That does not strictly justify Clegg in refusing to agree to boundary revisions that are plainly overdue, and were linked to
the alternative vote changes.
Not exact matches
One of the desirable qualities of a
voting system (according to Kenneth Arrow) is independence of irrelevant
alternatives — the introduction of a new candidate shouldn't
change the winner unless it's to that candidate.
They claim boundary
changes was introduced as a quid pro quo for the May 2011 referendum on electoral reform, in which the public rejected the
alternative vote system by a ratio of two
votes to one.
These
alternative faces of Leave were exploited to gain
votes for «
change,» but the exact
change sought by any two voters could be very different.
The reforms were designed to
change the nature of electoral representation (the referendum on the
alternative vote), alter the composition of both Houses of Parliament (boundary review and House of Lords reform), and to reduce the power of the Prime Minister to time elections.
There are certainly several examples in Britain where people have rejected
change, the most prominent examples include the referendums on Scottish Independence, the
Alternative Vote electoral system, and, in 1975, the UK's membership of the European Community.
Having failed to achieve a
change in the
voting system for the House of Commons — with the loss of last year's referendum on the
alternative vote — Nick Clegg's party is determined to push ahead in order that his party can boast having forced a major constitutional
change on the country as a result of being in government.
He faces a more real threat from energy and climate
change secretary Chris Huhne, who has been at the forefront of dissent against the Conservatives» approach to the rejected
alternative vote referendum.
Gordon Brown has briefed the Cabinet on planned constitutional
changes which could see the first - past - the - post
voting system scrapped in favour of
alternative vote (AV).
Constitutional
changes now being embraced by Cameron — fixed - term parliaments, a referendum on the
Alternative Vote (ok not embraced, but put forward)-- are positive.
These were just some of the public responses to the great MPs» expenses scandal, but strangely,
changing the electoral system to bring in the
alternative vote was not high up the list.
Matt Wootton at LeftFootForward is more concerned at the failure of the Left to unite against FPTP: «The referendum on the
Alternative Vote was a once - in - a-lifetime chance to
change politics for the better, and to mainstream red, green and liberal politics, and sideline Conservative.
It's not surprising that they oppose a
change to the
alternative vote system, since an analysis by the BBC shows that such a system would at the last election have given them 27 fewer seats and Labour 21 more.
We now know the date for the referendum when the British public get the opportunity to decide whether we
change from our traditional first - past - the - post (FPTP) electoral system to the
Alternative Vote (AV).
«There are no circumstances in which I would have
voted for a
change to the
alternative voting system without a referendum.
I support this coalition because a hung Parliament makes it necessary, but I would not support
changes to our
voting system that would make hung Parliaments the norm, so although I will loyally
vote to hold a referendum on
changing the
voting system, I will campaign vigorously against the
alternative vote.»
It seems to be taken for granted by a lot of commentators that
changing to the
alternative vote (AV) will be a move towards proportional representation - resulting in more hung parliaments and coalition governments.
But the biggest
change to Germany's political scene was the emergence of the far - right
Alternative for Germany (AfD) party as the country's third biggest political force with 12.6 percent of the
vote.
Jack Straw has said he is not opposed to the idea of the
alternative vote system where people can rank their preferences for MPs, but it is a hardly a radical
change to the way we elect our politicians and the Tory leader David Cameron has said that at least with first past the post you can kick out a government.
«Moving from first - past - the - post to
alternative vote is not a big
change, it's not real reform, it's not proportional representation,» he said.
While not as fundamental a reform as The Independent and other advocates of proportional representation would like, a move to the
Alternative Vote system would still be a landmark
change for a country that has used first - past - the - post since modern elections began.
With Labour now attempting to form its own coalition government, the Conservatives promised the Liberal Democrats a referendum on
changing the
voting mechanism to the
Alternative Vote (AV) system.
The latest YouGov polling shows support for the
Alternative Vote in a referendum on
voting change dropping to 39 %, just one point ahead of... (Comments: 0)
In one of the least noticed
changes, Clegg has been given responsibility for political reform including a bill enabling a referendum on the
alternative vote for electing the Commons.
Back to today the only remedy we have on the table is a referendum to
change the way we
vote from one X on the ballot paper (first past the post) to a series of 1, 2, 3,... preferences for each of the candidates (the
alternative vote).
The 2011 referendum proposing to replace the first - past - the - post (FPTP)
voting system with the
alternative vote (AV) was the culmination of a long process led by political parties and organised pressure groups pushing for
change.
The Liberal Democrats clearly wanted to
change the first - past - the - post system radically, but the compromise to hold a referendum on a merely slightly less majoritarian
Alternative Vote system was too lukewarm a compromise to ignite anyone's passion, let alone that of the electorate.
As for the suggestion that people will
vote for
change, regardless of substance, in preference to the status quo, I refer you to the recent referendum on the
alternative vote.
If a majority backed
change, a new method of
voting called
Alternative Vote (AV) could then be introduced at the election after next.
What was linked was the boundary
changes to last year's referendum on the
Alternative Vote.
We included administrative data from teacher, parent, and student ratings of local schools; we considered the potential relationship between
vote share and test - score
changes over the previous two or three years; we examined the deviation of precinct test scores from district means; we looked at
changes in the percentage of students who received failing scores on the PACT; we evaluated the relationship between
vote share and the percentage
change in the percentile scores rather than the raw percentile point
changes; and we turned to
alternative measures of student achievement, such as SAT scores, exit exams, and graduation rates.
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Members of the Florida Constitution Revision Commission Education Committee today
voted to support a proposal by Commission member Erika Donalds to
change language in the Florida Constitution that will authorize the Legislature to enact general laws providing
alternative processes to authorize the establishment of charter schools.
This includes reviews that are a part of a paid publicity package • Solicitations for helpful
votes Inappropriate content: • Other people's material (this includes excessive quoting) • Phone numbers, postal mailing addresses, and URLs external to Amazon.com • Videos with watermarks • Comments on other reviews visible on the page (because page visibility is subject to
change without notice) • Foreign language content (unless there is a clear connection to the product) Off - topic information: • Feedback on the seller, your shipment experience or the packaging (you can do that at www.amazon.com/feedback and www.amazon.com/packaging) • Details about availability or
alternative ordering and shipping information • Feedback about typos or inaccuracies in our catalog or product description (instead, use the feedback form at the bottom of the product page).
Xenophon, a sitting senator who was re-elected on Saturday, told Guardian Australia he would not
vote for the abolition of the carbon tax until the Coalition's
alternative Direct Action plan had been
changed to ensure it could meet Australia's emission reduction targets.
Similarly, the result of the referendum on an
alternative voting system in 2011 required no
change, but had it been otherwise, it was beyond doubt that
change could have been achieved only by legislation passed by Parliament.