Appealing to tradition does not rebut the claim that establishing relevant background and qualifications functions
as an appeal to authority.
Placing aside, for the moment, that this is a logical fallacy known
as the appeal to authority — the statement lacks credibility because it is a highly criticized authority subject to the whims of political influence.
The whole «scientists» thing is a logical fallacy known
as appeal to authority.
But: (1) often, I see «skeptics» building straw men out of valid arguments that expertise should not be dismissed out of hand, and (2) I often see selective reasoning from «skeptics» where they denounce «realist» arguments
as appealing to authority when they then turn right around and appeal to their own authorities.
Not exact matches
Following the steps in this chapter will give you formulas for creating content that is
appealing to your target audience while establishing you
as an
authority.
Allowing for the remarkable contrasts, Ker believes he can still trace at least one theme through the work of all six of his subjects, a theme that has little
to do with the obvious «motifs» of English Catholicism such
as «aestheticism, a love of ritual, ceremony, tradition, the
appeal of
authority, a romantic triumphalism, the lure of the exotic and foreign, a preoccupation with sin and guilt.»
It's a form of the
appeal to authority, but disguised
as sola scriptura.
For some reason it never seems
to occur
to the clergy person (s)
to ask whether the accuser (s) have first personally confronted the defendent,
as instructed
to do by Scripture, before
appealing to an
authority figure.
For in spite of its prima facie attraction, and even if there is such a «primal» experience, that experience would not be accessible in any philosophically helpful way, could not be exploited without reliance upon the very analyses and arguments whose lack of immediacy and
authority the
appeal is seeking
to escape, could not (even for oneself) sustain translation into the discursive and dialectical combat zone of philosophy, and could not by itself alone provide a nonarbitrary basis for determining what in it is essential
to experience merely
as such.
What you have here is a logical fallacy known
as an «
appeal to authority.»
Fundamentally, they present themselves
to us
as bearing an objective
authority that overrides competing
appeals or reasons
to do otherwise.
This most basic character I described
as openness
to developments in the culture and presentation of reasons for the Christian faith without any
appeal to supernatural
authority.
Appeal to authority on questions such
as birth control, divorce and women priests «did not satisfy an educated people who wanted
to be convinced with arguments».
And thus do they pervert and distort the Scriptures, making them the guide
to slavish details of the daily life and an
authority in things nonspiritual instead of
appealing to the sacred writings
as the repository of the moral wisdom, religious inspiration, and the spiritual teaching of the God - knowing men of other generations.»
Charlemagne's successors were less powerful and
as they became unable
to hold overbearing archbishops in check, bishops
appealed to the Pope for support and this increased papal
authority.
«
As the three men launch their
appeal, we urge the Iranian
authorities to ensure due process is observed.
The magisterium
appeals to these
authorities as grounds for repudiating divorce, abortion, homosexual relations, and the ordination of women
to the priesthood.
The claim that the UN resolutions suffice
to assure «just
authority» is belied by destruction in Iraq unrelated
to freeing Kuwait (bridges, roads, municipal water and sewage systems) and by restatements of war aims (asking Iraqis
to replace Saddam Hussein, demanding unconditional surrender and a war crimes trial) which go far beyond the UN objective (note
as well the elements of bad faith in the UN
appeal to which Geyer pointed).
She makes no
appeal to philosophical doctrine
as an external
authority.
Brunner
appeals explicitly
to the prologue of John and
to certain sayings of Paul, but surely one who is
as emphatic
as he in rejecting the
authority of Scriptural teachings
as such does not mean
to say that we accept the doctrine of creation because of the presence of these passages in the New Testament.
This is precisely why religious people fail because they are inherently irrational and they use a logical fallacy (
appeal to authority)
as their basis for moral decisions.
First, it is interesting that in the fourth century, the road
to Constantinople in 381 is not paved by blunt
appeals to church
authority but by extensive wrestling over biblical texts and fine - tooling of extra-biblical language (most notably the term «hypostasis») in an attempt
to establish which exegetical claims made sense of Scripture
as a whole and which fell short.
If there is anything that must define a progressive Christianity in the modern age, it is that you simply can't retrench
to your own position,
appeal on
authority to your given text and let it go at that
as far
as seeking the truth of your own view is concerned.
First, Aristotle has in mind, under the heading of «witnesses» (martures) not narrators of things seen so much
as moral
authorities appealed to by the orator.
The crucial issues mentioned in the Wheaton declarations were: Mission and syncretism, mission and universal salvation, mission and proselytism, mission and the Roman Catholic Church, mission and church growth, mission and foreign mission and mission and Evangelical unity.8 In all these they
appealed to the Scripture
as final
authority.
(2) The New Testament itself
appeals to «eyewitnesses and ministers of the word»
as authorities for the tradition (Luke 1:2), thereby showing its concern for the historical ministry of Jesus.
