The SALI Club will look to explore the legal landscape and in particular consider the use and effectiveness of International Investment Agreements («IIAs»), in particular, Bilateral Investment Treaties («BITs») executed between Asian and African States giving investors the ability to obtain
arbitration awards which may be enforced against state assets.
Today, a majority of the Supreme Court of Canada upheld
an arbitration award which concluded that a random alcohol testing policy for use in a safety sensitive workplace was not justified.
Not exact matches
Also, in Q2 / 18 the company may receive a favorable ruling from an
arbitration tribunal that could
award substantial damages,
which could be a major near - term catalyst for the stock, significantly adding to the company's balance sheet and initiating a re-rate in the marketplace.
For any matters
which are not subject to
arbitration as set forth in these Official Rules and / or in connection with the entering of any judgment on an
arbitration award in connection with these Official Rules and / or the Contest, the parties irrevocably submit and consent to the exclusive jurisdiction and venue of the state and federal courts located in or closest to the County of New York in the State of New York.
Regardless of the manner in
which the
arbitration is conducted, the arbitrator shall issue a reasoned written decision sufficient to explain the essential findings and conclusions on
which the
award is based.
If the
arbitration is decided in your favor -
which occurs if there is an
award to you that is greater than the value of HBO's last written settlement offer made before an arbitrator was selected - you will not be required to reimburse HBO for any of the fees and costs advanced.
If any
arbitration or other proceeding is brought to enforce or interpret this Agreement or matters relating to it, the substantially prevailing party, as determined by the arbitrator's
award, will be entitled to recover reasonable attorneys» fees and other costs and expenses incurred in such
arbitration or proceeding from the other party, in addition to any other relief to
which such prevailing party is entitled; provided that in no event will the arbitrator have the authority to
award punitive damages.
Consequently, where an arbitral tribunal has rendered an
award which decides matters beyond the scope of the
arbitration agreement, there is a ground for refusing to enforce an
award under article V (1)(c).799
Article V (1)(d) provides that the composition of the arbitral authority must have been in accordance with the agreement of the parties, or in the absence of an agreement, the law of the country where the
arbitration took place, failing
which recognition and enforcement of the
award may be refused.
The conditions for recognition and enforcement in the Convention establish a «ceiling», or maximum level of control,
which Contracting States may exert over arbitral
awards and
arbitration agreements.
Article V (1)(a) provides that courts may refuse recognition or enforcement of arbitral
awards which are not based on a valid
arbitration agreement.832 Article V (1)(a) is similar in nature to article V (1)(c) in that both articles concern whether an arbitral
award has been rendered on the basis of a valid
arbitration agreement.
Parties have also successfully challenged enforcement of
awards under article V (1)(c) on the grounds that an
award was based on an underlying contract
which was not within the subject matter of the
arbitration agreement.
In keeping with the pro-enforcement bias of the New York Convention, article V (1)(c) provides «that part of the
award which contains decisions on matters submitted to
arbitration may be recognized and enforced», provided that matters properly within the scope of the
arbitration agreement «can be separated from those not so submitted.»
Courts have consistently confirmed this in relation to article V (1)(c).837 For example, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit denied a party's attempt to raise a challenge under article V (1)(c) to oppose an order compelling
arbitration, that is, before the arbitral proceedings had even taken place.838 The court noted that the provision could only be invoked by a party opposing enforcement of an
award,
which was not possible in circumstances where no
award had been issued, and also unlikely where the party raising the challenge was the claimant in the would - be
arbitration, and thus not the party who would be in a position to challenge any resulting arbitral
award absent any counterclaims.839
After a protracted
arbitration process and final hearing —
which involved two separate state court appeals — the Arbitrator, a former Chief Justice of the Florida Supreme Court, ruled in favor of the health system respondents on liability, and
awarded no damages to the physician - limited partner on any of his
arbitration claims.
Although article V (1)(d) moves beyond the text of the 1927 Geneva Convention, it is not as liberal as certain
arbitration statutes,
which attach even less importance than the New York Convention to the law of the country where the
arbitration took place at the recognition and enforcement stage.854 As explained in the chapter on article VII, 855 the Convention sets only a «ceiling», or the maximum level of control,
which courts of the Contracting States may exert over foreign arbitral
awards.
