In many instances, federal judges will dispose of federal employment cases
at the summary judgment phase — and there's often not much relief on appeal.
It would be erroneous to assume that Hyrniak necessarily will foster a flood gates of decisions
at the summary judgment level.
[Expert evidence was required on causation in a legal malpractice case
at summary judgment proceeding.]
At a summary judgment hearing last week (see this report by the IDG News Service), Judge Koh already scheduled a preliminary injunction hearing for Friday, June 29.
At the summary judgment motion, the judge found that the legality of the present use of the residential apartments was a valid objection and the vendor did not establish that the residential apartments were a legal non-conforming use.
In some circumstances, such as «where it was evident that the record would be complex or voluminous,» a failure to seek directions may result in substantial indemnity costs
at summary judgment.
Noting the «full trial has become largely illusory» and Combined Air sets the summary judgment bar «too high,» Hryniak instead emphasizes the powers to weigh evidence, evaluate credibility, and draw reasonable inferences
at summary judgment are «presumptively» available to the motion judge.
This will sometimes include expert evidence on complex matters, even
at summary judgment applications.
In the recent decision of Covenoho v. Pendylum Ltd., the Ontario Court of Appeal awarded a former employee of Pendylum 40 weeks» pay ($ 56,000.00), overturning the ruling of the Motion Judge
at summary judgment.
At the summary judgment hearing the Master found in Mr Ellis's favour, stating that the circumstances of execution of the will and Mr Ellis's record of the deceased's instructions created a strong presumption in favour of the will and that the appellants» submissions had not created sufficient suspicion as to validity to rebut the presumption.
Harvard has argued that, if the case is decided
at the summary judgment stage, the only evidence that should be disclosed is that needed to make a decision.
He trained law students from Florida A&M University and other volunteer attorneys in housing counseling and foreclosure litigation; served as a liaison between Community Legal Services of Mid-Florida and the FAMU College of Law; attended Alex Sink Foreclosure Workshops throughout the CLSMF service area, coordinated efforts with other nonprofits; volunteered at foreclosure legal advice clinics where clients were provided legal advice and pro se assistance with foreclosure pleadings; appeared
at summary judgment hearings; provided full representation; co-counseled with staff attorneys; and counseled clients during mediations.
However, this inquiry may be resolved
at the summary judgment phase when the «defense is conclusively established by plain, palpable and undisputed evidence» that leave no issue of fact for a jury to determine.
Our variable of interest is whether the moving party was successful
at the summary judgment stage.
In February of 2015, Lynch Schwab successfully had a personal injury lawsuit dismissed
at the summary judgment stage.
The employee had argued unsuccessfully
at a summary judgment motion that the language of the termination clause was an attempt to contract out of the ESA because it did not specifically provide the employee with «severance» as required by the ESA.
Under F.R.Civ.P 56 declarations usually are not within the type of evidentiary categories that can be used
at the summary judgment phase.
Successfully defeated water intrusion claims of condo association
at summary judgment stage on behalf of developer
Not exact matches
The Arbitrator (i) shall apply internal laws of the State of New York consistent with the Federal Arbitration Act and applicable statutes of limitations, or, to the extent (if any) that federal law prevails, shall apply the law of the U.S., irrespective of any conflict of law principles; (ii) shall entertain any motion to dismiss, motion to strike, motion for
judgment on the pleadings, motion for complete or partial
summary judgment, motion for
summary adjudication, or any other dispositive motion consistent with New York or federal rules of procedure, as applicable; (iii) shall honor claims of privilege recognized
at law; and (iv) shall have authority to award any form of legal or equitable relief;
An Ontario Court of Appeal justice has warned against «
summary judgment at all costs» in her dissent of a ruling on the application of the doctrine of emergency in a personal injury case.
«However, the goal is not
summary judgment at all costs.
In stating in
summary fashion the Christian conception of the Kingdom of God we are not pretending that we can see perfectly what this means, nor are we saying that we can arrive
at a formal principle which can act as a rule by which all Christian value
judgments can be simply made.
13 Whitehead does not use the term
judgment at this point, but see S 50; PR 100, 260, 267; MT 181 for various
summaries of PI in which its judgmental character emerges.
At that time, the plaintiffs — adult stem cell researchers James Sherley and Theresa Deisher — expect to file what's called a motion for
summary judgment, which asks that the case be decided without a trial.
Here's a closer look
at the court's ruling on the district's and individual defendants» motion for
summary judgment for Ms. I's claims.
(c) Violation of 14th Amendment procedural due process The court granted the defendants» motion for
summary judgment for this claim, finding that Ms. I did not meet the applicable precedent, which requires
at the threshold an allegation that the reason for the forced discharge was to avoid a pre-termination hearing.
