On the contrary, the Duke report noted, comparable students who remain in public schools are scoring
better than voucher students on national tests.
Not exact matches
Who
better to put money into your brilliant business idea
than people who can already
vouch for you?
Recent analysis of the widely followed
voucher experiment in Milwaukee shows that low - income minority students who attended private schools scored substantially
better in reading and math after four years
than those who remained in public schools.
Like Spence he is skeptical that mixed - income projects will ever meet the needs of more
than a tiny proportion of the poor, and he suggests that the
best, though imperfect, policy might be a system of housing
vouchers that disperses the poor by providing them with a subsidy with which to seek housing in the private market.
On the one hand, you could argue that a restaurant
voucher is
better than a teacher simply handing out junk food rewards since, with a
voucher, some intervening parental oversight is required.
Having done this kind of work myself for many years in San Francisco, I can
vouch for how frustrating it can be, and yet, as a parent or guardian who really wants to make a difference in nutrition and health for an enormous number of children, there is really no
better opportunity
than serving on your local school nutrition parent advisory council.
Mr. Schneiderman said he voted in favor of the
voucher program, which involves providing homeless sex offenders $ 90 a night to stay in a motel, even though he didn't like it because he believed it was a
better plan
than the current trailer policy.
«Insurance companies are experts at assessing risk and should have known
better than to
vouch for bad institutions that harbor sexual predators,» said State Assemblymember Linda B. Rosenthal.
More
than 700,000 students in more
than 1,200 New York City schools — including large high schools in all five boroughs — would face higher class sizes, have fewer teachers and lose after - school academic and enrichment programs if President - elect Trump makes
good on a campaign promise to pull billions of federal dollars away from public schools to pay for private
vouchers, a UFT analysis has found.
«Who
better to
vouch for a casino operator with a string of legal problems
than David Paterson, architect of the Aqueduct fiasco,» a casino industry insider said.
Why would shopping
vouchers be more of an incentive
than their child's
well - being?
Sure, environmentalists, outdoor adventurers, and camping enthusiasts will
vouch for the restorative powers of nature any day of the week, but there is no
better way to reconnect with the earth
than at the dawn of a new year.
This is the first cruelty free brush of this type I have used, so I can't
vouch for that part BUT I can say that this works much
better than the hair type kabuki brushes I owned in the past.
And who
better to
vouch for embracing curves
than Khloé Kardashian herself?
Education savings accounts operate like the «partial
voucher» that Friedman envisioned more
than a decade ago, allowing families to seek out the
best educational opportunities for their students — whether those be in a private or parochial school or a mix of non-traditional education options.
From James Coleman's early observational studies of high schools to the experimental
voucher evaluations of the past 15 years, researchers have routinely found that similar students do at least as
well and, at times,
better academically in private schools
than in public schools.
[3] Would poor students using
vouchers to attend private schools do
better than if they remained in their public systems?
But 56 percent of independents thought teacher unions had «done more harm
than good,» 54 percent supported school
vouchers, and only 34 percent favored raising teacher salaries, once they had been informed about average salary levels in their state.
In fact, there have been seven scientifically valid random - assignment analyses of
voucher programs, and all seven found either that all
voucher students perform significantly
better than their nonvoucher contemporaries, or at least that most of them do (in some studies the results for black students, the majority of participants, are positive, while the results for other students fail to achieve statistical significance).
Such a strategy also calls for researchers to ask more nuanced questions
than simply whether or not
voucher programs are
better than public school programs.
Interpretaton: EdNext finds public opinion closely divided on the issue, whereas PDK finds a
better than 2:1 split against
vouchers.
So, twenty years after the enactment of Milwaukee's program, a growing body of research shows that students receiving
vouchers do as
well and often
better than their peers in public schools and at a fraction of the taxpayer cost.
None of the independent studies performed of the most lauded and long standing
voucher programs extant in the U.S. — Milwaukee, Wisconsin; Cleveland, Ohio; and Washington, D.C. — found any statistical evidence that children who utilized
vouchers performed
better than children who did not and remained in public schools.
