Known
as the fiduciary rule and set by the Labor Department to take effect in April 2017 — but then delayed by the Trump administration until at least June 2017 and some parts until January 2018 — the rule simply requires people in the financial services industry to put consumers» best interests ahead of their own.
Trump's order will give the new administration time to review the change, known
as the fiduciary rule.
Not exact matches
Since the Department of Labor finalized its
fiduciary rule (now in limbo) last year, annuity sales have fallen dramatically
as brokerage firms and advisors anticipate that the products may not pass muster under a tighter regulatory standard.
Garrett and other
fiduciary financial advisors see the recently issued
fiduciary rule passed by the Department of Labor
as a major step in the right direction of controlling the costs of advice to investors.
Calling the
fiduciary rule a «controversial regulation,» Acosta said that while courts have upheld the
rule as consistent with Congress» delegated authority, it may not align with Trump's «deregulatory goals.»
On April 8, 2016, the Department of Labor (Department) published a final regulation (
Fiduciary Rule or Rule) defining who is a «fiduciary» of an employee benefit plan under section 3 (21)(A)(ii) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA or the Act) as a result of giving investment advice to a plan or its participants or benef
Fiduciary Rule or
Rule) defining who is a «
fiduciary» of an employee benefit plan under section 3 (21)(A)(ii) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA or the Act) as a result of giving investment advice to a plan or its participants or benef
fiduciary» of an employee benefit plan under section 3 (21)(A)(ii) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA or the Act)
as a result of giving investment advice to a plan or its participants or beneficiaries.
Many supporters of delay also argued that the President's Memorandum has rendered the ultimate fate of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs uncertain and that proceeding with the April 10, 2017 applicability date in the face of this uncertainty would impose unnecessary costs and burdens on the financial services industry and result in unnecessary confusion to investors inasmuch
as products, services, and advisory practices could change after completion of the examination.
As a result, the Fiduciary Rule and the Impartial Conduct Standards in these PTEs will become applicable beginning on June 9, 2017, while other conditions in these PTEs, such as requirements to make specific written disclosures and representations of fiduciary compliance in investor communications, are not required until January 1, 201
As a result, the
Fiduciary Rule and the Impartial Conduct Standards in these PTEs will become applicable beginning on June 9, 2017, while other conditions in these PTEs, such as requirements to make specific written disclosures and representations of fiduciary compliance in investor communications, are not required until January
Fiduciary Rule and the Impartial Conduct Standards in these PTEs will become applicable beginning on June 9, 2017, while other conditions in these PTEs, such
as requirements to make specific written disclosures and representations of fiduciary compliance in investor communications, are not required until January 1, 201
as requirements to make specific written disclosures and representations of
fiduciary compliance in investor communications, are not required until January
fiduciary compliance in investor communications, are not required until January 1, 2018.
As compared to the contract, disclosure, and warranty requirements of the BIC Exemption and Principal Transactions Exemption, the
Fiduciary Rule and the Impartial Conduct Standards are among the least controversial aspects of the rulemaking project (although not free from controversy or unchallenged in litigation).
Another theme of commenters and petitioners supporting delay is that, even without regard to the President's Memorandum, the Department initially erred in adopting April 10, 2017,
as the applicability date of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs.
However, the Department will review the 2016 RIA's conclusions
as part of its review of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs directed by the Presidential Memorandum.
The President directed that if the Department makes an affirmative determination
as to any of the above three considerations, or the Department concludes for any other reason, after appropriate review, that the
Fiduciary Rule, PTEs, or both are inconsistent with the priority of the Administration «to empower Americans to make their own financial decisions, to facilitate their ability to save for retirement and build the individual wealth necessary to afford typical lifetime expenses, such as buying a home and paying for college, and to withstand unexpected financial emergencies,» then the Department shall publish for notice and comment a proposed rule rescinding or revising the Fiduciary Rule, as appropriate and as consistent with
Rule, PTEs, or both are inconsistent with the priority of the Administration «to empower Americans to make their own financial decisions, to facilitate their ability to save for retirement and build the individual wealth necessary to afford typical lifetime expenses, such
as buying a home and paying for college, and to withstand unexpected financial emergencies,» then the Department shall publish for notice and comment a proposed
rule rescinding or revising the Fiduciary Rule, as appropriate and as consistent with
rule rescinding or revising the
Fiduciary Rule, as appropriate and as consistent with
Rule,
as appropriate and
as consistent with law.
