A number of prominent physicists have made critical comments about the subversion of science, what Richard Feynman
called cargo cult science.
Their fervour
for cargo cult sciences may simply be mercenary, and a function of the massive government funding going into things like global warming studies.
when Feynman gave his memorable 1974 commencement talk at cal tech, advising
against cargo cult science, perhaps he drew on heros from his youth?
And you get hockey sticks,
cargo cult science really, because when sociology takes over, it is the power over that is important, not the power for, and the people who survive the competition are not the real scientists but they are the manipulators of science for their own and their groups advancement.
Yes, when we make the assumption that * every * new failure, discrepancy, or divergence is a reflection of a new kind mechanism, then we are surely
doing cargo cult science.
Contrarians are fond of citing his strictures
on cargo cult science (in some cases I have to admit because it always gets a rise out of me when I find it) but in fact they are the cargo cultists (he was referring to engineers and administrators who didn't want to admit that an o ring could freeze and break, and the like, because they were wedded to their ideas).
One of my professors, Richard Feynman, would have called
it cargo cult science.
That he was mentioned at all is because his writings regards
the cargo cult science is for me the anchor piece for what honest science is and what is not honest science.
Famed scientist Richard Feynman offers an excellent description of «good science» vs. «
cargo cult science» here.
Tagged as: Aldo Leopold, Ashtoreth,
cargo cult science, David Graber, environmentalism, Gaia, greening churches, Greenpeace, John Muir, National Parks Service, Pachamama, pagan, perennial philosophy, Prince Charles, Sierra Club, uroburos, World Wildlife Fund, WWF
«
cargo cult sciences» is a term close to my heart.
It is «Post normal science» or «
cargo cult science».
Somewhere, Richard Feynman must be grimacing, scoffing and muttering «
cargo cult science.»