While some Vergara supporters, maybe most, will want teachers evaluated on
the basis of student test scores, I'm not one of them.
The bill, like Senate Bill 6, requires school systems to evaluate and pay teachers primarily on
the basis of student test scores, which assessment experts say is an ineffective evaluation method.
In addition, the U.S. Department of Education strongly pressured states to adopt controversial policies expanding charter schools and measuring teacher effectiveness on
the basis of student test scores.
Not exact matches
Among the 18 countries in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development's assessment, the U.S. ranked at best eighth and at worst 12th,
based on the range
of scores from its 1,133
students tested.
He spearheaded the creation
of new teacher evaluations allowing half
of a teacher's rating to be
based on
students» standardized
test scores.
The type
of learning you're describing, with open classroom discussion, a lot
of choice for
students, inquiry -
based learning, projects, it seems at odds with the kind
of call - and - response, very teacher - directed style that you see at a lot
of so - called «no excuses» charter schools that produce high
test scores with disadvantaged populations.
There are too many problems with standardized
tests — how they are constructed, the baggage
students bring into the
testing room from their regular lives, etc. — to make any serious decisions
based on their
score of a single
test.
Approximately 30,000
students will take up to three - hour - long field
tests for new Common Core -
based exams starting Monday — a week ahead
of official state exams that will count
students»
scores in math and English.
Cuomo and lawmakers approve stricter rules raising the portion
of teachers» evaluations
based on
student test scores to approximately 50 percent.
Over the past five years, Duncan has used a combination
of financial incentives and regulatory waivers to push the use
of teacher performance ratings
based partly on
student test scores.
At least going by his rhetoric, he seems to have almost declared war on the teacher unions and he has proposed a new system
of evaluation, which is more heavily
based on
students»
tests scores than the one currently in use.
Most academic studies find that teachers account for between 1 percent and 14 percent
of variability in
student test scores, while Cuomo wants to
base 50 percent
of teacher evaluations on
test scores.
His proposals to determine the fate
of teachers» pay and jobs and schools» funding and survival
based on
students» standardized
test scores look like more pay - to - play politics in Albany.
Going forward, move toward
basing teachers» and principals» ratings, in part, on a 3 - year average
of student test scores.
20 %
of teacher evaluations will be
based on
student scores on standardized
tests, and another 20 %
of the teacher's grade will be
based on standardized
test scores, but there will be some leeway for interpreting those
test scores.
About 38,000 teachers, or 20 percent, had one - fifth
of their evaluations
based on their
students»
scores in the fourth - through eighth - grade English and math
tests.
He spearheaded the creation
of new teacher evaluations allowing half
of a teacher's rating to be
based on
students» standardized
test scores.
The law, which
bases as much as 50 percent
of teachers» job ratings on
student test scores, was strengthened during a time when more rigorous standardized exams,
based on the national Common Core academic standards, were being introduced into classrooms.
ALBANY — A drive to repeal New York's legal requirement
basing teacher job ratings largely on
students» state
tests scores ignited debate Monday over the question
of whether repeal could mean «double
testing» for
students.
7:15 pm: Juan asks DioGuardi: The NYC Department
of Education is poised to release to the public in the coming weeks Teacher Data Reports, which are
based on
student scores on state
tests.
The contract cemented the practice
of evaluating teachers
based on
students»
test scores.
EDUCATION Mr. Cuomo proposed a new teacher rating system that would
base 50 percent
of an instructor's evaluation on
student test scores — an increase from 20 percent.
Under his reform plan, Mr. Cuomo is suggesting that 50 percent
of teacher assessments be
based on
student test scores instead
of the current 20 percent.
Some 20 percent
of the evaluation (25 percent after two years) would be
based on
student scores on standardized
tests.
Included among the proposed reforms is a teacher evaluation system
based half on
student test scores, an increase in the length
of time before a teacher is eligible for tenure and allowing the state to take over failing schools and districts.
Whatever the parties negotiate or King decides, the evaluation system will be
based 20 percent on standardized
test scores when applicable, 20 percent on other evidence
of student learning and 60 percent on classroom observation and other measures
of teacher effectiveness, in keeping with the 2010 state law on teacher evaluation.
Contreras said no more than 30 percent
of teacher evaluations should be
based on
student test scores.
Students of teachers using Cognitive Tutor, a computer - based curriculum for Algebra I students developed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers, for a second year showed a meaningful improvement in test
Students of teachers using Cognitive Tutor, a computer -
based curriculum for Algebra I
students developed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers, for a second year showed a meaningful improvement in test
students developed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers, for a second year showed a meaningful improvement in
test scores.