At the point where the matters of fact are determined and it has become a simple matter of law, a party can move for
summary judgment, moving to apply that matter of law to that set of facts.
Fair use is a legal defense, meaning that in order to «win» on it, you have to (a) be sued, and (b) litigate the case until
at least the
summary judgment stage.
On reflection, all of the student
judgments —
at least as reflected by Judith's
summary posted here — were very qualitative.
If there are no alternative facts submitted by the defendant, the case will be decided
at the motion for
summary judgment stage.
[18] I pause
at this juncture, to remind myself of the goals of this
summary judgment hearing.
Generally, the contents of lawyers» affidavits of this sort can be ignored on motions for
summary judgment: Victoria Mendes et al. v. Blaisdale Montessori School, 2014 ONSC 3178 (CanLII)
at para. 3, aff'd 2014 ONCA 821 (CanLII).
His memorandum in opposition to a defense motion for
summary judgment was due
at midnight.
Perhaps,
at least in
summary judgment matters, this is a response to the comments of the Manitoba Court of Appeal in Hyczkewycz v Hupe, 2016 MBCA 23 in para. 5.
Perhaps,
at least in
summary judgment matters, this is a response to the comments of the Manitoba Court of Appeal in Hyczkewycz v Hupe, 2016... [more]
Represented Braintree Laboratories
at the Federal Circuit to reverse a district court's grant of
summary judgment of noninfringement for Breckenridge Pharmaceutical, following a patent dispute concerning Breckenridge's planned generic version of Braintree's SUPREP laxative drug.
Limoges argued that the expert's affidavit was sufficient to establish duty and breach, particularly
at the
summary -
judgment phase of the proceedings.
«Having considered both parties» submissions, this order finds that good cause has not been shown to engage in a
summary judgment battle
at this time.»
Both Freeman and the Harbor Schools filed motions for
summary judgment, arguing that the three year statute of limitations on all claims had expired, as the claims accrued in the spring or summer of 1993 or
at the latest in November 1993.
At the time of trial, another co-defendant's appeal was pending of a denial of
summary judgment concerning immunity.
By order dated July 14, 2014, the motion judge, the Honourable Justice Martin S. James of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice sitting
at Ottawa, granted Mr. Arnone's motion for
summary judgment and ordered Best Theratronics to pay (i) damages equal to the gross amount of the salary Arnone would have earned until he qualified for an unreduced pension, less payments made to him to satisfy the statutory obligations of the employer, (ii) $ 65,000 representing the present value of the loss of an unreduced pension, (iii) a retirement allowance equal to 30 weeks» pay, and (iv) costs totaling $ 52,280.09.
At the motion for
summary judgment, the plaintiff had filed a letter from a third party dentist, which noted that the defendant dentists did not meet the standard of care.
The landlord moved for partial
summary judgment on the rent that had already accrued and was undisputedly owing
at the date of the motion... [more]
It has become more and more difficult to get a fair chance
at trial due to the anti-employee bias of many federal judges, including the evermore difficult standards required to get past
summary judgment.
If a growing proportion of the cases today that «should» settle but do not are those in which
at least one party is simply not prepared to settle under any circumstances, this could help to explain why litigants who resist
summary judgment are doing so all the more doggedly.
Judge Reiss granted the defendants» motion for
summary judgment, finding that «the only reasonable interpretation of that language is that it requires Killington Ltd. to provide the designated passholder free use of all ski lifts operated by Killington Ltd.
at the Killington Ski Area so long as it operates in that area... «The term corporation, she wrote, «clearly refers to the named corporations, Sherburne and Killington Ltd.» and «reveals no intention to bind Killington Ltd's successors... To the contrary, Killington Ltd.'s obligations under the passes clearly terminate with its cessation of operations in the area.»
Patent holders are successful 37 percent of the time, with a 19 percent win rate in
summary judgments and a 57 percent win rate
at trial.
The defendants contended that what the publication complained of occurred on an occasion of qualified privilege
at common law, that the claimant had no real prospect of showing the publication was malicious and that, accordingly,
summary judgment should be given for them.
The motion judge correctly ruled that, where there was no evidence that David Pearlman was in control of the vehicle
at the time of the accident or that he gave his consent to Thomas» operation of the vehicle, he was entitled to
summary judgment with respect to the negligence claim against him.
It was not appropriate to take into account the course the litigation took thereafter, and the reasons for
judgment on the
summary dismissal action given one year later, in deciding whether H met the standard of care
at the time.