With this in mind, it becomes apparent that the «slight shock» delivered
by dog shock collars isn't all that slight after all.
For example, dogs that have issues responding to positive reinforcement methodologies may respond exceptionally well to the delivery of sounds, vibrations, light effects, or even static electricity produced
by dog shock collars.
Not exact matches
A recent study
by researchers at the University of Lincoln in the UK found that
dogs who had
shock collars showed significantly more symptoms of distress.
As a controversial training tool,
shock collars preferred
by most professional trainers to suppress the unwanted behavior of your
dog.
GoodBoy No Bark
Collar For Small To Medium
Dogs by Waterproof Anti Bark Training
Collar - Best Selling On Amazon — Safe, No
Shock Design With No Spiky Prongs — Updated LCD Display (7 + lbs)
GoodBoy
Dog Bark
Collar For Small Medium And Large
Dogs by Pet Anti Bark Device With 7 level Sound And
Shock System To Control or Stop Your Pups» Excessive Barking (12 + lbs)
Doggy Dan «s video course is the world's ONLY video - based
dog training website, endorsed
by the SPCA, and constantly updated
by a professional
dog trainer which firmly stands against the use of
shock collars and sprays.
The electric
shock from these remote
dog training
collars is initiated
by the owner or a
dog trainer who holds a remote - control device.
Moreover, another big study (13) conducted
by Cooper et al. on the welfare of
dogs and the use of e-
collars has found a clear risk the use of
dog shock collars presents.
A study
by Blackwell et al. (7) has analyzed the use of
dog training
collars and came to the conclusion that, as the above graph shows,
dog owners are most often confused or ignorant about the aspects of
dog training, including differences between negative and positive punishment, and negative and positive reinforcement, which was observed as the main reason to choose the use of
dog shock collars for training.
Dog shock collars are designed to help eliminate this unwanted behavior
by providing a negative stimulus each time the barking begins.
The
collars are used on
dogs by some to give an electric
shock when the
dog is deemed to be behaving incorrectly.
Some advocate
dog shock collars by claiming that if they were «so bad» they wouldn't be allowed to be sold.
A YouGov survey about electric
shock collars, commissioned
by the Kennel Club in 2009, that 70 % disapproved of the use of electric
shock collars on
dogs, with only 9 % of people approving of their use.
I've thoroughly reviewed Blackwell's study and several accompanying papers, have taken an extensive look at all claimed negative consequences of
dog shock collars and whether there's some good scientific evidence on the pros of using
dog training
collars aside from the arguments made
by author Steven R Lindsay.
But as indicated in the Blackwell's study, the primary problem is that most
dog owners are unaware of the strength of these
dog shock collars, and have no idea the pain a certain level of
shock may deliver to the
dog, or
by how much they are increasing the strength when turning it up and what the delivered
shock actually does to the
dog (10).
Force Free
dog training (the one that really bothers me since it is also used
by a company that produces
shock collars)
I have seen instances in which a
dog wearing a fence
collar was inadvertently
shocked by the owner's television, computer or vacuum.
When used to control barking,
dog training
shock collars should be accompanied
by a behavior modification program
The Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) funded two pieces of research on electric
shock collars which were published last summer and show that electric
shock collars can cause long term negative behavioural and physiological changes in
dogs, even when used
by professional trainers following an industry set standard of training.
I didn't have to coax
dog trainer (certified
by many groups including Karen Pryor Academy), and certified animal behavior consultant Laura Monaco Torelli into saying you NEVER need to use a
shock collar on a
dog.
For instance, bark
collars may train a
dog not to bark
by emitting a
shock, aversive spray or an ultrasonic sound the moment the
dog barks.
Bark
collars punish your
dog for barking
by emitting an irritating, high - pitched sound, a spray of citronella, or delivering a painful static
shock via metal prongs on your
dog's neck.
These
collars are triggered
by markers and will eventually give the continuing
dog an electric
shock or a spray of some sort.
Furthermore, studies
by the Animal Behavior Clinic at Cornell's College of Veterinary Medicine suggest that citronella
dog collars are even more effective than electric
shock collars.
Punishments such as leash jerks and
collar corrections, hitting, poking, «nudging,» kicking, hanging
by the
collar, or using electric
shock or spray
collars may be effective in suppressing behavior at that moment, but these tools and techniques do little to solve the problem in the long term and can make a
dog's behavior much worse in the future.
Staffies in particular are prone to
dog aggression (I have had them for years, I'm not some hater) and
shock collars can lead to them associating other
dogs with pain and therefore becoming aggressive if approached
by another
dog.
Once set to «
shock» mode, there are usually varying levels of intensity delivered
by a two - pronged device attached to a
dog collar.
With boundary training (often marketed as an electric fence or an invisible fence), the
shock collar is triggered
by wires placed underground along the property line so the
dog learns exactly how far they can go before they reach the boundary.
These days,
shock collars are often used to curb a variety of stubborn and unwanted behaviors in family
dogs, from excessive barking to food aggression, as well as to train pups to stay safely within a property line or to stick close
by while off leash.
Training
dogs by scaring or hurting them through physical intimidation using choke, prong, or electric
shock collars, «alpha» rolls, muzzle grabs, or throwing things (chains, water balloons) at
dogs can slow training, damage the human /
dog relationship, and contribute to the development of aggression as self - defense for the
dog.
Shock Collars / Electronic Collars often called remote or e-collars collars by advocates, and shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a correc
Shock Collars / Electronic Collars often called remote or e-collars collars by advocates, and shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a corr
Collars / Electronic
Collars often called remote or e-collars collars by advocates, and shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a corr
Collars often called remote or e-
collars collars by advocates, and shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a corr
collars collars by advocates, and shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a corr
collars by advocates, and
shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a correc
shock collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the dog when given a corr
collars by detractors, are devices that deliver an electrical stimulus causing pain to the
dog when given a correction.
That being said, we don't know of any severe injuries or deaths caused
by no - bark
collars, and if the
dog learns not to bark, it won't be
shocked anymore.