They compared the death rate
at homebirth with the death rate in tertiary [high risk] facilities, but that's not what we want to know.
Not exact matches
The media has failed to differentiate between freebirth or unassisted birth (no midwife or doctor) and
homebirth (a birth
at home, usually
with a midwife or
homebirth doctor).
I wanted to
homebirth with my first, but when I went into preterm labor
at 23 weeks, that was the end of that.
While Push Back may prompt important discussions about birthing, feeding, and early caring among parents - to - be,
at times it is too black - and - white, failing to acknowledge that
homebirths can be made safer, for example, or that certain close and responsive interactions
with adults are a foundation for brain development.
Although tragic, cord prolapse and AFE occur rarely
at homebirth, 1/5000 and 1/500, 000 respectively, when balanced
with the dozens of acute emergency conditions endangering the health of mother and baby that occur
at planned hospital birth caused by intervening in the birth process, the scales tip easily in favor of planned attended
homebirth for low risk women.
Instead of excluding the high risk births from both groups, they include the
homebirth outcomes of premature births
at 34 - 37 weeks gestation (13 - 17) breech and twins (13,14) lethal anomalies incompatible
with life (13,14) unattended
homebirths (15,16) unplanned
homebirths (15,16) or women who became risked out of
homebirth by becoming high risk
at the end of pregnancy, had hospital births, but are included in the
homebirth group.
We want to know how the death rate
at homebirth compares
with the death rate
at all hospital births, not the death rate
at tertiary facilities.
My wife and I had our first 2 in a hospital and it almost killed them because of the drugs they forced on my wife the last 2 were born
at home in a pool the 1st
homebirth we had a midwife present the 2nd one the midwife was an hour and a half late so I delivered our daughter by myself it was awsome and now my wife is PG
with our 5th baby we have the same midwife who was late to our last birth and we already know she is not going to be here ontime mostly because she lives 2 hours away from where we live and we are ok
with this.
but in my thinking, that is EXACTLY what
homebirth is supposed to provide: the environment and support to do what can normally and naturally be done
at home,
with the wisdom and assessment of a care provider who knows when the risk is to great, thus utilizing home and hospital for their exact right purposes.
(I am an Australian midwife and also had
homebirths prior to becoming a midwife) Your system in America is quite radically different to ours here in Australia and so we don't have the same problem
with poorly trained and undereducated midwives and although we still have ideologically driven midwifery, where process is promoted over outcome, we have strict protocols, guidelines and governance
at all levels to ensure dangerous midwives are prevented from continuing to practice and women and their families are protected and have recourse for compensation.
I have had five babies, all came out of my nether regions, one was born
at home
with fantastic community midwives, and one started out as a
homebirth and ended up in hospital.
I don't know any rational woman who would go ahead
with a
homebirth in the knowledge that
at least 1 in 500 babies, even in optimal circumstances, die.
They're raising money to «free» an uncredentialed, unlicensed «midwife» who is charged
with misrepresenting her qualifications to parents, presiding over a
homebirth death, and who was arrested for prostitution, without making an attempt
at, indeed without even calling for an investigation of any kind.
Bear in mind that
homebirth midwives want cold, hard cash in advance, so a
homebirth is not an attractive choice for families
with cash - flow problems (which, like it or not, describes most US families
at nearly all income levels).
As much as some people dislike Dr. Amy's tone, her blunt, unapologetic approach does seem to bring people by — even if it is just to gawk
at how ebil we are, express hate, or try to «educate» us
with a round of
Homebirth Bingo.
She attended
homebirths with her midwife for two years before apprenticing
at Andaluz.
Partly OT: what happens when you have a bad
homebirth story (no lasting consequences, thankfully), see the new studies, look
at yourself and say
with certainty that had this data been available, you wouldn't have made a choice to
homebirth but you still support it for low - risk women in UK and Canada fashion?
