Arizona, along with Indiana and Oklahoma, recently passed legislation to hold
back third graders who are not reading at grade level.
When asked where he stood on his state's initiative to hold
back third graders, educational psychologist David Berliner — the Regents Professor of Education at Arizona State University — was blunt in his assessment.
Not exact matches
Won't
Back Down Jamie Fitzpatrick (Maggie Gyllenhaal) may not have much, but that doesn't stop the single mother from giving her all to help her dyslexic,
third -
grader daughter Malia (Emily Alyn Lind) get a chance at a real education.
On top of what seemed a run of desultory news, the University of Chicago researchers reported that, over a period of two years,
third graders who were retained did just as poorly as similarly low - performing
third graders who weren't held
back.
But I'm thinking
back to my kids — the
third grader who hadn't learned to grasp a pencil and the outwardly confident ninth
grader who was hesitant to expose his difficulty reading aloud.
Support personnel work with pre-kindergarten-through-second-grade students with poorly developed reading and writing skills,
third graders who were held
back, and students moving into sixth and ninth grades.
In commenting on my recent blog post on New York City's ending of social promotion, Fred Smith points out that those
third -
graders held
back in 2004 would not have shown up in 8th grade.
Thousands of
third -
graders may have a sense of déjà vu on the first day of school this year: The number of states that require
third -
graders to be held
back if they can't read increased to 13 in the last year.
Third -
grader Valeria Sanchez sat toward the
back of her science class Tuesday, listening as her classmates asked questions about an upcoming assignment.
Another grave concern for educators is the academic gap that would be left by teacher assistants that are primarily tasked with making sure students read on grade level by the
third grade — presumably still a significant goal for Senator Berger who was a key driver in the state's Read to Achieve legislation that mandates all
third graders read on grade level or be held
back from advancing to the fourth grade.
Florida
third graders, who fail FCAT are held
back and labeled failures in the eyes of the state regardless grade point average.
At the same time, Florida also started «holding
back»
third graders who were not making reading improvement.
Florida Some Districts Threaten to Hold
Back High - Performing
Third Graders Who Refused Test http://www.tampabay.com/blogs/gradebook/florida-
third-
graders-without-reading-test-scores-have-few-options-for/2279102
Fourteen states require that
third graders be left
back based on poor reading scores.
More than half of North Carolina's
third graders could be held
back this year as districts work to implement the state's new «Read to Achieve» law.
Legislators are also expected to vote today on other bills supported by Gov. Phil Bryant, including a teacher merit pay pilot program and a literacy bill would hold most
third -
graders back from advancing to the next grade if they are not on reading level.
But
third graders can still be held
back if they don't pass a reading test, and high school students will still have to pass a 10th - grade test to graduate.
Gov. Rick Snyder today signed legislation — approved by the Michigan Legislature last month — that would require schools to hold
back third -
graders who are more than a grade level behind in the subject.
Not all
third -
graders who are behind would be held
back, though.
Most school districts and administrators agree that, rather than simply retaining
third graders who are not reading on grade level, the better option is to identify struggling students prior to
third grade and provide academic supports and remedial classes to help them get
back on track.