Lynn Price has some wise words
about critique groups.
And here I should issue a general warning
about critique groups.
I could do an entire post just
about critique groups, but I'll cut to the chase.
You're right
about critique groups.
Not exact matches
Fifty years after its first publication, Herberg's
critique of pluralism is still impressive, as are his ideas
about the importance of
group identities and his derision of «the melting pot.»
It provides a good warning to conservatives against falling into the trap of defending the idea of «judicial supremacy» in their
critique of the president's statement
about a «
group» of unelected people striking down a congressional law.
It provides a good warning to conservatives against falling into the trap of defending the idea of «judicial supremacy» in their
critique of the president's statement
about a «
group» of unelected people striking down....
Soft just war theory is characterized by seven key components: a strongly articulated horror of war; a strong presumption against war; a skepticism
about government claims; the use of just war theory as a tool for citizen discernment and prophetic
critique; a pattern of trusting the efficacy of international treaties, multilateral strategies and the perspectives of global peace and human rights
groups and the international press; a quite stringent application of just war criteria; and a claim of common ground with Christian pacifists.
Similarly, when a
group of Christians in the Asian American community recently released a letter detailing some of their concerns
about common stereotypes and prejudices within the evangelical community, I saw many on social media
critique this action as «divisive» and «harmful to Christian unity.»
As a member, you will have exclusive access to my Strength System Facebook
Group where you can connect with myself and other Strength System Athletes to chat
about all things training, including the opportunity to upload your lifting videos, that I will personally
critique and give feedback to ensure you are doing everything correctly.
Considered one of the greatest films ever made, The Rules of the Game (La règle du jeu), by Jean Renoir, is a scathing
critique of corrupt French society cloaked in a comedy of manners in which a weekend at a marquis» country château lays bare some ugly truths
about a
group of haut bourgeois acquaintances.
From there, they'd spend time learning
about how to create a culture of
critique in the classroom, how to successfully facilitate
group work, student presentations, and more.
She shared the writing and illustrations from her insect expert
group and
critiqued her own work: «What I like
about this is the colors because they look beautiful.
After seven years of facilitating
critique groups and working closely with writers from a variety of genres, I have learned a lot
about the steps necessary to achieve success in this very competitive field.
He's gotten feedback on a few chapters from a
critique group, but the revision process can be overwhelming and leave us uncertain
about where to start, so he asked:
If Joyce, or Nabokov, or J.K. Rowling had run all their work through a modern
critique group, frequented online writing forums, attended writing workshops, and absorbed all the (generally) well - intentioned nonsense talked
about beats, the Hero's Journey, plot arcs, adverb use, and character change, it's unlikely they would have ever achieved the fame and status they have today.
June 17, 2014 Jami Gold Writing Stuff advice for writers, beta reader, cause and effect,
critique partners /
groups, editing, Editing Your Story, editors, feedback, Jami Gold, Learn
about Writing, organized, pacing, paranormal author, plot - driven vs. character - driven
While I don't have a writing
critique group, I do have a partner that I swap work with and I think
about these problems a lot.
You can find lots of info
about the craft of writing, market listings, writers»
critique groups, etc. on the Internet.
I've never been a part of a
critique group in the real world, but having used several
critique partners for my books, I know to think
about it when one person says it but really consider making changes only when all or most say it.
My saving grace was I was the only novice and the others in the
group understood that and helped me to figure out how to
critique in a way that allowed the writer to draw his or her own conclusions
about the work.
I've shared this post as well (as your other post
about crit
groups) with my
critique group.
One of my cps had experiences such as you talked
about in a «live»
critique group.
The neat thing
about this
group, of
about 45 - 60 members, is you often received 20 or so short
critiques and then could consider at your leisure what «felt» right and what didn't.
And yes, since we once shared a
critique group, I think you know exactly the kind of
critiques I'm talking
about And oh, don't you hate those perfect Mary Sue characters!
One of the things I like
about an in person
critique group is reading each chapter out loud.
Lida herself says this
about the book: «In these pages you will find writers
groups for support and
critiques, learn how to submit stories to ezines and polish your craft, send submissions via email and locate an e-publisher for your first novel.»
An author's worst fear can be
about getting their work edited or
critiqued by an editor, an agent, or even a
critique group.
We love them, we hate them, we write funny blog posts
about them, but the fact is that a good
critique group can be a writer's best friend with literary benefits.
I hope you'll pass on the word
about Mount Hermon to your
critique group.
Larry Brooks: «Make sure your story comes from a place of passion, that it deals with something important to you, that you have something meaningful to say
about it through your characters, and that isn't remotely a storytelling - by - the - numbers proposition that allows you to meet a
critique group deadline.
I've sat through so many
critique group readings where the only tension is finding out what the % & * @ the author is talking
about.
And all the above is not meant to guilt you into more active membership in your
critique group, or sign up for Colorado Gold tomorrow, but to encourage you to think
about your writing career beyond the page.
-LSB-...] more
about the how, read Jane Friedman on «How to Find the Right
Critique Group or Partner for You.»
This week Anne is over at her book blog talking
about witnessing verbal abuse in a
critique group or workshop.
June 23, 2016 Jami Gold Writing Stuff advice for writers, beta reader,
critique partners /
groups, drafting, editing, feedback, grammar, guest posts, Jami Gold, Julie Glover, Learn
about Writing, pacing, paranormal author, perfectionism, point of view, professionalism, risk, self - doubt, voice
But what
about the ten years of
critique groups, ten years of reading writing craft books, ten years of writers conferences.
I am lucky to have an awesome
critique group I've been working with for
about a year.
I remember writing slowly, I remember taking chapters to
critique group, I remember having no particular thoughts
about publication.
Then I began a second book, and
about the same time, joined my first
critique group.
And I could add to the advice
about producing a quality product before publishing to run your work past some savvy beta readers or a discerning
critique group to catch any parts that drag or are confusing, etc., then it would be best to get a professional edit from a reputable freelance editor who reads and edits your genre.
Here's how I got a reality check
about group critiques: when my first was book accepted by a small press in England, my editor sent it back bleeding with red - pencilled edits.
Yes, I also had read the earlier post
about why we should ignore most of the advice of your
critique group.
I wrote
about why to ignore most of the advice from your
critique group here on the blog in August of 2014.
Yes, there's a great article on edittorrent (a blog run by two editors)
about why agents / editors might not love what your
critique group loves, and one of the reasons it mentions is this same issue.
I especially wanted to thank you for including resources
about beta readers as although I've been part of online and in - person
critiquing groups and continue to be in one, I find there's a lot of demand for something to facilitate easier connections between beta readers and writers.
I've never encountered a rude writer in person, but I was once accidentally copied on an email in which a writer was condescending
about my application to a
critique group.
Having actually finished THREE manuscripts, stories, possible books, future fame and fortune endeavors, I then thought
about edits and rewrites followed by my
critique group.
I no longer have access to a live
critique group, and I've never been able to work up enthusiasm for joining online
groups where I know no one — or more importantly — know nothing
about anyone's writing skills.
I was going to write
about the latest payout numbers from the Kindle Unlimited Program today — and I will get to it shortly — but a member of my
critique group asked a question Sunday that had me sit back and think.