Concern # 1: Educational research and researchers strongly
caution against teacher evaluation approaches like New York State
In a recent conversation at my school, a student
cautioned me against teachers weighing in too heavily.
Not exact matches
The
caution is
against replacing the old set of abstractions, brought to the learning situation by the student, with a new set of abstractions chosen on the basis of a pattern apparent only to the person in charge, i.e., the
teacher.
Susan Stark, the chapter leader at PS 88 in Ridgewood, Queens, said more than 100
teachers, paras, guidance counselors, parents and students turned out to demonstrate in front of the school — wearing yellow hardhats with a sign stating «
Caution: Protecting Our School
Against Cuomo.»
Mr. Gbadago further
cautioned teachers at the basic school level
against charging such similar fees from students.
In a recent New York Times opinion piece even Bill Gates, a harsh critic of the old system of
teacher evaluation,
cautions against shaming educators by publishing
teacher scores in the media.
Michael Mulgrew, president of the United Federation of
Teachers,
cautioned Black
against trying to get a laugh next time around.
On the other hand, she
cautions against accountability structures that do not simultaneously boost supports for
teachers to improve their craft.
While these approaches could lead to large cost savings, and there are some approaches that would only affect
teachers with many more years left in the profession, as a general rule I would
caution states
against cutting benefits.
Hoyt also cited a recent policy statement by the American Educational Research Association that
cautions against using value - added data in
teacher evaluations and for high - stakes purposes.
We
caution, however,
against using technology for technology's sake, and encourage faculty and preservice
teachers to consider if the technology is allowing them to learn in a way they could not without the technology or if they are at least learning in a more meaningful way.
The blog of the Albert Shanker Institute, endowed by the American Federation of
Teachers, praised the study as «one of the most dense, important and interesting analyses on this topic in a very long time» — although it
cautioned against policy conclusions (of the kind that I'm reaching).
Researcher Bruce Baker
cautions against using VAMs even when test scores count less than 50 % of a
teacher's final evaluation.
To help
teachers successfully fulfill their role in this endeavor, effective
teacher supervision and evaluation systems that inform
teacher professional development and improve instruction are essential; however, disagreement over what those systems should measure remains, and some researchers
caution against relying on student test scores as a valid metric (Baker et al, 2010)
The American Educational Research Association became the latest organization to
caution against using value - added models — complex algorithms that attempt to measure a
teacher's impact on student test scores — to evaluate
teachers and principals.
Even those who champion value - added measures
caution against using them as the sole means of evaluating
teachers.
The preservice
teachers also
cautioned against overuse.
A report from the state's Commission on
Teacher Credentialing
cautioned against comparing the pass rates.
That vote failed on partisan lines, but Rep. Rosa Gill, a Wake County Democrat and retired math
teacher,
cautioned lawmakers
against expanding voucher spending in the absence of data that suggest the program has been successful.
He
cautioned against a wide range of disempowering practices that exist, not only within our
teacher education programs, but also within the practices of reading
teacher education researchers themselves.
And head
teachers» leader John Dunford has already
cautioned against ranking systems that downgrade schools working hard in the toughest areas.
However, one critic of the report
cautions against making too much of its findings because the report fails to delineate what students actually experience at various
teacher prep programs at colleges and universities throughout the nation.
As per Rothstein's testimony (again summarized by Pew) he
cautioned «
against placing too much weight on the «value - added models» now being used by many states to try to determine the impact of a
teacher on student learning.
Nonetheless, Grissom and Redding
cautioned against blaming the race gap only on White
teacher bias.
Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of
Teachers, however,
cautioned against making assumptions about the future.
Both the American Statistical Association, which is the largest organization in the United States representing statisticians and related professionals, and the American Educational Research Association have questioned the validity of using standardized test scores to measure
teacher effectiveness and
cautioned against using them for such purposes.
Teachers» unions and some supporters
caution against placing too much weight on student exams.