For example, there are very fine annual seasonal strata that could not have bee laid down all at once, e.g.
Varves in New England, Loess plateau in China.
These encompass tree ring width, density and isotopes, some ice cores, corals, and
varved lake sediments.
Think of Lightsum as a measurement of some physically - real aspect of
a varved sediment series.
Do
Varves, Tree - Rings, and Radiocarbon Measurements Prove an Old Earth?
Carbon - 14 is Do
Varves, Tree - Rings, and Radiocarbon Measurements Prove an Old Earth?
An overview of the main technologies used to date historic structures and their components focusing on dendrochronology, radiocarbon dating and Do
Varves, Tree - Rings, and Radiocarbon Measurements Prove an Old Earth?
It's better that tree rings and lake
varves and ice cores and corals tell similar stories than obsessing over single chronologies.
We report variations in planktonic foraminifera from
varved sediments off southern California spanning the past 1400 years.
The primary series recorded by Tiljander et al. were X-Ray Density,
varve Thickness, and Lightsum.
In their «A Comment on «A statistical analysis...»» (PDF), Schmidt, Mann, and Rutherford mention the Lake Korttajarvi
varved sediment (Tiljander) data series twice.
Lightsum is the portion of
varve thickness contributed by mineral matter.
Thomas P, I havent been privy to
any varve data, but it is an interesting question.
-- isotope and physical analysis of layers in lakes especially those with
varves (annual layers) and in arid areas.
If I were to speculate on what sort of proxies had a chance of succeeding, it would be ones that were based on isotope fractionation or other physical processes with a known monotonic relationship to temperature and away from things like tree ring widths and
varve thicknesses.
This scenario can be tested using
our varve record.»
Because the muds, called
varves, seem to have a strong signal for the pulse of La Nina events, the team realized that cores taken from them could offer insights into the climate's past - and maybe its future - for this part of the world.
«Yes, the sign of the lake
varves «signal» is reversed and maybe it was contaminated as well but as long as the paper was published I can link to it and win the argument.»
Proxies are used by paleoclimatologists and include ice cores, tree rings, lake sediments (
varves), pollen counts, or anything that results from temperature or precipitation changes.
But there is more work to do on the muddy
varves, he concluded.
An early use of rhythmites in climate reconstruction was a specific form called
varves and related to annual sedimentary layers in proglacial lakes.
â $ œRecent temperatures were the warmest since the fourteenth century, but similar conditions existed intermittently during the period spanning ~ 4000â $ «1000
varve years ago.â $ http://www.geo.umass.edu/climate/papers2/cook2008.pdf Data — http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/metadata/noaa-lake-6195.html
The so - called Blytt — Sernander system was soon tied to the archaeology and to
the varve chronology of Gerard De Geer.
I think everyone should be aware that tree rings were used for dating ancient sites and for comparisons with other dating methods —
varve counting comes to mind.
Where billions have been spent of public money on; Dangerous warming as delineated in a Hockey schtick that used upside down data, where the rings from just one tree accounted for 25 % or 30 % of the claimed warming, where observed data was grafted onto tree ring and
varve and other paleo data to give the impression of rapid warming but which grafting was carefully hidden behind other lines in the Hockey stick graph.
«Record 20 was corrected to reflect the interpretation of Tijander et al. (S32) that X-ray density is related inversely to temperature Record 21 was corrected to reflect the interpretation of Haltia - Hovi et al. (S33) that
varve thickness is related inversely to temperature»
Other materials eg corals and macrofossild in
varved lakes are used for older dates because trees are not available.
A record of climate over the last millennium based on
varved lake sediments from the Canadian High Arctic.
Even swifter changes could show up in the clay
varves derived from the layers in the mud of lake beds laid down each year by the spring runoff.
Most telling were studies in the 1930s and 1940s of Scandinavian lakes and bogs, using ancient pollen to find what plants had lived in the region when the layers of clay («
varves») were laid down.
The flipping is done because the increase in
varve thickness due to construction and agricultural activities is interpreted by Mann et al as a «nonlocal statistical relationship» or «teleconnection» to world climate.
Actual interaction with an issue and some community members came in the form of learning about the Lake Korttajarvi
varve series.
If one strays from the fold (e.g. by modifying «
varve series» with «upside - down»), the conversation retreats to the realm of etiquette — snark, justifications for edited and snipped blog comments, and the like.
The issue is not the dendros themselves, or the folks studying
varves, or boreholes, or oxygen isotopes.
Mandelbrot calculates Hurst indices and 3rd and 4 th moments for 12
varve series, 27 tree ring series from western U.S. (no bristlecones), 9 precipitation series, 1 earthquake frequency series, 11 river series and 3 Paleozoic sediment series.
In a small lake with a poorly oxygenated bottom, the presence of laterally continuous laminated sediment that includes well - known periodicities in rhythmite thickness is interpreted as representing annually generated
varves that correspond to seasonal variations in sedimentation.
He looked at the statistics of 9 rainfall series, 12
varve series, 11 river series, 27 tree ring series, 1 earthquake occurrence series, and 3 Paleozoic sediment series.
Much longer records are needed; thus we followed Hurst in looking for very long records among the fossil weather data exemplified by
varve thickness and tree ring indices.
Some sediment cores show
varves, which can be counted for relative age information.
Think of Lightsum as a measurement of some physically - real aspect of
a varved sediment series.
Northeast US precipitation variability and North American climate teleconnections interpreted from late Holocene
varved sediments
There are at least a dozen other proxies: foram mineral composition,
varves, cave deposits, carbon and Be isotopes (indicators of solar activity), ice cores....
The Medieval Warm Period in AD 980-1250 is the most distinctive climate period in the whole sediment sequence identified by changes in sediment colour, X-ray density,
varve thickness, LOI, as well as the isotopic composition of hydrogen in kerogen.
For
the varve usage, it appears that he erred by not having someone who had better understanding of these series and their backgrounds (especially given how critical they end up being to the 1300 no - tree claims, which I agree were prominent in PNAS and a lot of what made that paper additive).
Can you suggest how she was to construct a pre-1720 temperature series, for the portion of
the varve record that was least affected by non-climate local signals?
2)
varves are generally regarded as an accumulation of annual «pairs» of strata, crudely summer and winter
In the case of the Tiljander
varves the only source of a priori knowledge comes from the original Tiljander paper which has never been contested in any literature that I am aware of.
1850 - 1995, the major influences on
the varve series were nearby agricultural activities, roadbuilding and bridge reconstruction, and lake eutrophication.
Can an increase in a Lightsum
varve proxy over time be interpreted to mean Cooling by some authors, while the same trend is interpreted to mean Warming by other authors?