Updated, July 23, 1:40 p.m. A new study of methods used to track Antarctic sea ice trends has raised important questions about whether recent increases in ice there are, to a significant extent, an illusion created
by flawed analysis of data collected by a series of satellites.
Not exact matches
In what one software engineer calls «the most demonically clever computer security attack I've seen in years,» researchers at the University of Michigan have developed a way to insert a hidden security
flaw into a microprocessor chip that can't be detected
by any known method of security
analysis.
Even
by the hedge fund's own
flawed analysis, DuPont under Kullman has been a profit machine.
Americans for Annuity Protection has engaged in active outreach to leaders of influence to establish the argument that the DOL's fiduciary rule should be returned because of the
analysis performed
by the department is
flawed, inconclusive and arbitrary; it is not compatible with the Uniform Security Law or established insurance law, and the law has potential conflict with the Dodd - Frank requirements to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on reviewing a uniform fiduciary standard.
While most laypeople won't likely want to read the entire
analysis and rebuttal of Wax's work, it is significant because these researchers pretty much refute all of Wax's work and show, step
by step, how
flawed the study was and how referencing this study as a basis for decision making is also
flawed.
This means that any individual
flaw or bias in any one article gets weighed out
by the many other studies in the meta -
analysis.
Last week, the Monkey Cage published a post
by Alexander Motyl, a Ukrainian specialist at Rutgers - Newark, on the Five fatal
flaws in realist
analysis of Russia and Ukraine.
Financial secretary to the Treasury Mark Hoban told Channel 4 News the IFS report was «selective», with «
flawed assumptions» and stressed that the government stood
by its initial
analysis that the budget was «fair and progressive».
Your readers may want to know that the interpretation and
analysis provided
by geologist Tom Rockwell, and on which the story is based, is in our view both
flawed and highly editorialised.
• GLOBAL WARMING Physicist Richard A. Muller, although convinced that climate change is real, potentially dangerous and probably caused in part
by humans, has disagreed with many climate scientists, asserting that their measurements and
analyses are deeply
flawed.
Among the areas determined to be
flawed and in need of more research are: accuracy and error rates of forensic
analyses, sources of potential bias and human error in interpretation
by forensic experts, fingerprints, firearms examination, tool marks, bite marks, impressions (tires, footwear), bloodstain - pattern
analysis, handwriting, hair, coatings (for example, paint), chemicals (including drugs), materials (including fibers), fluids, serology, and fire and explosive
analysis.
Now a study
by MIT linguistics professors and a team from Carleton University, based on an experiment with children between the ages of 3 and 6, proposes a new explanation, with a twist: In examining this apparent
flaw, the researchers conclude that children deploy a more sophisticated mode of logical
analysis than many experts have previously realized.
However, according to a new
analysis, the apparent paradox may be explained
by the simple fact that BMI is a very
flawed measurement.
In addition, the pre-A-Plus Florida
analysis reported
by the Economic Policy Institute is plagued
by several research design
flaws.
«The new
analysis from the Productivity Commission highlights the way enrolments have been calculated to date meant they could be
flawed by showing all students in the year before school had been enrolled
by comparing four and five year olds in preschool with just the population of four year olds.»
The
flaw of selection on dependent variable
analyses is so obvious that it is shocking that education policy debates continue to be shaped
by them.
Our
analysis of its workings in Florida reveals it to be badly
flawed and not as accurate as the measuring stick employed
by the state of Florida for similar purposes.
However, as pointed out
by several other witnesses, since the key performance measure used
by these entities is student performance on the STAAR test, which many consider a
flawed measure, the resulting productivity / efficiency
analysis would be
flawed as well.
And
flawed educational research conclusions have been made
by using poverty in data
analyses.
But the media blurbs that followed the report's publication fail to dig into the
flawed analyses and vacuous recommendations pitched
by its authors, Professors Gary Orfield, Jongyeon Ee and Ryan Coughlan Guttman.
«A 1990 report produced
by the Energy Department's Sandia National Laboratories broke down the
flaws in the «A Nation at Risk»
analysis but got little attention.
The report is recommended
by education historian and school privatization opponent Diane Ravitch, who notes that the report «also includes an
analysis of
flaws in existing oversight, recommendations for reform, and an appendix of instances of fraud and abuse from 1997 through 2017.»
... However, I stand
by my earlier prediction — and this is where I find a
flaw in Mahaney's
analysis: Apple won't stand still and let Amazon have this market all to itself.
However, doing the
analysis, especially
by hand, you could see some of the
flaws in the P / E based approach.
One source of badly
flawed analysis revolves around the establishment of a comparative
analysis «strawman,» to wit, the thesis that all investors should be judged solely
by the extent to which their results outperform, or equal, the performance of a related market or index consistently.
So many journals these days publish dubious or
flawed or merely unclear
analyses that quickly get picked up and respun lamely
by the traditional media like a bad game of telephone.