Courts have rejected challenges under article V (1)(d) where the parties choose institutional rules to govern their procedure that provide for flexibility concerning the manner in
which the tribunal is to be composed.881 On the other hand, a German court refused recognition and enforcement where an
award was rendered by two, instead of three arbitrators, as expressly required by the rules of the International
Arbitration Court of the Belarusian Chamber of Commerce that the parties had agreed would govern their
arbitration.882
Courts have also applied article V (1)(c) in the context of multiparty
arbitrations to exclude from enforcement portions of an
award which address a party not bound by the
arbitration agreement, but enforce the
award with respect to the remaining parties.
Moreover, by confirming that the public policy objection can not be interpreted broadly, the Supreme Court confirmed that when parties agree to arbitrate their disputes, they may expect that there will be limited grounds on
which they may challenge the
award and should be ready to accept these consequences of agreeing to
arbitration.
Almost 60 years after its creation, the New York Convention continues to fulfil its objective of facilitating the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral
awards, and in the years to come, will guarantee the continued growth of international
arbitration and create conditions in
which cross-border economic exchanges can flourish.
Obtained
arbitration award for a large Internet company against an overreaching landlord
which had made claims related to the lease of client's primary office.
As one United States court observed, «[u] nder the New York Convention, we examine whether the
award exceeds the scope of the [
arbitration agreement], not whether the
award exceeds the scope of the parties» pleadings».803 This interpretation of article V (1)(c)
which distinguishes the parties» pleadings or prayers for relief from the «submission to
arbitration» referred to in article V (1)(c), is consistent with a narrow interpretation of the grounds for refusal to recognize or enforce an
award.
This was the case in a challenge to enforcement brought under article V (1)(c) before the Supreme People's Court of China,
which found that one of the respondents named in the
award was not a party to the
arbitration agreement.
«Matters» has broadly been defined in two ways: first, as the subject matter over
which the arbitral tribunal has jurisdiction pursuant to the
arbitration agreement; and second, in some jurisdictions, as the personal jurisdiction over one of the parties addressed in the
award.
Where article V (1)(a) concerns the existence of a valid
arbitration agreement
which is binding on all the parties addressed by an
award, article V (1)(c) assumes the existence of a valid
arbitration agreement between the parties and is concerned instead with whether an
award has gone beyond the scope of the subject matter the parties intended to submit to
arbitration.
Our work has included obtaining the recognition and enforcement of four AAA arbitral
awards through proceedings conducted before and after the enactment of the Dominican commercial
arbitration law,
which have become landmark cases in the Dominican Republic.
Summary: The respondent in the
arbitration challenged a separate
award on costs, in
which the arbitral tribunal had ordered the respondent to reimburse the claimant for the respondent's part of...
(China and the UK are both parties to the New York Convention,
which requires courts of contracting states to recognise and enforce
arbitration awards made in other contracting states.)
Symbion Power LLC v Venco Imtiaz Construction Company [2017] EWHC 348 (TCC)-- We acted successfully for the defendant, Venco, in this High Court case where the Court rejected an application to set aside an ICC
arbitration award for serious irregularity under section 68 (2)(d) of the
Arbitration Act 1996 on the basis that the tribunal had failed to deal with issues
which were put to it.
Charles acted for Soteropoulos in an unsuccessful mediation,
which was followed by an adverse
arbitration award as well as a costs order against her.
They may also help improve the reputation of international
arbitration,
which has been criticised for its lack of transparency (both of the process and the
awards) and accountability (of arbitrators and practitioners alike) by some sections of the media and members of the legal profession.
August 31 was a day in
which two decisions were issued by Courts of Appeal, both demonstrating the deference that trial and appellate courts will give to
arbitration attorney's fees
awards.
It is anticipated that the new law will provide a properly structured procedural framework for domestic and international
arbitrations seated in the UAE, with clear rules on when an
award may be challenged, as well as easing the route to enforcement of
awards by giving
arbitration awards the status of court judgment
which can be ratified in the UAE Courts (thereby avoiding lengthy enforcement proceedings).
