Some notes, or questions I am going to anticipate and try to answer before they are asked: I bought
the brown cupcake liners at the New York Cake & Baking Supply on 22nd Street (and wow, do I miss only living a few blocks from there) but they're also available on Amazon and from many other online baking supply shops.
First of all, you'll need dark
brown cupcake liners for the regular and mini-muffin sized cupcakes so that they nicely match the Reese's wrappers.
Not exact matches
I also like using these
brown mini
cupcake liners to make them look more official, but you can use any kind you like!
Pull out some
liners that match our theme (I use Wilton Color Cups as they hold their color and never turn
brown) and line your
cupcake pans.