That increased by 4 percentage points if the student received the offer of a
voucher, a
better than 100 percent increment in the percentage enrolled in a selective college, a very large increment from a very low baseline.
The principle of education for the common
good is more important now
than ever, as school systems across the United States become more plural through charter schools, tax credits,
vouchers, and education savings accounts.
Though Fordham's accountability plan for
voucher schools is
well - intentioned, their justifications are unpersuasive and their proposal is more likely to do harm
than good.
Although the promise and potential of parental choice is nowhere more evident
than in the realm of technology, the arguments for allowing students ready access to cyberschools extend to interdistrict school choice, charter schools, private schools, and
vouchers as
well.
Four recent rigorous studies — in the District of Columbia, Louisiana, Indiana, and Ohio — used different research designs and reached the same result: on average, students that use
vouchers to attend private schools do less
well on tests
than similar students that do not attend private schools.
«Rather
than using taxpayer dollars to provide
vouchers to a few, we must focus our resources and efforts on concrete reforms that make our public schools
better for all of the District's schoolchildren.»
The four different studies use four different designs but arrive at the same result: on average, students that use
vouchers to attend private schools do less
well on tests
than similar students that do not attend private schools.
The fact that Milwaukee
voucher students advanced through their college years at
better rates
than the comparison group indicates that their higher high - school graduation rate was not driven by possibly - lower diploma standards in the private - school sector.
Also, students in
voucher - accepting schools systematically could do
better than lottery losers and still
vouchers might lower overall system performance.
Friedman would have allowed schools to charge parents more in tuition
than what a
voucher could cover, potentially allowing rich parents to send their kids to
better - resourced schools
than poor parents could.
From a policy - maker's point of voew the important issue is not whether private schools out - perform government schools in the education of students who want out (
voucher applicants), but whether choice systems as a whole perform
better than systems which do not feature choice.
Allowing for possible differences in student bodies, those students opting out of government schools through a
voucher program on average score
better than those who apply for
vouchers but do not receive them.
School
vouchers never had a
better friend
than Peter Flanigan.
First, he uses a 2002 GAO study to say that students who receive
vouchers fare no
better than comparable public school students, even though a veritable mountain of evidence to the contrary has been published since then.
But students who use
vouchers or attend charter schools generally do no
better academically
than comparable students who remain in regular public schools.
The Scranton Times - Tribune editorial board says that
vouchers aren't perfect, but they're
better than the status quo.
Still Milwaukee public school students fared
better than those students who received
vouchers to attend private and charter schools.
She chose it because it was across the street from the Catholic school for boys that her son attends, also with a
voucher, and it seemed
better than a neighborhood public school that has failed for years to meet achievement targets.
Weil's family would not qualify for the
voucher program, which is advertised as a way for students from low - income families to get into schools that may be a
better fit for them
than what the public school system offers.
Report after report proves that public schools provide more opportunities and students there perform
better than those in
voucher schools,» said WEAC president Betsy Kippers in a statement.
Vouchers» dollar amounts are significantly lower
than the amounts public schools spend per - student and yet
voucher programs often achieve
better results.
The researchers were only 91 percent certain (statistically) that the
better performance of
voucher - program students was due to the program rather
than chance, and they had to be 95 percent certain.
There is no clear evidence that demonstrates students who receive
vouchers and attend private schools perform
better than students who attend public schools.
Hopefully it will provide a window into whether or not
voucher students are experiencing
better learning gains
than public school students.
That's not the same as saying a little more
than half came from private schools, but either way it's definitely a
better deal for taxpayers
than having to pay tuition for the 73 percent of students in the expanded statewide
voucher program whose families were already sending their kids to private school.
Although why that's any
better for students
than eviscerating teachers unions and expanding
vouchers is also something I have yet to figure out.
The answer to that is about as muddled as the answer to whether
voucher schools provide an educational product that is any
better, on the whole,
than the one provided by public schools.