If I, or my daughter, had needed emergency medical care (or worse) I think that the last person I would want to face
at the hospital would be a doctor
with a grudge against
homebirth like this doctor has.
Most studies of
homebirth in other countries have found no statistically significant differences in perinatal outcomes between home and hospital births for women
at low risk of complications.36, 37,39 However, a recent study in the United States showed poorer neonatal outcomes for births occurring
at home or in birth centres.40 A meta - analysis in the same year demonstrated higher perinatal mortality associated
with homebirth41 but has been strongly criticised on methodological grounds.5, 42 The Birthplace in England study, 43 the largest prospective cohort study on place of birth for women
at low risk of complications, analysed a composite outcome, which included stillbirth and early neonatal death among other serious morbidity.
Let's weigh the options this mother had: Option 1 — 39 weeks — RCS — live baby Option 2 — 40 weeks — RCS — live baby Option 3 — 41 weeks — RCS — live baby Option 4 — 42 weeks — RCS — live baby Option 5 — 43 weeks — show up
at hospital in labor, RCS — live baby Option 6 — 43 weeks — show up
at hospital in labor, demand TOL, CS
at first sign of distress — live baby Option 7 — 43 weeks — attempt
homebirth vba2c — DEAD baby Yea... the
homebirth had NOTHING to do
with it.
The overall all rate of perinatal death
at planned
homebirth with a LICENSED midwife was 800 % higher than comparable risk hospital deaths.
Morgan McLaughlin McFarland, in a guest post
at Bring Birth Home entitled Brave Has Nothing to Do
With It, helpfully illustrates the self aggrandizing ignorance that is the hallmark of
homebirth advocacy.
And then let's look
at the injuries and deaths that occured in
homebirth with CPMs and the like... how many would have been prevented in a hospital setting?
So I think it is clear,
at least to me, that the tradeoff is that
homebirth lowers minor morbidity in the mother and replaces it
with major morbidity in the baby through a lack of timely intervention.
ROTHMANAnd I also just want to say that it is really great to have physicians like Dr. Downing, who understand the midwifery model, understand our scope of practice and where it intersects
with obstetrics, so that when we do have something going on
at a
homebirth where we're not sure things are going well and we were starting to feel like maybe we need to access medical technology, that we have people like Dr. Downing that we can call and say, here's what's going on, we're coming in, and that we know that we and our clients will be received
with compassion and respect and understanding of what has come before, so that we never have to hesitate to bring someone in knowing that they're gonna get that good care.
The two larger hospitals have lower c - section rates than the smaller hospital closest to me and they also boast women's clinics
with multiple midwives on staff, but my
homebirth midwife recommended an OB
at the closer hospital — a personal friend of hers — who had given birth her own child
at The Farm (
with Ina May as a back - up midwife!)
When this 20 % risk of death is compared to the 0.02 % rate of cord prolapse during labor
at homebirth that might have a better outcome if it happened in hospital, this means that a low risk woman has a 1000 times higher chance of having a life threatening complication either to her life or her fetus / newborns life
at planned hospital birth, than if she plans to have an attended
homebirth with a well - trained practitioner.
When compared
with babies born vaginally in the hospital, babies born
at homebirth had a rate of hypoxic brain damage 32 times higher, suggesting that C - sections dramatically decreased the risk of hypoxic brain injury.
Therefore, no one has to provide you
with the means of having a
homebirth, but no one can stop you if you choose to give birth
at home.
Over
at Natural Moms Talk Radio there is a great interview
with Lynn Griesemer, mom of 6 and author of Unassisted
Homebirth: An Act of Love.
My midwifes were confident to go ahead
with my
homebirth but my family (which is in another country) was very worry specially when I said my baby will be born
at home in water.
We had initially planned a
homebirth,
with our midwife who had supported us
at our daughter's birth
at home one year ago.
Most women can deliver most of their babies
with minimum intervention, they are less likely to receive unnecessary intervention
at home, and in that sense
homebirths can be safer.
