Meaning that the democratic link between the «Northern Powerhouse»,
city region devolution and civic engagement has been largely overlooked by politicians at both a national and local level.
Whilst the other 6 «metro mayors» were elected a year ago, the SCRCA contest had to be delayed by a year due to issues related to the geography of
the city region devolution deal and the status of its constituent and non-constituent members.
Not exact matches
Moreover, EVEL does not engage with on - going reforms in the other nations of the UK nor within England, appearing designed to operate in parallel, rather than in tandem, with other policies such as
devolution to England's
cities and
regions and the wider Northern Powerhouse agenda.
Crucially, current approaches to
devolution via bespoke
city regions and other territorial deals will create asymmetries in policy remit amongst MPs in different parts of England that resemble the very «West Lothian Question'that EVEL is supposed to put to rest.
For the most part, the underlying message in the current regional and
city regional agenda seems to be that
devolution will lead to economic renewal for the
regions «lagging behind».
However, the party has also reiterated its belief in
City Regions, a policy first mooted in the wake of the 2004 North - East regional assembly referendum defeat — stating that it will pass an «English Devolution Act» if elected into government, giving more powers to City and also County regions, and replacing the House of Lords with an elected Senate of the Nations and regions to work as a forum for regional represen
Regions, a policy first mooted in the wake of the 2004 North - East regional assembly referendum defeat — stating that it will pass an «English
Devolution Act» if elected into government, giving more powers to
City and also County
regions, and replacing the House of Lords with an elected Senate of the Nations and regions to work as a forum for regional represen
regions, and replacing the House of Lords with an elected Senate of the Nations and
regions to work as a forum for regional represen
regions to work as a forum for regional representation.
The case for a convention is strong: the constitutional settlement is currently in flux with cross-party agreement to devolve further powers to Scotland; the Welsh and Northern Irish assemblies want enhanced powers; and there are calls for
devolution to the
regions and
cities within England and / or an English parliament.
Thirteen months after its
devolution deal was first announced, not a single candidate from a major party has come forward to stand in the
city region's mayoral election next year, while local leaders have continued to question whether they should even have to introduce a metro mayor full - stop — despite the Communities secretary Sajid Javid stating explicitly that this would continue to be a «real red line» for progressing with
devolution deals.
In 2017 elections were held for Greater Manchester, the Liverpool
City Region, the, Tees Valley, West of England and the West Midlands as part of the
devolution deals allowed by the Cities and Local Government Devolution
devolution deals allowed by the
Cities and Local Government
DevolutionDevolution Act 2016.
The report concluded that only two
city regions in England (Greater Manchester and West Yorkshire) are ready, at this stage, for further
devolution.
As the
Cities and Local Government
Devolution Bill makes clear, it only really sees power as something that can be centralised in large
city regions outside of the capital, not spread around all our
city centres.
Such evidence indicates that the problem is historically deep - seated, which means that it is highly unlikely that
devolution in its present form will give the
city region of Manchester the financial resources, administrative capability and policy imagination to manage these genuinely structural problems.
Ed Miliband will broaden his drive for the
devolution of political and economic power to the
cities and
regions, and away from London, by saying he wants an elected second chamber completely recast as representative of the
cities,
regions and nations of the UK.
Given the backdrop of last year's independence referendum in Scotland and the prime minister's ensuing call for greater
devolution of powers to local and regional arenas, it is no surprise that the spectre of a Northern Powerhouse as a new
city region has reared its head.
Labour has promised to devolve # 30bn of funding over five years if it wins the election, calling the move «the biggest
devolution of economic power and funding to England's
city and county
regions for generations».
The electoral system, the use of referendum on key issues, a written constitution,
devolution of power and resources to the powerless in communities,
cities and
regions, abolition of the Lords and the end to the attacks on trade unions, charities, civil society, civil liberties and the complacency, inertia and disregard for the weakest and inequality that creates despair must be swept away.
The post of the Sheffield
city region mayor has been mired in controversy because, unlike similar roles in Manchester and the West Midlands, no
devolution and funding deal has yet been agreed to go with the appointment.
Having gained 47 per cent of the first round vote (on a turn - out of 26 per cent), Jarvis has a strong mandate to bring together the combined authority leaders and rubberstamp the
city region's
devolution deal to enact the manifesto he campaigned on, including making the case for a Yorkshire Mayor, which we would argue against making the first priority.
Second, disagreements between members of the combined authority (made up of Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield)-- and with the Government — mean that the public consultation needed to unlock the powers and resources on offer as part of the
city region's
devolution deal has not yet taken place.
And even if Liverpool and Sheffield will now benefit from devolved powers, we are still in a position where the Leeds
City Region, one of the areas most fundamental to the Northern Powerhouse, is without a
devolution deal — with local and national politicians bogged down in arguments regarding a pan-Yorkshire deal.
Rather than creating multiple new institutions to support
devolution in those
city regions, Labour should argue for the new mayors to be given the full range of powers and funding they need to address the issues that matter most to jobs and economic growth.»
Further
devolution to England may be concentrated on
cities or
regions that did not previously have it, so that London might lose out.
Dan Jarvis, the Labour MP who has been elected the first mayor of the Sheffield
City Region, said there is a «conversation to be had» about the future of Yorkshire
devolution.
The Welsh Liberal Democrats have criticised Labour's approach to a Cardiff
City Deal, claiming that the Deal is a «sham» without the
devolution of extra powers to the
region.
David Cameron's call for «English votes on English laws» is simplistic and divisive, but Labour's alternative,
devolution to
city and county
regions, is not a panacea.
Devolution gives us the opportunity to link Liverpool as the economic engine of the
city region with our surrounding areas - creating both synergy and scale.
Tags: Andy Burnham,
city regions,
devolution, George Osborne, Jeremy Corbyn, Nick Small, Northern Powerhouse, Yvette Cooper