In our earlier posts, we focused on the use of
a constructive trust as a remedy for breach of fiduciary duty and third party fraud liability.
This post discusses the finding by the Court of Appeal that it was inappropriate for the application judge to have granted
a constructive trust as a remedy for breach of fiduciary duty.
The BC Court of Appeal in BNSF Railway v Teck Metals Ltd 2016 BCSC 350 the court delivered the following brief summary of the history of
constructive trust as an equitable remedy:
Not exact matches
This discussion also does not consider any specific facts or circumstances that may be relevant to holders subject to special rules under the U.S. federal income tax laws, including, without limitation, certain former citizens or long - term residents of the United States, partnerships or other pass - through entities, real estate investment
trusts, regulated investment companies, «controlled foreign corporations,» «passive foreign investment companies,» corporations that accumulate earnings to avoid U.S. federal income tax, banks, financial institutions, investment funds, insurance companies, brokers, dealers or traders in securities, commodities or currencies, tax - exempt organizations, tax - qualified retirement plans, persons subject to the alternative minimum tax, persons that own, or have owned, actually or constructively, more than 5 % of our common stock and persons holding our common stock
as part of a hedging or conversion transaction or straddle, or a
constructive sale, or other risk reduction strategy.
Mr. Morley is seeking a judgment and order that Square, Mr. Dorsey, and Mr. McKelvey hold ownership of Square in
constructive trust for Mr. Morley,
as well
as a variety of damages, injunctive relief, royalties, and correction of inventorship of certain of our patents.
A mentor is someone who can be a
trusted counselor to a student — someone who can serve
as a role model, help the student to identify goals
as well
as the steps needed to achieve them, provide
constructive criticism, and provide emotional support.
That
trust enabled them to accept the feedback accompanying her classroom observations
as constructive, rather than punitive.
You're going to need to prove, alongside your bankruptcy attorney
as a debt - related Sherlock Holmes, that you are holding the property in your name
as what's called a
constructive trust.
And if,
as can easily happen, a claim involves both sets of rules (eg
constructive trust and Sch 1) nobody knows whether a claim proceeds in the family courts under FPR 2010 or in the civil courts under CPR 1998; and each set of rules has their significant differences (
as will be explained in forthcoming articles).
It is increasingly common (
as happened in this case) for breach of the implied term of
trust and confidence to be alleged by an employee in
constructive dismissal cases (
as such a term is fundamental and goes to the root of the contract).
In the even that you have missed the two limitation period, you still have an opportunity to pursue so called «equitable remedies» such
as «unjust enrichment» and «
constructive trusts».
A court might very well impose a
constructive trust or equitable lien on the proceeds of the sale after it happened
as well.
The majority of the Court generally agreed that Indalex had breached its fiduciary duty
as plan administrator but that the
constructive trust imposed by the Ontario Court of Appeal was not the appropriate remedy.
However,
as is well established, s 2 (1) did not defeat a claim brought on the basis of a proprietary estoppel or
constructive trust.
[36] Fred argues in the alternative that he is not found to be the beneficiary of an express
trust or a resulting
trust, that the court should impose a
constructive trust on 50 % of the equity in the house
as Al has been unjustly enriched.
Both the plaintiff's claims of resulting
trust and
constructive trust (unjust enrichment), were dismissed in Chambers v Chambers 2012 BCSC 88 The facts of Chambers were blogged yesterday,
as was the younger brother's claim for an express
trust, also dismissed.
The excerpts from the court with respect to the issues of resulting
trust and
constructive trust are
as follows:
Tamara has vast experience of all forms of Property law representing landlords and tenants
as well
as Lenders in proceedings ranging from standard possession claims to more complex issues of art 8 and unreasonableness, undue influence in mortgage fraud (Ertridge), Judicial Review and reasonableness of action on the part of social housing authorities, co-habitee and family resulting /
constructive Trusts, injunctions and applications under s91 of the LPA 1925 to the High Court for orders for sale in mortgage possession proceedings.
For present purposes, I will highlight just one and offer what I
trust will be received
as a respectful and
constructive commentary.
Some will welcome the Court of Appeal's approach in Davies
as a further application of the court's ability to take anything of relevance into account in establishing inferred common intention
constructive trusts following Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17, [2007] 2 All ER 929, and Jones.