The President, by Memorandum to the Secretary of Labor dated February 3, 2017, directed the Department of Labor to examine whether the
Fiduciary Rule may adversely affect the ability of Americans to gain access to retirement information and financial advice, and to prepare an updated economic and legal analysis concerning the likely impact of the
Fiduciary Rule as part of that examination.
Thus, the
fiduciary definition in the
Rule published on April 8, 2016, and Impartial Conduct Standards in these exemptions, are applicable on June 9, 2017, while compliance with other conditions for covered transactions, such
as the contract requirement, in these exemptions is not required until January 1, 2018.
Not all firms within a given NAICS code would be affected by this
rule, because being an ERISA
fiduciary relies on a functional test and is not based on industry status
as defined by a NAICS code.
As highlighted in the Final Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis for the
Fiduciary Rule, 96.2, 97.3, and 99.3 percent of BDs, Registered Investment Advisors, and Insurers respectively are estimated to meet the SBAs definition of small business.
As part of this examination, the Department was directed to prepare an updated economic and legal analysis concerning the likely impact of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs, which shall consider, among other things:
The impacts of today's final
rule are categorized consistently with the analysis of the original Fiduciary Rule, and the Department has also concluded that the impacts identified in the Regulatory Impact Analysis accompanying the 2016 final rule may still be used as a basis for estimating the potential impacts of that final rule, were it not being modified to
rule are categorized consistently with the analysis of the original
Fiduciary Rule, and the Department has also concluded that the impacts identified in the Regulatory Impact Analysis accompanying the 2016 final rule may still be used as a basis for estimating the potential impacts of that final rule, were it not being modified to
Rule, and the Department has also concluded that the impacts identified in the Regulatory Impact Analysis accompanying the 2016 final
rule may still be used as a basis for estimating the potential impacts of that final rule, were it not being modified to
rule may still be used
as a basis for estimating the potential impacts of that final
rule, were it not being modified to
rule, were it not being modified today.
The Department also considered a scenario where the
fiduciary definition in the
Rule and Impartial Conduct Standards in the PTEs take effect on April 10, 2017
as originally planned, while the remaining conditions in the PTEs become applicable on January 1, 2018.
As amended, Section III of the PTE requires Financial Institutions to make certain disclosures to plan
fiduciaries and owners of managed IRAs in order to receive relief from ERISA's and the Code's prohibited transaction
rules for the receipt of commissions and to engage in transactions involving mutual fund shares.
Many commenters also based support for delay on opposition to the substance of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs,
as written, and disagreement with the conclusions reached in the final rulemaking and associated Regulatory Impact Analysis.
The Department is uncertain about the magnitude of this reduction and will consider this question
as part of its review of the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs pursuant to the President's Memorandum.
Specifically, the Department extends the applicability date for the
Fiduciary Rule and the BIC Exemption and Principal Transactions Exemption (including their transition relief) for 60 days,
as proposed.
In the 2016 RIA, the Department concluded that published research supports its estimates of investor gains and that the
Fiduciary Rule and PTEs were not likely to impose additional social costs
as a result of the loss of access to financial advice.
Finally, because the Impartial Conduct Standards will become applicable on June 9, 2017, the Department believes that firms will make efforts to adhere to those standards, motivated both by their applicability and by the prospect of their likely continuation,
as well
as by the impending applicability of complementary consumer protections and / or enforcement mechanisms beginning on January 1, 2018, depending on the results of the Department's review of the
Fiduciary Rule pursuant to the President's Memorandum.
This week, the DOL delayed the effective date of its
Fiduciary Rule — which would define all retirement plan financial advisors
as ERISA
fiduciaries, effectively banning conflicted 401 (k) investment advice that puts advisor profit ahead of client interests — by 60 days from April 10, 2017 to June 9, 2017.
As a critic of the
Fiduciary Rule, it's a good bet that President Trump ordered the DOL analysis to build a case for overturning it.
The
fiduciary rule requires that advisors act
as would a reasonable person with knowledge of the subject matter, Weir said.
