If the state has substantial evidence against you, I will go into negotiating mode, working with the prosecutor to obtain a plea bargain that is
below mandatory sentencing.
Judges have limited discretion to sentence
below a mandatory sentence, even when evidence supports doing so.
Not exact matches
Any point total over 44 points means that a state prison
sentence must be imposed unless the prosecutors agree or the judge chooses to depart
below the
mandatory prison term as called for by legal guidelines.
Wrong as the court's order may be under Montana law (and it seems from the press coverage and statements by attorneys involved that the
sentence is unlawful as it is far
below the
mandatory minimum), the judge can not just change his ruling.
R v. Nasogaluak, 2010 SCC 6 where Andrew Lokan and Danny Kastner represented the Canadian Civil Liberties Association at the Supreme Court of Canada and successfully argued that
sentence reductions, even
below mandatory minimum
sentences, ought to be available as a remedy for unconstitutional state conduct in the criminal justice process.
«The Court of Appeal said that that was a perfectly appropriate type of
sentence and that there was no reason to go
below that
mandatory minimum, nor could they think of a scenario where it could be warranted,» says Brown.
Well... I think Thomas's closing was just a little sloppy — he should have said that the the judge made two errors: using judicial fact finding to boost the
sentence and then going
below a
mandatory guideline regime.
Bellin's piece, headlined «Waiting for Justice: One man's seven - year wait for a trial reveals the ways
mandatory minimums distort our courts,» spotlights how
mandatory minimum
sentencing statutes lurked
below this (not - so) remarkable case.
Earlier this year I started to correspond with Caleb Mason concerning his effort to preserve a
sentence imposed
below a federal
mandatory minimum in the face of a government appeal.
The safety valve also restores a partial measure of judicial discretion, allowing a judge to
sentence below a statutory
mandatory minimum, should the judge believe the
sentence is too harsh for the offense committed...
In relation to native title see: ibid, pp128 - 132; Native title report 1999, Chapter 2; In relation to
mandatory sentencing: see
below.