Based on a study of more than 30,000 elementary, middle, and high school students conducted in winter 2015 - 16, researchers found that elementary and middle school students scored lower on a computer - based test that did not allow them to return to previous items than on two comparable tests — paper - or computer - based — that allowed them to skip, review, and change previous respo
Based on a study
of more than 30,000 elementary, middle, and high school
students conducted in winter 2015 - 16, researchers found that elementary and middle school
students scored lower on a computer -
based test that did not allow them to return to previous items than on two comparable tests — paper - or computer - based — that allowed them to skip, review, and change previous respo
based test that did not allow them to return to previous items than on two comparable
tests — paper - or computer -
based — that allowed them to skip, review, and change previous respo
based — that allowed them to skip, review, and change previous responses.
Urban
students in grades seven and eight who were engaged in the LeTUS inquiry -
based science curriculum demonstrated higher standardized
test scores than
students engaged in traditional instruction in a sample
of 5,000
students.
Using
student - level data from two states, Harvard Professor Martin West and I found that 40 to 60 percent
of schools serving mostly low - income or underrepresented minority
students would fall into the bottom 15 percent
of schools statewide
based on their average
test scores, but only 15 to 25 percent
of these same schools would be classified as low performing
based on their
test -
score growth.
Now, results from the
tests students took last spring won't be available until at least February after the state school board discovered a problem that led to incorrect
scores on the science portion
of the 11th grade
test, graded by San Antonio -
based Harcourt Assessment.
A teacher in New York State is considered to be ineffective
based on her
students»
test score growth if her value - added
score is more than 1.5 standard deviations below average (i.e., in the bottom seven percent
of teachers).
But, as numerous studies have shown, having a master's degree is generally not correlated with measures
of teacher effectiveness,
based on
student test scores.
He criticizes the federal law for
basing school accountability on a single year's
test scores and holding schools accountable for the performance
of transient
students.
After extensive research on teacher evaluation procedures, the Measures
of Effective Teaching Project mentions three different measures to provide teachers with feedback for growth: (1) classroom observations by peer - colleagues using validated scales such as the Framework for Teaching or the Classroom Assessment
Scoring System, further described in Gathering Feedback for Teaching (PDF) and Learning About Teaching (PDF), (2)
student evaluations using the Tripod survey developed by Ron Ferguson from Harvard, which measures
students» perceptions
of teachers» ability to care, control, clarify, challenge, captivate, confer, and consolidate, and (3) growth in
student learning
based on standardized
test scores over multiple years.
Schools were assigned an overall rating
based on the pass rate
of the lowest -
scoring subgroup -
test combination (e.g., math for whites), giving some schools strong incentives to focus on particular
students and subjects.
Evaluations led by Harvard's Tom Kane and MIT's Josh Angrist have used this lottery -
based method to convince most skeptics that the impressive
test -
score performance
of the Boston charter sector reflects real differences in school quality rather than the types
of students charter schools serve.
The state wants 80 percent
of all
students and
student subgroups to
score at a level demonstrating that they are on track for postsecondary readiness by 2024 - 25,
based on state
tests; also wants all
students and
student subgroups to graduate at a 90 percent clip by the same year.
Since the Texas state
test was a
test of basic skills, and the accountability metric is
based on pass rates, schools had strong incentives to focus on helping lower -
scoring students.
The NEPC report paints a dismal picture
of student learning at K12 - operated schools, but the fatal flaw
of the report is that the measures
of «performance» it employs are
based primarily on outcomes such as
test scores that may reveal more about
student background than about the quality
of the school, and on inappropriate comparisons between virtual schools and all schools in the same state.
By 2029, 80 percent
of students achieving a
test -
based grade - level proficiency
score.
Westinghouse Information Service, a
scoring contractor
based in Iowa City, Iowa, blamed «computer error» for mistakes in the
scores of the Arizona
students in grades 1 through 12 who took the California Achievement
Test in April.
This statistically significant difference
of -0.23 standard deviations is in the opposite direction
of that expected,
based on the
student - level relationships between self - control and
test -
score gains displayed above.
Since 1997, states have picked up the pace
of their standards -
based reforms, and
test scores for minority and low - income
students, in particular, have improved.
In an article for The 74, the new reform - oriented education news website launched by Campbell Brown, Matt Barnum looks at the impact
of the Obama administration's decision, in 2009, to push states applying for Race to the Top funds to evaluate all teachers
based in part on
student test scores.
In response to the criticism that teacher impacts on
student test scores are inconsistent over time, the authors show that «although VA measures fluctuate across years, they are sufficiently stable» that selecting teachers even
based on a few years
of data would have substantial impacts on
student outcomes, such as earnings.
As critics contend, the state's aggregate
test -
score improvements on the 4th - grade FCAT reading exam — and likely on the NAEP exam as well — are inflated by the change in the number
of students who were retained in 3rd grade in accordance with the state's new
test -
based promotion policy.
The report, released last week by the U.S. Department
of Education, is
based on 4th grade
scores from the National Assessment
of Educational Progress, a set
of federally mandated
tests given periodically to nationally representative samples
of students.
In most cases, he argues, claims
of effective reforms are
based on either a misanalysis
of test scores or the selection
of advantaged
students into reform programs.