«Only 15 % of the largest
academy chains perform above the national average in terms of progress made by pupils, compared with 44 % of councils, while more than 80 % of maintained schools are rated as «good» or «outstanding» by Ofsted.
Not exact matches
The head of Ofsted, Michael Wilshaw, just last week said many
academy chains were
performing badly and letting down disadvantaged children.
«With more than 80 per cent of council maintained schools currently rated as good or outstanding by Ofsted, and only three of the 20 largest
academy chains viable to take on additional schools, high
performing maintained schools should also be able to sponsor struggling schools, without having to go through
academy status first.
Many
academies, including most of the strongest, are now run by «
chains» — the British version of CMO's — which are also being asked to turn around low -
performing schools.
High -
performing academy chains will also play a huge role in spreading existing best practice and innovation between schools.
The data also revealed that the lowest -
performing chains included many larger trusts, that most secondary trusts with poorer pupils
perform way below average, and that trusts with a mix of
academies seem to
perform better.
And she asked MPs: «What is autonomous about forcing a highly
performing school into an
academy chain?»
This kind of assessment is tricky:
academy chains tend to take on local authority schools that are
performing below the expected level, even when you take their challenging circumstances into account.
Commenting in the story in today's Times that Nicky Morgan is considering letting the best -
performing councils run their own
academy chains.
This year we identified seven out of 39
chains that are
performing significantly above the national average for all mainstream schools (maintained and
academies), for their disadvantaged pupils.
It says that one in five
academy chains is «
performing substantially below the national average for attainment and improvement» for children from poorer families.
Commenting in the story in today's Times that Nicky Morgan is considering letting the best -
performing councils run their own
academy chains, Dr Mary Bousted, general secretary of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), said: