The Assembly and Senate this week overwhelmingly passed legislation that would impose a one - year moratorium on
the city bag fee law that is due to go into effect Feb. 15.
A state or
city bag fee was most likely never possible last year, whatever Gov. Andrew Cuomo's task force concluded.
Not exact matches
Just as Torontonians were getting used to shelling out 5 cents for plastic
bags, Mayor Rob Ford — possibly angered by having to carry so many nickels and unwilling to suffer the indignity of paying for a reusable shopping
bag — put forth a motion to do away with the
city's plastic -
bag fee as of July 1.
Supporters of the plastic
bag fee say it's designed to cut down on environmentally harmful waste and surcharges in other
cities have worked better than outright bans.
The New York
City Council voted 28 - 20 to require certain retailers to collect a
fee on each carryout
bag, paper or plastic, with some exceptions, with Mayor Bill de Blasio expressing support for the measure.
NYC First Deputy Mayor Anthony Shorris said the administration would support a ban or
fee on plastic shopping
bags, which the
City Council has been eying to pass.
The bill to be taken up later today in the Senate would block any
fees or taxes on carry - out merchandise shopping
bags in New York
City.
That bill has now landed on Cuomo's desk, and the clock is ticking since the
City's
bag fee is set to come on line February 15.
The DN praises Cuomo for «finally deciding» to do something about plastic
bags, but adds: «the statewide ban he now proposes, more than a year after letting the state Legislature trash the
City Council's better idea to impose a 5 - cent per -
bag fee, is the wrong answer to a real scourge.»
Say what you will about the
bag fee legislation approved by the
City Council last month, It's probably fair to say no one expected the Democrat dominated New York State Assembly to even consider overturning the will of the also overwhelming Democratic New York
City Council.
State Sen. Simcha Felder (D - Brooklyn), who led the charge against the
city's
bag fee, declined to comment Monday.
As the Republican - controlled Senate Tuesday prepares to vote on legislation that would block New York
City from enacting a five - cent
fee on plastic
bags, an environmental group is urging the Legislature to let the surcharge take effect.
After state lawmakers stepped in last week to vote on legislation that would delay the implementation of a plastic and paper
bag fee in New York
City, a Brooklyn assemblyman, Felix Ortiz, is looking to discourage use of disposable
bags statewide.
On Monday, Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie acknowledged there are concerns among some of the New York
City lawmakers in his conference over the
bag fee.
City Sanitation Commissioner Kathryn Garcia faced a barrage of criticism from the panel, including State Assemblyman Dov Hikind of Brooklyn, who said the 5 - cent
bag fee amounts to taxation without representation.
It is unclear whether Cuomo's proposal would fly in the Republican - led State Senate, which also opposed the
city's 5 - cent
bag fee.
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed a bill on Tuesday that blocked implementation of a 5 - cent
fee on plastic shopping
bags that was to go into effect the following day in New York
City.
NEW YORK (CBSNewYork / AP)-- State lawmakers held a hearing Friday to examine whether New York
City's plan to impose a
fee on plastic
bags will be a burden on consumers.
The bill instating such
fees, which exempts food stamp recipients and transparent produce
bags, cleared the
City Council last week over bitter opposition.
Backers of the
fee note that New Yorkers consume 9 billion disposable
bags a year, which clutter parks, cling to trees, accrue into islands in the world's oceans, strangle marine life and cost the
city sanitation system an estimated $ 12.5 million annually to process.
Protesters gathered outside
City Hall, where the
City Council considered a
fee on disposable
bags.
«In
city after
city, around the country and around the world, people who were initially resistant to
bag fees have very quickly adjusted and overwhelmingly started to bring reusable
bags — precisely to avoid paying them.
Other council members pointed to studies showing plastic
bag use is on the rise in
cities that have instituted similar punitive
fees, like San Francisco and Washington, D.C.
But as with so much else in the
city, the last word on the subject lies with the State Capitol, where hostility to the
bag bill has threatened to undo, or at least revise, the
fee.
ALBANY — The yearslong debate over whether to impose a
fee for plastic
bags in New York appeared to come to a hard - fought end last month, when the
City Council voted to charge 5 cents for most plastic and paper shopping
bags.
State Senator Simcha Felder of Brooklyn, in Albany on Tuesday, is among the opponents of New York
City's plastic
bag fee.
But the State Legislature this week voted to block the
city's duly enacted law, doing the bidding of the plastic -
bag industry, and hiding behind the argument that the
fee is a tax on the poor.
A New York
City Housing Authority tenant leader tore into Manhattan Councilwoman Helen Rosenthal for leading chants claiming families can afford a proposed 10 - cent
fee on plastic
bags at a rally in favor of the measure earlier this week.
A similar bill in the State Assembly seemed poised to follow until, later on Tuesday, the speakers of the Assembly and the
City Council agreed to delay enacting the bag fee while city officials amended the city's bill to the Assembly's lik
City Council agreed to delay enacting the
bag fee while
city officials amended the city's bill to the Assembly's lik
city officials amended the
city's bill to the Assembly's lik
city's bill to the Assembly's liking.
Suffolk County and the
City of Long Beach have enacted plastic
bag fees.
BUFFALO, N.Y. — As the state legislature debated a bill to stop New York
City from putting a 5 cent
fee on plastic shopping
bags, it wasn't just downstate interests that were watching closely.
The
City Council passed the
bag fee law last month, hoping it would reduce trash by encouraging shoppers to use reusable
bags.
Rather than hit customers who use plastic and other disposable
bags with the 5 - cent
fee under the
city law, a new bill would actually pay them to use reusable
bags.
Gov. Cuomo Tuesday signed a bill to impose a moratorium blocking the
city from imposing a controversial 5 - cent
fee on plastic disposable
bags.
A bill that prevents all
cities and towns in the state from imposing
bag fees passed the Republican - led Senate on Tuesday, with 36 in favor and 22 opposed.
After a vote by the legislature, Governor Andrew Cuomo now holds the fate of the
city's grocery
bag fee in his hands.
State lawmakers have voted to delay the implementation of a five - cent
fee on plastic and paper grocery
bags in New York
City, which effectively kills the bill.
«The Governor even had the Chutzpah to suggest the
City Council's vote for the BYOBag law was some sort of fluke and shouldn't count,» Kellner wrote, referencing a comment Cuomo made that the council vote on the
bag fee bill was a close one while the legislation imposing the moratorium overwhelmingly passed the state Legislature.
Supporters of the
fee have said 10 billion plastic
bags are thrown out a year in New York — amounting to 1,700 tons a week, and only 5 % of plastic
bags are currently recycled in the
city.
The former state lawmaker plans to create a second committee — Nickel PAC — that he said will contribute directly to candidates who pledge to support a
City Council speaker next year who vowed to bring the
bag fee bill up for a new vote.
The push from the state echoes another battle: the legislature's move to suspend the
city's
fee on plastic and paper
bags.
ALBANY — A former state assemblyman is creating a super PAC to push for the resurrection of a law imposing a 5 - cent
fee on disposable
bags in New York
City.
City Council Speaker Melissa Mark - Viverito wants to sock New Yorkers with a five - cent
fee on grocery
bags to boost recycling and reduce waste.
The Citizens Budget Commission and many others have had enough: it's time for New York
City to act on imposing a plastic
bag fee.
He said the goal of the
fee, which he made clear was initially a
City Council idea, was to change people's behavior to get away from using plastic
bags, which clog landfills.
Most recently, a New York
City - backed move to charge a 5 - cent
fee on plastic
bags was delayed amid concerns from state lawmakers.
«Supporters of New York
City's pending five - cent - per - carryout -
bag fee pitch the levy as environmentally sound, saving the
City from a perceived scourge of plastic shopping
bags,» Potrikus wrote.
Nixon, who supports placing a
fee on plastic
bags in New York
City, was asked about the
bag ban issue during her first campaign trip to Buffalo last Wednesday.
The New York State Retail Council in a letter to Gov. Andrew Cuomo this week backed a delay of the 5 - cent
fee on carry - out
bags in New York
City, but not because merchants will be able to pocket the surcharge.
Still, the council in the letter to Cuomo says the
bag fee is more preferable than an outright ban on plastic
bags in New York
City.