This is due to the premise of
bitcoin being legal tender.
Not exact matches
In order for
bitcoin to
be a real currency, Adeney claims, it must
be three things: easy and frictionless for trading between people, widely accepted as a
legal tender for all debts (both public and private) and stable in terms of value.
In Japan,
Bitcoin has
been recognized as
legal tender, and financial regulators have officially recognized multiple cryptocurrency exchange operators.
Russia previously revealed that its central bank
was developing a national cryptocurrency and that it would not recognize others like
bitcoin as
legal tender.
So
Bitcoin gets none of the benefits of
being a currency in the state of New Jersey, but all of the downside of
being «
legal tender».
Bitcoin is not
legal tender, so it should not
be just another revenue stream for the state.
Last April, Japanese authorities acknowledged
bitcoin as a
legal tender and stated that they would entail cryptocurrency exchanges to register with the Government.There
are 16 cryptocurrency exchanges in Japan which have registered with Japan's Financial Services Agency (FSA).
Since
bitcoin is not yet considered
legal tender in Germany, employers using PEY will
be able to offer
bitcoin as a tax - free benefit to their employees.
Finance minister going all out against
Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies
is definitely a reason for grave concern for the Indian cryptocurrency investors as he said that the government does not consider these virtual currencies as a
legal tender.
Besides
legal tenders such as Dollar, Ruble, Euro, RMB, and virtual currencies such as
Bitcoin, Litecoin, LNC also can
be exchanged with indirect currencies such as gold, silver and valuable financial derivatives.
However,
bitcoin can not
be placed in the same category since it
is not
legal tender and has very few uses outside its trading zone, thereby making investors holding the currency that has zero value extremely vulnerable to potential risks.
The Judgment C - 264 / 14 declared that
bitcoin and cryptocurrencies
are VAT exempt as currency, although not
legal tender.
«As part of the new Regulations, an official joint announcement will
be released during the upcoming PBOC press conference making it clear that neither the People's Bank of China nor the Hong Kong Monetary Authority recognises
Bitcoin or any other virtual currency as
legal tender, thus, making its use as an official currency to settle debts and financial obligations illegal.
[65] It classified digital currencies and other digital payment systems such as
bitcoin as «virtual currencies» because they
are not
legal tender under any sovereign jurisdiction.
On 5 December 2013, the People's Bank of China announced in a press release regarding
bitcoin regulation that whilst individuals in China
are permitted to freely trade and exchange
bitcoins as a commodity, it
is prohibited for Chinese financial banks to operate using
bitcoins or for
bitcoins to
be used as
legal tender currency, and that entities dealing with
bitcoins must track and report suspicious activity to prevent money laundering.
A gift of virtual currency, such as
bitcoin, to charity or a donor - advised fund
is not recognized by the IRS as
legal tender.
2 stating «
Bitcoin and other virtual currencies
are distinct from «real» currencies, which
are the coin and paper money of the United States or another country that
are designated as
legal tender, circulate, and
are customarily used and accepted as a medium of exchange in the country of issuance.»
«The CBN reiterates that the VCs such as
bitcoin, ripples, monero, litecoin, dogecion, onecoin, etc and similar products
are not
legal tenders in Nigeria, thus any bank or institution that transacts in such businesses does so as its own risk.»
There
are only two fundamental differences between
bitcoin and national currencies: (1)
bitcoin is issued by an algorithm rather than a central bank so predictable machines rather than arbitrary humans control the «printing» and the total amount of
bitcoin; (2) creditors can sue you if you present
bitcoin to settle a debt denominated in national currency but if you present the currency it will
be a defence to the creditor's suit under some form of a «
legal tender» statute (Currency Act, RSC 1985, c C - 52 in Canada; 31 U.S. Code § 5103 in the US).
In April 2017 the government declared that
bitcoin was officially accepted as a
legal tender.
The Indian government
is unlikely to criminalize the holding and trading of cryptocurrencies, especially now that world leaders such as Japan and Germany have already embraced their use as
legal tender, with the United States only recently announcing the launch of
bitcoin futures in November 2017.
Japan also set its own precedent in the understanding of
Bitcoin as back in April it
was announced that
Bitcoin was accepted as
legal tender, instantly showing a positive approach from the government.