So, there is no real hope that Miskolczi will ever understand the global warming problem despite his line -
by - line modeling and his deeply
flawed analysis of observational data.
That doesn't mean there's no possibility whatsoever of Gleick having faked the memo, but so far I find the speculation on why «it is probably fake and Peter Gleick is a liar» to be highly
flawed, including pseudo «independent
analyses»
by individuals who've enjoyed the hospitality of HI, if not their cheque book, and bat for the same ideological side.
That figure actually represents 179,000 «person - years of employment» — a job for one person for one year — and comes from an
analysis funded
by TransCanada that independent analysts have called «dead wrong,» «meaningless,» and «
flawed and poorly documented.»
These Russian experts in particular have a history of opposing international climate treaties (based on
flawed expert
analysis, as determined
by other experts in the linked paper below):
We might have a post
by Rud which seems sophisticated in its
analysis (even if potentially analytically
flawed) which is then followed up
by his highly tribalistic comments related to the politics associated with climate change science.
The website and group were formed in May 6, 1997, «to dispel the myths of global warming
by exposing
flawed economic, scientific and risk
analysis.»
Until such time as these recent
analyses are proven
flawed it should be accepted that any increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations caused
by the use of fossil fuels has negligible impact upon the global climate.
«Both [Fall et al. 2011 and Menne et al. 2010](and cited
by Muller et al) do an
analysis over a thirty year time period while the Muller et al paper uses data for comparison from 1950 — 2010... I see this as a basic failure in understanding the limitations of the siting survey we conducted on the USHCN, rendering the Muller et al paper conclusions highly uncertain, if not erroneous... I consider the paper fatally
flawed as it now stands, and thus I recommend it be removed from publication consideration
by JGR until such time that it can be reworked... it appears they have circumvented the scientific process in favor of PR.»
It is reasonable to expect that if
flaws exist then detailed alternative
analyses would have been on record
by now showing clearly where and how it is considered that these scientists have erred
These estimates are based on an
analysis by the Perryman Group — funded
by TransCanada — that independent analysts have called «dead wrong,» «meaningless,» «
flawed and poorly documented.»
Time and again, these experts find that Lomborg's assertions and
analyses are marred
by flawed logic, inappropriate use of statistics and hidden value judgments.
The Cooler Heads Coalition was formed on May 6, 1997, «to dispel the myths of global warming
by exposing
flawed economic, scientific and risk
analysis.»
Never mind the
flaws in Wegman's
analysis and conclusions that have been extensively critiqued
by numerous peer - reviewed and reputable scientific bodies.
The Cooler Heads Coalition's initial mission was to «dispel the myths of global warming
by exposing
flawed economic, scientific, and risk
analysis.»
published last November found significant
flaws in the methodologies, assumptions or
analyses used
by the 3 percent of scientists who concluded otherwise.
Ninety - seven percent of peer - reviewed research agrees with the conclusion that burning fossil fuels, deforestation and industrial farms are enshrouding the planet in heat - trapping gases, and a research review published last November found significant
flaws in the methodologies, assumptions or
analyses used
by the 3 percent of scientists who concluded otherwise.
Reasonable folks, who have believed in the «skeptic» meme will probably acknowledge that they got fooled
by internal natural variability and scientifically
flawed statistical
analysis presented to them
by «skeptics».
Muller spent two years investigating claims
by global - warming deniers that temperature rises verified
by multiple studies were skewed because of
flawed analysis, unreliable weather stations and the effect of urban heat islands.
The Cooler Heads Coalition, also known as GlobalWarming.org, is formerly a sub-group of the National Consumer Coalition, but now run as an «informal and ad - hoc group focused on dispelling the myths of global warming
by exposing
flawed economic, scientific, and risk
analysis.»
In 2008, the Bush administration released a new proposal for fuel economy standards that were slightly better but still far too low; they were determined through a fatally
flawed analysis employing numerous assumptions defying common sense and the law, such as a prediction that gas will cost $ 2.36 per gallon in 2020 and an assumption that technological solutions available now can't be employed
by automakers a few years from now.
Along the same lines, I do not find credible arguments that any product of peer review is therefore inherently corrupted
by tribalism — any more than I feel that any «skeptical»
analysis in the «skeptical» blogosphere is inherently
flawed due to tribalism among «skeptics» as a group.
The British Met Office has issued «erroneous statements and misrepresentations» about the pause in global warming — and its climate computer model is fundamentally
flawed, says a new
analysis by a leading independent researcher.
The briefing was hosted
by the Heritage Foundation and the Cooler Heads Coalition, an anti-regulatory-minded group formed to «dispel the myths of global warming
by exposing
flawed economic, scientific and risk
analysis.»
Eventually, M&M found massive
flaws with Mann's statistical approach,
flaws that have since been confirmed
by many experts, such that there are few people today that treat Mann's
analysis seriously (At best, his supporters defend his work with a mantra roughly akin to «fake but accurate.»