In the 2010 - 11 school year, the latest year for which that information was available, about one - quarter of
charter school expulsions — 68 of 263 — fell into those categories, according to Jeffrey Noel, director of data management for the Office of the State Superintendent of Education.
Not exact matches
This infographic compares out - of -
school suspension and
expulsion rates in
charter schools with traditional public
schools.
In an exclusive interview with Education Week, Richard Barth talks about
expulsion and suspension policies in his
charter school network.
They point to application barriers at some
charter schools and high
expulsion rates at others as evidence that the
charter sector as a whole may be skimming the most motivated, disciplined students and leaving the hardest - to - reach behind.
However, some
charter schools are criticized for their student discipline practices — including suspension,
expulsion, and other actions resulting in the removal of students from the classroom — that disproportionately exclude and impact students with disabilities.
The investigation has provided more fuel for the national debate over how
charter schools use suspensions,
expulsions and other harsh disciplinary practices to weed out students who need extra support and, in so doing, boost the
schools» test scores.
Susan Schaeffler, who heads the KIPP (Knowledge Is Power Program)
charter schools in the District, said
expulsions have not been a major factor.
A
charter school's policies for suspensions,
expulsions, or other involuntary removals, must comply with federal and state constitutional requirements and the procedures below:
• One investigation (Catalyst - Chicago) revealed that «
Charter schools (had) a higher rate of
expulsion than traditional
schools....
The State Legislature should amend state law to include explicit standards for expelling students to ensure that
expulsions for all
schools, including
charter schools, are limited to the most severe and dangerous behaviors in accordance with decisions of the Education Commissioner.
hat Green's article does not cover at all is this: the highest
school suspension and
expulsion rates for students of color can often be found in the Twin Cities» ever - expanding landscape of highly segregated
charter schools.
In the state Senate, lawmakers will consider SB 433 by Sen. Carol Liu, D - Pasadena, which would require
charter schools to comply with state laws governing pupil suspension and
expulsion.
But what Green's article does not cover at all is this: the highest
school suspension and
expulsion rates for students of color can often be found in the Twin Cities» ever - expanding landscape of highly segregated
charter schools.
Charter schools» admission and enrollment policies must be fair to all student populations and not discourage any student (except expelled students or those in
expulsion proceedings) from seeking admission and enrollment.
SB322, introduced by Senator Mark Leno, looks to align rules governing
charter student suspension,
expulsions, admissions and departures by putting them on par with traditional
school districts, and seeks to address the frequent accusation that
charters screen students during admission to admit only students with high test scores.
Andrew Broy, president of the Illinois Network of
Charter Schools, noted that the data show several charter schools do not have high expulsion rates, and discounted the argument that charters use discipline to improve their academic
Charter Schools, noted that the data show several charter schools do not have high expulsion rates, and discounted the argument that charters use discipline to improve their academic
Schools, noted that the data show several
charter schools do not have high expulsion rates, and discounted the argument that charters use discipline to improve their academic
charter schools do not have high expulsion rates, and discounted the argument that charters use discipline to improve their academic
schools do not have high
expulsion rates, and discounted the argument that
charters use discipline to improve their academic record.
Broy said
charters will work with CPS to bring down
expulsion rates in the privately run
schools, and he in turn hopes to share some behavioral programs that have been successful at
charter schools with the district.
It's the first time the district has released student suspension data for every
school and also the first time it has released data on
expulsions for
charters.
Skeptic —
Charter schools can elect to use Ed Code suspension and
expulsion provisions or adopt other discipline policies.
Half of the 164 New York City - reviewed
charter school discipline policies permitted suspension or
expulsion as a penalty for lateness, absence or cutting class, in violation of New York state law.
When the matter of inappropriate discipline was raised — this was what all speaking against the plans for a new
charter school found most alarming — there were attempts by Achievement First reps to brush the issue aside by repeating that almost half of the suspension / expulsion data was due to In School Suspensions, which they defined as when a student was removed from the classroom for more than two hours at a
school found most alarming — there were attempts by Achievement First reps to brush the issue aside by repeating that almost half of the suspension /
expulsion data was due to In
School Suspensions, which they defined as when a student was removed from the classroom for more than two hours at a
School Suspensions, which they defined as when a student was removed from the classroom for more than two hours at a time.
There have been numerous, verified reports of KIPP and other
charter schools practicing the No Excuse approach, using very harsh disciplinary practices, including high rates of suspensions and
expulsions, on students.
In D.C. in 2011 - 2012, the same year that
charter schools were 72 times more likely than the traditional
school system to expel a student, there were six
charters that issued zero suspensions or
expulsions, and 15 others that issued five or fewer.
Corporate and Tax - Exempt Fundamentals Best Practices for Open Meetings and Avoiding Conflicts of Interest; Laws Affecting Governance and Transparency in
Charter Schools: Brown Act, Government Code 1090; Political Reform Act; Determining Which Governance and Public Transparency Laws Apply to Your
School; Tax Exempt Facilities Financing; Prop 39; Commercial Space to
School Use; Lease Negotiations; Compliance Related Legal Updates; HR Compliance; Pupil Fees; Student Privacy Laws; Student
Expulsions and Dismissals; Admissions Practices and Lottery Preferences; Renewal; Revocation; Closure; Risk Management and Internet Safety
Filed Under:
Charter schools, DC Public Schools, Discipline Tagged With: expulsion, restorative justice, sus
schools, DC Public
Schools, Discipline Tagged With: expulsion, restorative justice, sus
Schools, Discipline Tagged With:
expulsion, restorative justice, suspension
At the same time, most
charter schools provide that certain offenses, including some non-violent ones, will result in automatic
expulsion.
