Not exact matches
«It appears that
TFA alumni candidates running for school boards paid attention to both national and local messages because of a growing recognition that local politics is far from dead,» said Jacobsen, associate professor of
teacher education and lead investigator on the
study.
Prior to coming to the Ed School, Donaldson admits that she never thought about
studying TFA, but, considering her experience as a former
teacher and her sister's participation in
TFA, she became more curious about retention rates among graduates of the organization
The findings might have been strengthened if measures of
teacher ability had been included in the analysis, because the alternatively certified
teachers in the
study, from Teach For America (
TFA) and the NYC Teaching Fellows program, represent high - achieving students from the nation's elite universities.
A September 2013
study from Mathematica Policy Research found that
TFA middle and high school math
teachers outperform other math
teachers in their schools, by the equivalent of students gaining 3 points on a 100 - point test.
EN:
Studies have shown that most
TFA teachers leave the classroom after two to three years.
Across the four cohorts of
teachers included in this
study who completed two years or more of teaching, more than a third of
TFA teachers remained past their commitment.
Our
study examined the performance of
TFA and non-
TFA teachers from two perspectives.
The
study found that students with
TFA teachers attained greater gains in math and equal gains in reading compared with students of other
teachers in the
study, even those with certified
teachers and with veteran
teachers.
Such
teachers need to be included because the purpose of this
study is to compare
TFA teachers with the pool of potential hires available to the district.
As a group, the
studies tend to show that the students of uncertified
TFA recruits underachieve when compared to students of new certified
teachers, but this gap tends to disappear as the
TFA recruits obtain professional knowledge through coursework and certification.
JM: External research has validated
TFA's findings on
teacher effectiveness: a June 2004
study by Mathematica Policy Research found that
TFA teachers perform at least as well as traditionally prepared and certified
teachers in similar schools, while a 2006
study published in Education Next (see Kane, Rockoff, and Staiger, «Photo Finish,» research, Winter 2007) found the same to be true in New York City.
The 2004 Mathematica
study says that «
TFA teachers did not have an impact on average reading achievement.
An extensive PDK
study shows that nearly two - thirds of
TFA teachers continue as public school
teachers beyond their two - year commitment.
North Carolina, Louisiana, and Tennessee all independently concluded that
TFA corps members were the most effective out of recent graduates from other
teacher preparation programs with which they had worked.151 A controlled
study conducted by Mathematica found that students taught by
TFA teachers earned higher math scores than students taught by non-
TFA teachers with similar years of experience; the
TFA - taught students learned approximately 2.6 months of additional material in math during the school year.152 Similarly, another
study found that
TFA first to third grade
teachers» students grew 1.3 additional months in reading compared with their peers who had non-
TFA teachers.153
OMG, the
study that, when you get to the fine print says, «a
TFA «
teacher» will have the same or no worse impact on * student test results * as an education major at the same level of experience as the
TFA» — it is actually not even that nuanced.
The
study offers few clues about what caused the
TFA teachers to do better.
Despite a series of non-peer-reviewed
studies funded by
TFA and other organizations that purport to show benefits of
TFA teachers, peer - reviewed research on their impact continues to produce a mixed picture.
I read an article yesterday about a new
study which «proves» how effective
TFA teachers and
TFA alumni
teachers are.
A 2004 randomized experiment, also by the Washington - based Mathematica, found score boosts among elementary students taught by
TFA teachers, too, but that
study was criticized in part because the control group of
teachers had lower rates of certification, less formal education preparation, and less experience in student - teaching than a national sample.
TFA is among the most
studied teacher - preparation programs in the nation.
An independent
study commissioned by SFUSD in 2012 found that new
TFA teachers had higher ELA (English Language Arts) and Math acceleration scores than other new
teachers, and similar acceleration to veteran
teachers.
Based on this
study of
teacher prep programs, UNC found that
TFA teachers blew away EVERY other cohort.
The same is true for the very mixed results of
studies about the effectiveness of
TFA teachers compared to non-
TFA teachers.
Kopp said «we can philosophize» about better training methods, but cited a recent
study by Mathematica Policy Research that found children taught by
TFA teachers advanced more in math than children taught by veteran
teachers, though they still scored at very low levels.
The
study looked only at middle and high school math
teachers — a small percentage of
TFA's corps.