We used carefully matched samples
of charter and traditional public school students from Stanford's CREDO National Charter School Study to ensure that differences in student characteristics were unbiased.
In fact, there is little evidence that using a voucher to enroll in a private school improves student test scores, and any differences in the average performance of
charter and traditional public schools by this metric are modest relative to the amount of variation in performance within the charter sector.
In our re-analysis published in Education Next, we focused most of our efforts reanalyzing the CRP analysis
comparing charter and traditional public schools at the CBSA level — the Core - Based Statistical Area that the Census Bureau uses to define a metropolitan area.
«Our findings reveal that, across all grades and subjects, students in online charter schools perform worse on standardized assessments and are significantly less likely to pass Ohio's test for high school graduation than their peers in
traditional charter and traditional public schools,» said McEachin.
But any comparison of the demographics of students in
charter and traditional public schools provides at best an incomplete picture of segregation because segregation resulting from school choice policies would occur primarily across schools, not within schools.
Rates of classification in what might be considered the more severe (and less subjective) categories of special education — autism, speech or language impairment, or intellectual disability — remain quite similar in
charter and traditional public schools over time.
While the official release of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) data demonstrated that the sky had not fallen — after controlling for race, as many had pointed out, any differences between
charters and traditional public schools washed out — the news was no reason to celebrate either.
Despite his fraught political history with charter schools, on the first day of class today Mayor Bill de Blasio said he wants to
see charter and traditional public schools sharing ideas with each other more often.
[AFT and NEA] also recognized that such new national initiatives as the Common Core standards and President Obama's Race for the Top meant that teachers at
charter and traditional public schools faced similar challenges that the unions could help them address.»
This is why it is important that
charter and traditional public schools break down many of the barriers that exist between the two types of schools and work collaboratively in a myriad of ways that they can co-locate and cooperate in sharing best practices.
Recently he sat down with me to discuss the school - to - prison pipeline, the role of charter schools in fostering necessary change, and
how charter and traditional public schools can be partners instead of adversaries.
We focus our analysis on charter middle schools, because we are able to compare
charter and traditional public school students who had similar entering test scores and demographic characteristics and even attended the same elementary school.
While the national, state, and metro area analysis comprised the bulk of our report, we did, in fact, examine the segregation of students in
charter and traditional public schools by geography — comparing students in these school sectors within cities, suburbs, and rural areas.
This annual event brings together all the 1,000 or so teachers who work in Friendship Schools, an excellent group
of charter and traditional public schools in Washington, DC and Baltimore (which are featured in our other short film, Unchartered Territory, along with their inspirational leader Donald Hense).
Based on a wealth of existing evidence, however, we are unable to share in the team's optimism that more complete data might show narrower differences in segregation between
charter and traditional public schools.
But comparisons of simple averages at such a high level of aggregation can obscure wide differences in school - level demographics among
both charter and traditional public schools.
Indeed, we find the majority of students in the central cities of metropolitan areas, in
both charter and traditional public schools, attend school in intensely segregated settings.
Finally, research conducted by Robert Bifulco and Helen Ladd («Results from the Tar Heel State: Charter Schools and Student Achievement,» research, Fall 2005) indicates that North Carolina charter schools during this period may have been less effective in improving student achievement than were traditional public schools, at least for students who attended
both charter and traditional public schools between grades 4 and 8.