That is
to say, they must,
as much
as possible, frame their arguments in a public vocabulary that is
as accessible
to as many people
as possible, and must exercise a disciplined restraint in
appealing explicitly
to religious
authority.
Try not
to use him
as too large an
appeal to authority, it's like when people only seem
to know Einstein's name but Fermi, Dirac, Pauli, etc all seem
to be mentioned by few, despite being
as equally competent.
We are all equals that must never
appeal to our
authority as an expert.»
Now the point of this discussion is not
to appeal to Whitehead
as some sort of final
authority; Hall clearly recognizes that his own view differs from that of Whitehead at some points (see, e.g., UP 200f.
«Historically, opinion on the
appeal to authority has been divided — it has been held
to be a valid argument about
as often
as it has been considered an outright fallacy.»
The force of Luther's protest against the claims
to authority of the established Church is
to be found partly in the
appeal to scripture, but also in this doctrine of man's condition and of the love of God
as present only through God's grace.
From this time come the disputes over interpretation of the Law, in which they
appealed to the
authority of Jesus and represented him
as the rabbi which he had never been.
After claiming the
authority of natural law, Scripture, tradition, the previous teaching of the magisterium, and the unanimous agreement of the bishops today, the Pope
appeals to his own
authority as successor of Peter and issues a solemn declaration.
Pinnock
appeals to absolutes revealed by God
as the final
authority in theological reflection.
Paul and others will make an
appeal to their
authority as apostles when necessary, or they will say it is a custom, or a hymn; it's not that hard, really, when anyone reads the whole thing instead of just verses.
Pinnock acknowledges the diversity in Scripture
as the ultimate
authority but
appeals to continuity within diversity and the early creeds
as the basis for theology.
If they do this, one can not get out of such a situation by the application of doublethink,
appeals to knowing «by faith,» or even by relying on tradition
as authority.
Popieluszko's vision of liberation made no
appeal for the Polish
authorities who dubbed the «masses for the nation»
as «rallies hostile
to the Polish state and accused Fr.
«Judge Doty's order did not contain any determinations concerning the fairness of the
appeals process under the CBA, including the commissioner's longstanding
authority to appoint a designee
to act
as hearing officer.
Thus, Unicef
appeals to the public who may want
to donate milk
to Sendong survivors not
to give the milk directly
to affected populations, but rather give the milk
to the appropriate
authority, such
as the DOH, so that distribution of the milk can be carefully managed.
The feeling that somebody has just passed away whose horizons and global
appeal extended the international significance of this country is omnipresent —
as well
as the prevailing idea that his death marks an end of one era... Even the other Vaclav in the presidential office, his successor Klaus, who has been Havel's rival and critic ever since 1989, is now giving him credit —
to the degree of admitting that we owe his predecessor «like nobody else for the international position, prestige and
authority of the Czech Republic in the world.»
The
appeal court added that since the House of Representatives or any chamber of the National Assembly lacked the power
to conduct criminal investigation, its report «can not be used
to prevent or shield any of the petroleum marketer and supply companies from being investigated by competent investigative
authority upon a criminal complaint that it fraudulently received billions of naira
as imported petroleum subsidy payments when it did not import or market the petroleum in Nigeria.»
And based on a court ruling yesterday, neither is now required
to report
to the
authorities anytime soon
as their convictions are
appealed — a process that could take more than a year.
The Homeowners Forum will host presentations from the New York City Department of Finance in reference
to calculating and
appealing property tax assessments, The New York State Energy Research and Development
Authority (NYSERDA) who will be offering energy efficiency program options, the Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City (NHS) presenting first - time homebuyer's education & counseling
as well
as foreclosure prevention, and HPD which will be present
to respond
to questions regarding code enforcement.
If the DEBTOR fails
to pay within 30 days of the date of judgment date (and files no
appeal), the CREDITOR may request a SHERIFF»S EXECUTION from the COUNTY CLERK»S OFFICE giving the Sheriff's Department full
authority to seize money or property
as payment toward the Judgment.
«Up till today, that
Appeal Court judgment of October 10, 2010, that made Fayemi governor is not being cited
as authority in any election matter and with Obasanjo's reference
to Salamigate
as terminology for judicial manipulation, it should be clear
to Fayemi himself that he became governor by judicial fraud.
Jacob who works
as a Social Worker with the Federal Ministry of Women Affairs and Social Development, Abujaalso
appealed to the practitioners and other stakeholders
to prevail on those in positions of
authority so that the opportunity will not elude the association.
A fugitive from the U.S.
authorities, Snowden chose SXSW
as the venue for his first live conversation with an audience because the gathering
appeals to computer programmers and other technology professionals receptive
to his message.
Each local
authority makes up its own policy on what
to do with cases, and
as result of the successful
appeal, many have had
to look again at this matter.