The English Court of Appeal allowed her appeal on the basis that the claim was more in the nature of a
constructive trust,
as opposed to a resulting
trust, and by whatever name it is described, it is a
trust imposed by law, whenever justice and good conscience require it.
A breach of fiduciary duty not only gives rise to a tort, it gives rise to special damages and remedies that are unique to fiduciary cases apart from common economic loss damages, such
as disgorgement of ill - gotten gains or a
constructive trust.
With respect to the knowing receipt claim, Justice Horkins held that the claim disclosed a reasonable cause of action,
as it pled the existence of a
trust, a breach of that
trust,
constructive knowledge of the breach of
trust on the part of BMO (knowledge of facts sufficient to put a reasonable person on notice or inquiry of the breach of
trust), and the receipt of
trust property by BMO for its own use and benefit by way of service fees associated with the impugned transactions.
Southin J. followed the maxim of equity that will not permit even an act of Parliament to be used
as an instrument of fraud, and applied the notion of «good conscience» to impose a remedial
constructive trust, because Mr. Martindale had, by the separation agreement surrendered any right he may have had to the property of the deceased.
And while he did get a little hung up on «bare trustee»
as a category of
trust (at para. 11), he did go on to consider other characterizations including an express
trust and a
constructive trust before settling on a resulting
trust analysis based upon the contribution to purchase price.
The date of separation may also be of interest to an unmarried («common law») couple if the couple is asserting a joint venture /
constructive trust (such
as where an unmarried couple invested in property together during the relationship and share that investment upon separation).
At trial the husband made a
constructive trust argument in relation to the matrimonial home, without seeking to add the wife's mother
as a party to the case.
As part of the Respondent's claim for division of property, she asserts an entitlement to
constructive trust against proceeds from the sale of the Applicant's corporate shares.
An implied
trust can either be a resulting
trust, ie there is a presumption that it was intended that someone would have a share in the property
as it was clear that they did not make a financial contribution
as a gift and their share would be determined by the extent of their financial contribution, or a
constructive trust, ie there was a common intention to have an interest in the property which, following Lloyds Bank v Rosset [1991] AC 107, [1990] 1 All ER 1111, was held to be
as a result of a direct financial contribution to the property.
Other than the doctrine of
constructive trust, it is possible in certain circumstances to apply other equitable principles such
as proprietary estoppel.
There has been much debate
as to whether the property is held on an implied or
constructive trust, and whether that
trust is fixed or floating.
But under an equitable doctrine such
as Unjust Enrichment,
Constructive or Resulting
Trust (discussed below), the other spouse could claim an interest to such property.
As opposed to an express
trust created by the parties,
constructive trusts are
trusts imposed by law to prevent what would otherwise be a fraud by the party who holds legal title.
The consequences of the parties» risky choices in structuring their Property Settlement Agreement
as they did, did not justify the application of a
constructive trust that would harm third parties, the former husband's creditors.
To recap, the idea behind a
constructive trust is
as follows.
At present the owner of an intangible can only make a claim against a party with whom there is no contract in special circumstances — such
as where a
constructive trust arises
as a result of dishonest assistance or knowing receipt — and such claims depend on fault.
Within this varied role, you will cover all sales and administration relating to recruitment such
as: Generating sales leads through cold or warm leads Management of your Client Accounts Sales meetings and presentations Resourcing and validation of candidates for relevant roles Developing relationships with candidates and provide them with
constructive criticism and guidance with the aim of securing them their next position Business networking to further spread the employers brand,
as a
trusted and reliable recruiter Keep all database records complete and up to date in line with company requirements Regular attendance of clients visit and industry events I like it, tell me more!
As the BC Claims Task Force Report noted, «Early implementation of sub-agreements may provide the parties with an opportunity to demonstrate good faith, build
trust and establish a
constructive relationship».
As the BC Claims Task Force Report noted, early implementation of sub-agreements may provide the parties with an opportunity to demonstrate good faith, build
trust and establish a
constructive relationship.
The court also held that Spec was not liable under a
constructive trust claim,
as Spec was not unjustly enriched by its dealings with the Gurtins.
If a
constructive trust is imposed, the court will determine that the damaged party is in fact the owner of the property and that the party currently in possession is merely holding the property
as trustee for the other party.