The opinions expressed are not intended to serve
as investment advice (either under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, or the Department of Labor's
Fiduciary Advice
Rule), a recommendation, offer, or solicitation to buy or sell any securities, or recommendation regarding specific investment strategies.
Indexed annuity sales in 2017 fell 5 percent to $ 57.6 billion compared with record sales in 2016, but analysts expect FIA sales to rise this year
as insurers and distributors adjust and move on from new Department of Labor
fiduciary rules.
After six long years, the specter of the Department of Labor's
fiduciary rule has finally taken shape, although
as one BD leader put it, the industry is still in a «state of flux»
as it determines how to comply with all aspects of the
rule.
Fixed indexed annuity (FIA) products will now be subject to the best interest contract exemption (BICE) of the DOL final
fiduciary rule, meaning that the advisor will be required to act
as a
fiduciary with respect to recommendations provided in connection with these products.
As I wrote back in January, the
Fiduciary Rule, though well - intentioned, would inevitably limit the number of investment products available to retail investors.
As expected, President Barack Obama on Wednesday vetoed resolutions passed by the House and Senate to kill the Department of Labor's
rule amending the definition of
fiduciary under ERISA.
The Department of Labor has issued technical corrections to the
fiduciary rule, specifically clarifying whether insurance companies can use the best interest contract exemption
as well
as principal transaction exemption clarifications.
The key to understanding the
fiduciary rule is «are you making a recommendation, and do you get paid in a way that after the fact can be viewed
as conflicted,» Blass said.
As a practical matter, the Department of Labor will need a significant amount of time - at the very least through the June 9, 2017 date it proposes - to conduct the review the President directed and determine upon the issuance of a notice of proposed rulemaking to revoke or modify the
Fiduciary Rule.
Some sponsors are selling them in lieu of non-traded BDCs and REITs because they are viewed to be more investor friendly
as sponsors look to address FINRA notice 15 - 02 and the new DOL
fiduciary rule.
Further, the final
rule defines a variety of investment education activities that fall short of
fiduciary conduct, and makes clear that advisors do not act
as fiduciaries merely by recommending that a customer hire them to render advisory or asset management services.
As anticipated, GOP lawmakers are introducing bills to block the Department of Labor's recently released
rule to amend the definition of
fiduciary on retirement advice.
Nancy Smith, executive vice president and corporate secretary at AARP, said on a conference panel with Hauser that AARP will not only continue to advocate for the
fiduciary rule but plans to assemble some members to act
as «mystery shoppers» to see if advisors are complying.
As discussed above, the BICE is the primary means of relief for advisors who provide rollover recommendations under the new
fiduciary rule.
Dale Brown, FSI's president and CEO, stated on the call that FSI,
as well
as the other groups joining the suit, «has supported a uniform
fiduciary standard since 2009 — before Dodd - Frank became law... but the Department of Labor's complex and unworkable
rule will only harm the smaller investors it claims to protect.»
Broker - dealers are helping investors make better retirement decisions
as a result of procedural changes firms have made in preparation for the DOL
fiduciary rule, according to a study done by state regulators on the Individual Retirement Account rollover market.
FSI, SIFMA
as well
as the Chamber have stated previously that they wouldn't
rule out taking legal action against DOL's
fiduciary rule.
While the new DOL
rules are principles based and do not provide discreet instructions
as to what advisors should do to fulfill
fiduciary duties, industry executive David Trainer said advisors can not lose with clients or regulators by incorporating research into their practice that is «inarguably in the best interest of clients.»
Despite that distinction, President Barack Obama is one of her biggest fans: In his speech last year pushing the Department of Labor to press on with its
fiduciary standard
rule, he pointed out Garrett by name
as an FA who puts the best interests of her clients first.
By Cerulli's numbers, less than 3 percent of the total advisor universe operated
as an ERISA
fiduciary plan specialist prior to finalization of Labor Department's
fiduciary rule.
As anticipated, financial services trade groups are said to be filing a lawsuit soon challenging the Department of Labor's new
fiduciary rule.
Furman and Betsey Stevenson, another council member, provide what they describe
as «evidence» that proves DOL's draft «Conflict of Interest
Rule for Retirement Savings,» which seeks to broaden the definition of who is a
fiduciary under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, is sorely needed.