Comment: This is the infamous case that lead to the resignation of multiple editors of the Climate Research journal in protest over a flawed peer review process that
allowed publication of the paper.
Later research into the peer - review process that
allowed the publication of their paper uncovered that Energy and Environment editor - in - chief Sonja Boehmer - Christiansen had rushed the paper into publication for «policy impact reasons, e.g. publication well before COP9.»
Not exact matches
«If the Education Secretary genuinely wishes England to do as well as countries such as Finland, to which he frequently refers in the White
Paper, he should follow its example by replacing the inspection system with school self evaluation, refrain from the
publication of results by school League Tables and the setting
of narrow performance targets and
allow teachers to choose their own method
of teaching reading.
In the realm
of scientific publishing, the Institute funds the continued development
of bioRxiv, a preprint server that
allows researchers to share their biology
papers with each other before
publication.
Consider Science's policy, for example (emphasis added): «Distribution on the Internet may be considered prior
publication and may compromise the originality
of the
paper as a submission to Science, although we do
allow posting
of research
papers on not - for - profit preprint servers such as arixv.org.»
For research
papers created under grants for which the authors are required by their funding agencies to make their research results publicly available (for example, from NIH, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, or Wellcome Trust), we
allow posting
of the accepted version
of research content (Research Articles and Reports) to the funding body's archive or designated repository (such as PubMed Central) no sooner than six months after
publication, provided that a link to the final version
of the
paper published in the Science Journal is included.
For authors who are required by their funding agencies to make their research results publicly available, AAAS
allows posting
of the accepted version
of the
paper to the funding body's archive or designated repository (such as PubMed Central) six months after
publication, provided that a link to the final version published by AAAS is included.
Since the same topics were addressed in different ways in different
papers, the new website, www.nature.com/encode, will
allow anyone to follow a topic through all
of the
papers in the ENCODE
publication set by clicking on the relevant thread at the Nature ENCODE explorer page.
If revisions are a condition
of publication, generally four weeks are
allowed for revisions and only one revised version
of the
paper is considered.
Jonathan's group is preparing a web browser to
allow users to examine selection signals in the data; this browser will be available upon
publication of this second
paper.
The e-Book versions
of the
publications will be released on the same day as the
paper versions
of the
publications * 1,
allowing readers to enjoy a wider lineup
of easily downloadable manga magazines.
The company makes available replica editions
of all
of their Canadian
papers via PressReader, which
allows domestic and international readers read all
of the daily
publications for a low subscription cost.
Breaking with a long tradition in scientific journalism, the authors
allowed a selected group
of reporters to have access to the
paper, provided they signed confidentiality agreements that prevented them from consulting other experts about the research before
publication.
al. (1998) Proxy Data Base and Northern Hemispheric Average Temperature Series,» was published in Energy and Environment (Volume 14, Number 6 / November 2003), a journal that was not carried in the ISI listing
of peer - reviewed journals and whose peer review process has been widely criticized for
allowing the
publication of substandard
papers.
[DC: The «peer review corruption» I am most concerned about is that which
allows publication of deeply flawed
papers from the likes
of lobby group allies like researchers Soon and Baliunas (Climate Research, back in 2003) or McLean et al (GRL, last year).]
Some online journals are
allowing for more lengthy
papers, since they are unbound by the limits
of paper publication.
Minority committee chair Jim Jeffers would create it when he read into the record the startling revelation that fully half
of the editorial board
of Energy and Environment had just resigned in protest over the «failed editorial process» which had
allowed the
publication of such a badly compromised
paper.