 2 summers) of the most cost - effective version of READS (CE READS) in
as many
as 10 school districts, and b) compare
achievement growth in the summer and school year for
students who received CE READS and
students who did not receive READS.
By way of comparison, the authors note that the impact of being assigned to a teacher in the top - quartile rather than one in the bottom quartile in terms of their total effect on
student achievement as measured by
student -
test - based measures of teacher effectiveness is seven percentile points in reading and six points in math.
Our data on
student achievement come from the Washington State Assessment of Student Learning, a statewide test given annually in 3rd through 8th grade as well as in 10th
student achievement come from the Washington State Assessment of
Student Learning, a statewide test given annually in 3rd through 8th grade as well as in 10th
Student Learning, a statewide
test given annually in 3rd through 8th grade
as well
as in 10th grade.
And if the underlying measure of
student achievement in these studies was standardized
tests,
as was surely the case in many of them, why are such
tests acceptable
as measures of teacher quality in studies that are meta - analyzed and used indirectly, but unacceptable when they are used directly to assess teacher quality in a structured research design?
But, unfortunately, evidence from both the United States and other countries shows that more school resources and smaller classes do not have much of an effect on how much a
student learns in school,
as measured by
tests of
achievement.
Student achievement at schools operated by the Bureau of Indian Affairs
as measured by scores on standardized
tests is considerably lower than that of public schools, according to a report by the federal General Accounting Office.
We need to be assured that the scale on which we measure
achievement is one of equal units: one
student's five - point increase on an
achievement test, from 15 to 20, must represent the same gain
as another
student's five - point increase from 25 to 30 (see Figure 1).
As noted earlier, whereas Amrein and Berliner simply compared the
test scores of 4th graders in one year with those of a different set of 4th graders four years later, we measured
students» growth in
achievement between the 4th and 8th grades.
As a result, we
tested the relationship between classroom observations and a teacher's average
student -
achievement gains.
When compared with such crude indicators, the combination of
student achievement gains on state
tests,
student surveys, and classroom observations identified teachers with better outcomes on every measure we
tested: state
tests and supplemental
tests as well
as more subjective measures, such
as student - reported effort and enjoyment in class.
To the extent that the most important staffing decisions involve sanctioning incompetent teachers and rewarding the very best teachers, a principal - based assessment system may affect
achievement as positively
as a merit - pay system based solely on
student test results.
This is important to know because research has shown that teachers» aptitude,
as measured by scores on standardized
tests, significantly affects
student achievement.
In theory, administrators could classify more
students as disabled each year (see Figure 2) and then provide each one with increasingly generous
testing accommodations until a desired level of aggregate
achievement was obtained.
Teachers» average
student -
achievement gains based on such
tests are more volatile from year to year (which translates to lower reliability) and are only weakly related to other measures, such
as classroom observations and
student surveys.
But for Core proponents, the timing couldn't be worse: Just
as states began implementing the new standards, 40 states receiving No Child waivers are also launching new systems to evaluate teachers, which will incorporate some measures of
student achievement, including, where available, scores from standardized
tests.
Her litany of complaints about the academic results of Klein's «radical restructuring» is somewhat familiar — «inflating»
test results and «taking shortcuts» to boost graduation — except for the charge that «the recalibration of the state scores revealed that the
achievement gap among children of different races in New York City was virtually unchanged between 2002 and 2010, and the proportion of city
students meeting state standards dropped dramatically, almost to the same point
as in 2002.»
The costs of extra planning time are offset, however, by significant rewards,
as evidenced by
students» successes and their improved confidence and attitudes,
as well
as their
achievement on standardized
tests.
NCLB, while broadening awareness of the
achievement gap, simultaneously narrowed the purpose of our nation's schools, boiling the whole endeavor down to the incremental movement of
testing numbers
as an attempt to say something about
student literacy and numeracy.
The ideal assessment will be more nuanced, gathering
student data over time but also looking at the small, yet significant improvements in
achievement, such
as higher grades or increased participation in class, which might not be immediately reflected in
students»
test scores.