Obtaining a favorable
arbitration award that adopted a valuation of shares required to be repurchased by our client under shareholder's agreement that was millions less than the price sought by the opposing party,
which was affirmed by the trial court.
Although the parties executed the document,
which was entitled «civil mediation agreement,» plaintiffs» counsel wrote to the retired judge to point out that although the document «refer [red] to this proceeding as a «mediation,»» plaintiffs «believe [d] that it is properly an
arbitration proceeding for
which you will be asked to render an
award.»
Although the text finds that the EU proposal is not compatible with the ICSID Convention, it also argues that the proposal meets the definition of»
arbitration» under the New York Convention,
which means that the resulting
awards could probably be enforced under that convention instead.
Ct. 196 (1999),
which provides a mechanism for multiple damages of
arbitration awards under G.L. c. 93A.
After the proceedings concluded, the retired judge rendered an
arbitration award,
which directed that the Association hire a contractor to make certain repairs and advance the funds for the work subject to reimbursement from numerous other affected lot owners who were not parties to any of the prior proceedings.
Participated in obtaining an $ 8 million final
arbitration award for a non-profit hospital against an affiliate of a multinational pharmaceutical conglomerate and defeated the affiliate's $ 43 million counterclaim, all of
which was confirmed by a federal district court
Certain provinces of Canada have adopted the New York Convention,
which states the participating provinces to enforce
arbitration awards, and that enforcement may only be refused on limited grounds.
The
arbitration award is especially helpful as employers consider the recent Bill 132 amendments to the Occupational Health and Safety Act (the «OHSA»),
which confirm that reasonable actions taken by an employer relating to the management or direction of workers or the workplace is not workplace harassment.
Obtained a labor
arbitration award in favor of a local Transit Corporation
which denied a union grievance alleging a suspension without just cause.
Clyde & Co took home the Dispute Resolution Team of the Year
award for its work on an international
arbitration case and subsequent appeal,
which set a precedent that has been followed by numerous others in Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC)
award enforcement cases.
It unanimously upheld the decision of the Alberta Court of Appeal,
which in turn upheld the trial court, in all cases finding that the winner of the Russian
arbitration was out of time to enforce the
award in Alberta.
The Dubai International
Arbitration Centre has also confirmed that Dubai Decree No. 57 for 2009 (
which established the Tribunal) does not affect disputes where the parties have agreed to have the dispute determined by
arbitration although any resulting
arbitration award has to be enforced through the Tribunal.
In reality, this reservation is more theoretical than anything else, because codified French
arbitration law itself does not contain any such limitation, and article VII (1) of the Convention confirms that the Convention does not deprive parties of more favourable rights they might enjoy under the law of the country in
which enforcement of the foreign
award is sought.
Inc. v. Department of Public Works,
which underscores the narrow judicial review afforded to an
arbitration award.
Following a lengthy
arbitration in
which he determined that the mother had undertaken a campaign of parental alientation, the arbitrator
awarded custody of the two sons to the father and ordered the father to attend a reunification program with the children.
Therefore, the homologation process in Ecuador implies that the party that seeks the enforcement of a foreign
award shall file a petition with the Provincial Court8,
which will assess whether the
award complies with the following requirements: (i) The international
award complies with the formalities required for it to be considered authentic in the state where it was issued; (ii) The
award is final and binding in the jurisdiction where it was delivered and the attachments are duly legalized; (iii) With regard to the requirement prescribed in the Convention, if the
award is in a language other than the official language of the country, in this case Spanish, it shall incorporate a translation; (iv) It is shown from the legal papers of the
arbitration proceedings that the party against whom the
awards is being enforced was duly notified of the claim and that there was no due process violation; (v) The petition must specify the domicile of the party against whom the
award is being enforced.
It found that it was common ground between the experts that under applicable Russian
arbitration law at least one valid ground to set aside the
award had been present,
which related to the obligations on the arbitrators to disclose certain potential conflicts of interest.