We must consider
charter schools» suspension and
expulsion rates when we evaluate their successes, especially when it comes to standardized testing.
Perhaps the Penn study can rally all of us, be we reformer or traditionalist, to push for both traditional districts and
charter school operators to stop overusing suspensions and
expulsions.
The rate of suspensions and
expulsions at
charter schools during the last
school year have declined slightly, but are once again far higher than state averages, particularly for children in elementary
schools where the rate is four times the state average, the report said.
Suspensions and
expulsions from public
schools are slowly declining, but at
charter schools and in low - performing districts the numbers remain significantly higher than state averages, according to a state report released this week.
Over breakfast this morning, Eva Moskowitz seemed to rattle off a list of people who are skeptical of her Success Academy
charter school chain — teachers union types who are suing her, the media that is scrutinizing her classrooms, the parents who are angry about suspensions or
expulsions — some of whom showed up to confront her today.
Charter school leaders said they don't have the same ability to transfer students to another
school or an alternative setting, which might be one reason for their elevated
expulsion rates.
During the 2011 - 12
school year, when
charters enrolled 41 percent of the city's students, they removed 227 children for discipline violations and had an
expulsion rate of 72 per 10,000 students; the District
school system removed three and had an
expulsion rate of less than 1 per 10,000 students.
It already has had a «profound effect,» with
charter expulsion rates dropping 25 to 30 percent so far this
school year, Pearson said.
Not surprisingly, the
charter schools represented by authorizers at the event showed lower percentages of students with disabilities, and slightly higher rates of suspension and
expulsion than the Detroit Public
schools.
Charter schools often have higher
expulsion and suspension rates than regular
schools.
The data do not explain why the other 195 students were expelled from
charter schools, Noel said, just that the
expulsions were for other reasons.
Mayo helped her daughter, Elsie, fight
expulsion proceedings at Thurgood Marshall Academy
charter school in Southeast D.C. (Brad Horn / THE WASHINGTON POST)
Charter schools can write and enforce discipline policies that make it possible to remove students who are needy or challenging, said Suzanne Greenfield of Advocates for Justice and Education, an organization that offers free legal assistance to students facing
expulsion.
Most were in
charter schools, which often have higher
expulsion rates than traditional
schools.
Elsie Mayo, now 18, underwent
expulsion proceedings from Thurgood Marshall Academy, a high - performing
charter high
school in Southeast, in December 2011.
Additionally,
charters around the country have established rigid discipline policies that charge monetary fines to students for even minor infractions like chewing gum, and give the
schools leeway to push out — through suspensions and
expulsions — large numbers of students.
Leaders of
charter schools with high
expulsion rates argue that they remove students only when necessary, to keep their buildings safe and their classrooms conducive to learning.
The guidance also clarified that Section 504 applies to all of a
charter school's disenrollment practices, such as
expulsions and other involuntary permanent removals of a student from a
school.
Charter application guidelines for groups applying to open a new
school state that the DC Public Charter School Board is «unlikely to approve applications for schools with discipline policies that rely solely on exclusion to manage student behavior and / or that are likely to result in high rates of suspensions and expulsions.&
school state that the DC Public
Charter School Board is «unlikely to approve applications for schools with discipline policies that rely solely on exclusion to manage student behavior and / or that are likely to result in high rates of suspensions and expulsions.&
School Board is «unlikely to approve applications for
schools with discipline policies that rely solely on exclusion to manage student behavior and / or that are likely to result in high rates of suspensions and
expulsions.»
Interestingly, Mr. Cunningham never uses the term «
charter schools» without tagging on «high quality» — which usually means highly selective (i.e., lottery based admission) and leads to problems with
expulsion of special learners (see: Heritage Academies).
1550 The Alameda, Suite 211, San Jose, CA 95060 About Blog Tollner Law Offices is a special education firm with a wide range of experiences that include: All Special Education issues; Transition issues; Homeschooling; Suspension and
Expulsion; Student Safety and Personal Injury; Bullying; Harassment; Discrimination;
Charter Schools; and Evaluations Frequency about 1 post per month.
Chicago Youth Call Out
Charter Schools» Extreme Punishments After determining that Chicago charter schools have expulsion rates seven times that of their counterpart public schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
Charter Schools» Extreme Punishments After determining that Chicago charter schools have expulsion rates seven times that of their counterpart public schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
Schools» Extreme Punishments After determining that Chicago
charter schools have expulsion rates seven times that of their counterpart public schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
charter schools have expulsion rates seven times that of their counterpart public schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
schools have
expulsion rates seven times that of their counterpart public
schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
schools (see factsheet), youth leaders of Voices of Youth in Chicago Education urged the state
charter school commission to intervene and hold charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
charter school commission to intervene and hold
charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
charter schools accountable for exclusionary discipline pra
schools accountable for exclusionary discipline practices.