All regulations governing
homebirth with licensed midwives in South Carolina are available in PDF format
at the following address: http://www.scdhec.com/administration/regs/docs/61-24.pdf.
They know that birthing
at home or in a birth center
with a trained midwife is a very safe option
with lower rates of interventions and high patient satisfaction but now you no longer have to search and search for studies regarding
homebirth which are often buried by cultural anecdotes and message boards.
But
at the same time, I have a lot of trouble
with the idea of outlawing
homebirth or something like that; I still think women should be able to choose it.
MANA's own results are telling you the RATE of mistakes that are made
with Homebirth are higher than the rate of mistakes that are made
at the hospital.
However, a thorough examination of MANA's provided data
with hospitals» compiled data,
with real available data
at the present time, show
homebirth is a higher risk to babies.
Evidently
homebirth midwives want women to read only the stories
with good outcomes; the many stories of
homebirth death shouldn't be published
at all.
We can also be sure that the authors understood that their data showed that
homebirth has a horrifically high death rate, because they try to hide the number of deaths for the past 5 years, released the data only under pressure, and then proceeded to draw a conclusion entirely
at odds
with what their own data showed.
When we compare the death rate
at homebirth of 2.06 / 1000
with the CDC death rate for low risk white women, ages 20 - 44,
at term,
with babies that are not growth restricted of 0.38, we find that
homebirth has a death rate 5.5 X higher than hospital birth.
The paper uses the term: «5 minute Apgar score of 0» as newborns that were born
with a heart beat but the midwife or doctor attending the planned
homebirth were unable to resuscitate the baby, so
at 5 minutes the Apgar was 0 and the baby was dead.
Talking to other mums who were preparing for
homebirths with older children present helped me to look
at my own attitudes and to prepare Joshua for sharing in the birth.
The nurse - midwifery team
at Believe Midwifery Services, LLC is as equipped, if not more so, than the local remote hospital to handle obstetric emergencies and to date, has a successfully assisted all their VBAC clients in a subsequent
homebirth with the exception of two who self - elected a non-emergent transfer for pain management.
In my experiences
with homebirth midwives that practice in Illinois (there is still a large Mennonite population, and a number of women who still wish to birth
at home), the recommend having a
homebirth friendly Pediatrician in place because, «there are orders to call CPS if a homebirthed baby or mom transfers to a hospital».
My first baby was born
at home
with a wonderful midwife and I'm planning a second
homebirth for this upcoming March.
Overend, Jenni WELCOME
WITH LOVE Kane / Miller, 1999 First published in Australia, Welcome with Love is a warm look at homebirth from big brother Jack's perspect
WITH LOVE Kane / Miller, 1999 First published in Australia, Welcome
with Love is a warm look at homebirth from big brother Jack's perspect
with Love is a warm look
at homebirth from big brother Jack's perspective.
I helped start a
homebirth practice
with my Midwife and was also one of her apprentice for two years; it was then that I discovered a more sacred way to birth when I first heard undisturbed birth by Micheal Ordent and I said OMG this is what I've been searching for, I then saw a flyer for a workshop by Whapio
at the Matrona and one of the Granny Midwives, Granny Smith and a local elder Midwife was going to be honored there and I said I have to go and meet them.
I'm no expert, but in addition to the vast amount of research I did before my 2nd child (
homebirth), my experience
with an ob before I switched to a midwife
with that same child, my experience
with a medicated vaginal hospital birth w / my first child, my experience in talking to dozens of women that have had surgical births, in addition to all that anecdotal «wisdom», I have taken a graduate level Sociology of Medicine class that was an in depth look
at our current medical system from a sociological perspective and we spent a couple of weeks talking about the medical model of birth and the alternatives.
I've met a few who described their birth experience as amazing (most of them were
homebirths or in birth centers — which are a fringe practice here too, but
at least
with real, medically trained midwives), but I wasn't there so I can't say how much of that was reality vs. glossing over it, and how the birth REALLY went safety-wise.