Wendy D. Manning, Susan Brown (2006) Children's Economic Well - Being in Married and
Cohabiting Parent Families, Journal of Marriage and Family 68 (2), 345 - 362.
Not exact matches
Adolescent well - being in
cohabiting, married, and single
parent families.
Nearly a quarter of couples who are
cohabiting when they have children will actually go on to get married within five years of becoming
parents, according to an analysis by the Institute for Fiscal Studies which is oddly little cited by the
family breakdown lobby.
Others live with single or
cohabiting parents, in blended or polyamorous
families, with grandparents or in multigenerational homes.
A quarter of married or
cohabiting parents say the mother plays more of a disciplinarian role in their
families, while 15 % say the father does, and 59 % say both share this role equally.
In what is perhaps the most comprehensive investigation of the implications of different kinds of
family structures for the well - being of teenagers, Thomas Deleire and Ariel Kalil studied more than 11,000 adolescents raised in ten different kinds of households, including, for example, households with married
parents, biological
cohabiting parents, single mothers (divorced, always - single, and
cohabiting considered separately), divorced single mothers in multi-generational households, and always - single mothers in multigenerational households.
One recent estimate from the National Survey of
Family Growth found that kids in the mid-2000s born to
cohabiting parents were more than twice as likely to see mom and dad break up by the age of 12 compared to kids born to married
parents.
What's more,
cohabiting parents meet the
Family Test, the criteria used by the state to streamline benefits and for purposes of policy.
An infographic showing married couple,
cohabiting couple and lone
parent families by the country of birth of the
family reference person.
If we were to exempt
cohabiting siblings from tax, what about other
family members such as
parents and children?
However, the definition of «spouse» under the section of the
Family Law Act pertaining to spousal support, includes common law partners: «either of two persons who are not married to each other and have
cohabited, (a) continuously for a period of not less than three years, or (b) in a relationship of some permanence, if they are the natural or adoptive
parents of a child.
Who commits «domestic violence» 2 (1) Domestic violence occurs when a person is subjected to an act or omission mentioned in subsection (1.1) by another person who (a) is
cohabiting or has
cohabited with him or her in a spousal, conjugal or intimate relationship; (b) has or had a
family relationship with him or her, in which they have lived together; (c) has or had a
family relationship with him or her, in which they have not lived together; (d) has or had a dating relationship with him or her, whether or not they have ever lived together; or (e) is the other biological or adoptive
parent of his or her child, regardless of their marital status or whether they have ever lived together.
By age 12, for example, children in
cohabiting families are about twice as likely as those in married
parent families to experience a parental breakup.
In this definition, single -
parent families may include
cohabiting couples and do not include children living with married stepparents.
Fragile
families and child behavior problems Several studies using FFCWS data confirm that child behavior problems are elevated in both single -
parent and
cohabiting families.
The FFCWS studies add to a large body of earlier work that suggested that children who live with single or
cohabiting parents fare worse as adolescents and young adults in terms of their educational outcomes, risk of teen birth, and attachment to school and the labor market than do children who grow up in married - couple
families.
Shannon Cavanagh and Aletha C. Huston, «
Family Instability and Children's Early Problem Behavior,» Social Forces 85, no. 1 (2006): 551 — 81; Cynthia Osborne, Wendy D. Manning, and Pamela J. Smock, «Married and
Cohabiting Parents» Relationship Instability: A Focus on Race and Ethnicity,» Journal of Marriage and
Family 69, no. 5 (2007): 1345 — 66; Osborne and McLanahan, «Partnership Instability and Child Well - Being» (see note 23).
Shirley Liu and Frank Heiland find that among couples unmarried at the time of the child's birth, marriage improved cognitive scores for children whose
parents later married.41 Terry - Ann Craigie distinguishes among stable
cohabiting unions, stable single - mother homes, and stable married - couple
families, as well as unstable
cohabiting families and unstable married - couple
families.
Using the 1999 National Survey of American
Families, Brown found that only 1.5 percent of all children lived with two
cohabiting parents at the time of the survey.17 Similarly, an analysis of the 1995 Adolescent Health Study (Add Health) revealed that less than one - half of 1 percent of adolescents aged sixteen to eighteen had spent their entire childhoods living with two continuously
cohabiting biological
parents.18
E. Mark Cummings and Patrick T. Davies, «Effects of Marital Conflict on Children: Recent Advances and Emerging Themes in Process - Oriented Research,» Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 43 (2002): 31 — 63; James L. Peterson and Nicholas Zill, «Marital Disruption,
Parent - Child Relationship, and Behavioral Problems in Children,» Journal of Marriage and the
Family 48 (1986): 295 — 307; Osborne, McLanahan, and Brooks - Gunn, «Young Children's Behavioral Problems in Married and
Cohabiting Families» (see note 9).
