Responding to a commentor who pointed out the study actually UNDERCOUNTED homebirth deaths because some deaths
at homebirth happened during or after transfer and were included in the hospital group, she offers this bit of obfuscation:
Not exact matches
They are very rare and not a single study documents the rate
at which these
happen suddenly
at attended low risk
homebirth.
It
happens so rarely that the rate of death from AFE (1/1, 000,000) and cord prolapse (1/100, 000)
at homebirth is a miniscule fraction of the maternal mortality (1/5, 000) and perinatal mortality (1.7 / 1000) from elective cesarean surgery in hospital (34).
Partly OT: what
happens when you have a bad
homebirth story (no lasting consequences, thankfully), see the new studies, look
at yourself and say with certainty that had this data been available, you wouldn't have made a choice to
homebirth but you still support it for low - risk women in UK and Canada fashion?
I've done
homebirths [in the UK] and the potential for irreparable disaster was present
at every one, although there was a crisis in only one [abruption] and mother and baby were both saved, they were also
at much greater risk
at home than in the hospital and in the end required much more intensive treatment [largely because of time delays] than if the same situation had
happened in hospital.
It is possible the bias of these authors originate from never having attended a
homebirth and extrapolating from the horrendous emergencies that
happen at hospital births, thinking that they also
happen at homebirths, when they don't.
When this 20 % risk of death is compared to the 0.02 % rate of cord prolapse during labor
at homebirth that might have a better outcome if it
happened in hospital, this means that a low risk woman has a 1000 times higher chance of having a life threatening complication either to her life or her fetus / newborns life
at planned hospital birth, than if she plans to have an attended
homebirth with a well - trained practitioner.
You seem to be working on the assumption that since only 0.21 % of babies die
at or around a
homebirth that it won't
happen to you.
Unfortunately, even if a problem
at a
homebirth is due to something like an unavoidable genetic defect, people will say, «That would have never
happened at the hospital!»
Again, couldn't we simply explore this to learn how
homebirths could be safer for those moms who have been previously scarred by hospitals (including losing an older child in a hospital birth — yes, it
happens) or for those who for whatever reason choose to birth
at home?
«Natural Childbirth»... well that can only
happen in a birth center or
at a
homebirth... right?
Ask a doula about which hospitals are best for breastfeeding and other issues, because even if you choose a
homebirth, anything can
happen and you wouldn't want to have to choose a hospital
at literally the last minute.
She went to get some coffee and breakfast
at about 6 a.m., and I laid there, listening to Tre's heartbeat on the monitor and mourning the loss of my
homebirth, and sobbing softly as I thought of all the things that were going to
happen that day.