Digital currency such as
Bitcoin is not
legal tender.
India has said it doesn't consider
Bitcoin to
be legal tender, China
is increasingly cracking down on digital currencies, while Korea
is planning a bill to ban all domestic cryptocurrency trading.
In January 2018, India's Finance Minister Arun Jaitley told the Indian parliament, «
Bitcoins or such cryptocurrencies
are not
legal tender and those indulging in such transactions
are doing it at their own risk.»
the Indian parliament, «
Bitcoins or such cryptocurrencies
are not
legal tender and those indulging in such transactions
are doing it at their own risk.»
Many have
been reluctant to work with startups that use
bitcoin technology in the past, but as the FCA announced it
is OK with its licensed payment companies using
bitcoin technology and Japan making
bitcoin legal tender igniting a boom of investment from Japanese financial institutions, the global trend must also now reach African banks and MNOs.»
In Japan,
Bitcoin is already treated as
legal tender, while Russia
is currently drafting legislation to regulate cryptocurrencies and ICOs.
Unlike illegal, counterfeit money, which
is a blatant example of a «currency» that misrepresents itself as
legal tender,
Bitcoin is entirely different.
Regulators in India have repeatedly targeted cryptocurrency exchanges and commented that
bitcoin and digital currencies
are not «
legal tender.»
On Nov. 30, 2017, when investor frenzy
was at a high with rising
bitcoin prices, finance minister Arun Jaitley said the country doesn't recognise cryptocurrencies as
legal tender.
Bitcoin was legalized in Australia and
is now a
legal tender of money.
Japan's Financial Services Agency stated that Coincheck's deposit service
is exempt from the country's banking regulations as
bitcoin is not
legal tender.
In an ICO a percentage of the newly issued cryptocurrency
is sold to investors in exchange for
legal tender or other cryptocurrencies such as
Bitcoin.
In an ICO campaign, a percentage of the cryptocurrency
is sold to early backers of the project in exchange for
legal tender or other cryptocurrencies, but usually for
Bitcoin.
By not recognising cryptocurrencies as
legal tender in India simply means that digital currencies like
Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc can not
be used to buy / sell goods and services.
Overall Indian
Bitcoin market
is positive and Indian Government may recognize
Bitcoin as
legal tender.
Looking at Japan other countries
are also starting to recognize
Bitcoin as a
legal tender of money.
India has still yet to give it
's decision regarding regulation of
Bitcoin and it
's acceptance as
legal tender of money.
«
Bitcoin may not qualify as currency or money as it
is not a
legal tender for Indian indirect tax laws.
The final resolution about
Bitcoin being considered as
legal tender was passed on April 2017.
It said while it has taken notice of recent developments in the use, holding, and trading of virtual or digital currencies (also known as cryptocurrencies), such as
Bitcoin in Ghana, it
is not
legal tender and it
is not regulated.
Countries such as Japan and the Philippines have completely legalized
Bitcoin as
legal tender and
are set to drop any special taxes for
Bitcoin investors.
The press release put forth from the PBOC today outlines that there
is significant volatility in
bitcoin trading, and also quoted from a notice released in 2013 saying that
bitcoin is a virtual good and doesn't have
legal tender status.
Overall, the public statements aimed to serve as a reminder to citizens who may
be considering the digital currency as an investment, and both quoted a government circular released in 2013 saying that
bitcoin is a virtual good and doesn't have
legal tender status.
The country's central bank released an initial warning in February and has followed up with repeated statements that
bitcoin and other digital currencies
are not
legal tender or a permitted means of payment in Vietnam.
Bitcoin prices
are continuously rising and the major reasons for it
is countries around the world
are starting to recognize it as a
legal tender of money.
On January 2, 2018, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley answered questions before Indian parliament, in which he stated that «
bitcoins or such cryptocurrencies
are not
legal tender and those indulging in such transactions
are doing it at their own risk.»
questions before Indian parliament, in which he stated that «
bitcoins or such cryptocurrencies
are not
legal tender and those indulging in such transactions
are doing it at their own risk.»
That does not, however, mean that
bitcoin is «
legal tender» - so far, only Japan has gone as far as to give
bitcoin that designation.