As we discuss below, one recent study found that
family stability trumps
family structure as it pertains to early cognitive development even after controlling for economic and parental resources.26 It has been shown that children living in stable single -
parent families (that is,
families that were headed by a single
parent throughout childhood) do better than those living in unstable two -
parent families (that is,
families that had two
parents present initially but then experienced a change in
family structure).27 Another study finds that children living in stable
cohabiting homes (that is,
families where two
parents cohabit throughout the child's life) do just as well as children living with
cohabiting parents who eventually marry.28 But other research challenges the conclusion that it is
family stability that is crucial for child wellbeing One study, for instance, found that children who experience two or more
family transitions do not have worse behavioral problems or cognitive test scores than children who experience only one or no
family transitions.
Children growing up in stable two -
parent families show higher levels of cognitive ability than those in stably
cohabiting families or those who experienced a change in living arrangements.
She finds no difference in children's vocabulary scores at age three between stable two -
parent families (whether
cohabiting or married) and stable single - mother
families, but she finds that scores are lower in unstable
families (whether
cohabiting or married) than in stable
families.42 Carey Cooper and co-authors also highlight the role that partnership instability plays in the link between
family structure and child cognitive development, although these links are much weaker than those they find for behavioral development (discussed below).43
That is, some studies find that being raised by stable single or
cohabiting parents seems to entail less risk than being raised by single or
cohabiting parents when these
family types are unstable.
And given that recent cohorts of children born to single and
cohabiting parents are relatively young, an additional complication involves comparing outcomes across studies (that is, analysts can not yet estimate effects of
family structure on adolescent and adult outcomes for cohorts such as FFCWS).
Furthermore, the number of
cohabiting couple
families has increased by 3 % and lone
parent families has risen by 2 % over the same period.
Cynthia Osborne, Wendy Manning, and Pamela Smock, «Married and
Cohabiting Parents» Relationship Stability: A Focus on Race and Ethnicity,» Journal of Marriage and
Family 69 (2007): 1345 — 66; Cynthia Osborne and Sara S. McLanahan, «Partnership Instability and Child Wellbeing,» Journal of Marriage and
Family 69 (2007): 1065 — 83.
Building on findings that the Minnesota
Family Investment Program (MFIP) resulted in higher rates of marital stability among two -
parent recipient
families who participated in this initiative that provided financial incentives to welfare recipients who worked, this report documents MFIP's long - term effects on marriage and divorce among participants in the program's sample of nearly 2,500 two -
parent families who were married or
cohabiting at study entry.
A One -
Parent Family Payment is not payable while a person is in a relationship and
cohabiting with someone of the opposite or same sex.
Also, because
cohabiting unions are more likely to dissolve than marriages, children in
cohabiting unions are at a greater risk of spending time in a single -
parent family, which significantly increases their poverty risk.
The likelihood of separation is higher among
families with younger mothers, mothers with no qualifications, mothers with poor mental health,
cohabiting parents, and when the birth had not been planned.
According to the 2013 National Marriage Project report, Knot Yet, children of
cohabiting parents in their twenties are three times more likely to experience the dissolution of their
family than children born to married
parents.
Child Abuse: While children living with their unmarried biological mother and her live - in boyfriend face a higher risk of suffering child abuse than kids in any other type of
family, children who live with their own
cohabiting parents are more likely to be abused than children of married
parents.
The Fragile
Families and Child Wellbeing Study (FFCW), meanwhile, finds that «nearly half of
parents who are
cohabiting at the time of their child's birth break up within five years, compared to only 20 percent of married
parents.»
Compared to children of married
parents, those with
cohabiting parents are more likely to experience the breakup of their
families, be exposed to «complex»
family forms, live in poverty, suffer abuse, and have negative psychological and educational outcomes.
Every
family member, including
parents, spouses, siblings, children, and
cohabiting partners is affected.
Cohabiting couples who have a child in their twenties and then break up — and that's almost two - fifths of them in the first five years — often also go on to have another partner or partners.44 One study of young urban
parents based on data from the Fragile
Families and Child Wellbeing Study found that for 59 percent of unmarried couples with a baby, at least one partner already had a child from a previous relationship.
According to a number of academic and bureaucratic (e.g., the Census Bureau) definitions,
families do not need to include children (couples count); they do not need to include more than one adult and they do not need to include two people in a sexual relationship (single -
parent families count); when they do include two adults, those adults do not need to be married (
cohabiting couples count) and they do not need to include a man and a woman (same - sex couples count).
Adolescent well - being in
cohabiting, married, and single -
parent families.
Single -
parent families tend to have much lower incomes than do two -
parent families, while
cohabiting families fall in - between.
Myth — Children do better in
cohabiting biological
parent families than in
cohabiting stepparent
families.
Findings indicate no differences in child well - being for children living in
cohabiting stepfamilies and
cohabiting 2 - biological -
parent families.»
A non-married couple with no common child was defined as a
cohabiting two -
parent family only if the two adult residents were of different sex and not siblings, over the age of 18 years and their age difference was < 16 years.
This study proposes that the
family structures associated with risk — single - mother, step -
parent, and
cohabiting — influence early sexual debut due to
family instability, including shifts in
family structure and maternal dating, which can undermine parental control and transmit messages about the acceptability of nonmarital sex.
«
Family type» classified into married two -
parent families,
cohabiting two -
parent families and single -
parent families.