The Joint Committee rejected the public defender model adopted in the United States on the basis that, for criminal cases, it was «wrong in principle that both prosecutor and defender are employed by the same master» and that the impersonal and bureaucratic nature of the public defender model made it impossible to exercise «the zeal and vigour which should be characteristic of
defence counsel in every case.»
Not exact matches
This is perfectly understandable to me within the general context of the investigation
in which the allegation had arisen, and considering that I have lately come to also realize that two of my colleagues
in chambers had been involved as
defence counsel in two
cases before the subject judge amongst twelve
cases in all they have ever done at the Industrial Court since inception.
Most recently, he has been retained as
defence counsel in a wide range of cartel
cases including the Air Freight, LCD Screen, Optical Disk Drive, Refrigeration Compressors and Car Components
cases.
In the
case, the judge referred to Miss Woodward as an «extraordinarily able lady» while her
defence counsel described her as «bright».
At Neuberger & Partners LLP,
in Toronto, our lawyers offer dependable and knowledgeable
counsel based on decades of criminal
defence experience
in drug crimes
cases.
So what is
defence counsel to say to the accused and concerned family members
in a
case like R. v. Murphy 2012 ONCA 573?
Generally speaking there are 5 basic constitutional issues that are commonly engaged
in a successful
defence of drinking and driving
cases: «arbitrary detention» (s. 9 of the Charter), «unreasonable search and seizure» (s. 8 of the Charter), «right to
counsel» (s. 10 (b) of the Charter), the «right to be informed promptly of the reasons for your detention» (s. 10 (a) of the Charter) and the «right to be tried within a reasonable time» (s. 11 (b) of the Charter).
In the present
case, the Court of Appeal reviews the special relationship between accused and
defence counsel and the role of the Crown.
His recent
cases include defending the former President and majority shareholder of VAB Bank against charges of contempt of court (sole
counsel); acting for Mercuria Energy Trading
in its successful
defence of a US$ 270 million claim by Citibank
in one of the biggest High Court banking trials of 2014, acting for the Claimant
in an on - going US$ 830 million fraud claim
in the Commercial Court (Russian banking sector), a US$ 800 million joint venture dispute
in the BVI and acting as junior
counsel to the Claimants
in Hulley & ors v.
According to the
defence counsel in the matter, the
case is one of the first since 2008 changes to the dangerous offender provisions to deal with the question of when a sexual offender isn't a dangerous offender.
Behind the scenes: The January 2011 Canadian Lawyer cover story that interviewed
defence counsel in the Russell Williams
case.
Without the knowledge of the plaintiff or her
counsel, the defendant and accused
in the
case had shared the plaintiff's documents produced
in the civil
case with his criminal
defence counsel, who then relied on these records at trial.
A decision released yesterday by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice's Divisional Court has overturned a Superior Court ruling that limited when civil lawyers can share compelled medical records and other personal information with
defence counsel in the same
case.
(Ontario did not challenge the appointments
in these
cases, but the issue of whether it was appropriate to appoint amici to,
in effect, act as
defence counsel, was raised by two of the six interveners, the Attorneys General of British Columbia and Quebec).
Speculative risks of conflict are not enough to remove
defence counsel, a Superior Court judge has ruled
in a
case the Crown argued could see the accused's lawyer cross-examining another client of his.
The purpose was to attempt to show that
defence counsel had received the same disclosure
in a previous
case and therefore ought to have sought the information which constituted the late disclosure.
Roderick Johnson has, for over a decade, practised almost exclusively as leading
counsel for the
defence in large, complex and high - profile
cases — specialising particularly
in cases involving drugs, fraud and money laundering.
34 The Supreme Court of Canada has recently confirmed
in R. v. Burlingham (1995) 97 C.C.C. (3d) 385, at p. 397, that: «s. 10 (b) specifically prohibits the police, as they did
in this
case, from belittling an accused's lawyer with the express goal or effect of undermining the accused's confidence
in and relationship with
defence counsel.
30 Although
defence counsel may well run the risk of having evidence of an accused viewed as tainted when testifying after hearing other
defence witnesses testify, I do not
in this
case find that Mr. Pasloski's evidence should be so characterized.
Our office has direct experience
in white collar crime
cases in these criminal acts, both as
defence counsels for people and companies who had some misunderstandings with authorities and on the side of victims of these criminal activities.
In separate
cases, we have represented both
defence counsel and class
counsel.
This
case provides an important re-statement of the law surrounding requests for further
defence medical examinations and rebuts the common presumption of
defence counsel that defendants are permitted to obtain
defence medical report (s)
in the same medical specialty to respond to report (s) served by the plaintiff, irrespective of what reports they have already served.
The trial judge
in that
case allowed
defence counsel to introduce two pieces of problematic evidence: sexually explicit text messages between the complainant and her affair partner, and a transcript of a sex video she had made with the accused, being her husband.
Defence counsel need to engage
in meaningful reviews of the
case and communicate with their clients.
This is no easy task and often involves showing the Crown
Counsel involved
in the prosecution of your
case the weaknesses of their
case, the strengths of possible
defences for the accused, showing the Crown that special or extra-ordinary circumstance exist for your client that may lead to the exercise of discretion based upon Crown policy and / or
in generally advocating for the client.
Throughout his lengthy career as a
defence lawyer, Justice Clifford served as
counsel in many high profile and complex criminal
cases; since 1997, he served as
counsel in over 18 major homicide
cases in the Ottawa area.
In cases where the prosecution relies on toxicology reports,
defence counsel will argue the assumptions the extrapolated readings are predicated on are inaccurate.
[242] This is a peculiar
case in that an adverse inference is sought against the plaintiff for failing to file a report from Dr. Cox, although Dr. Cox did
in fact give evidence at the trial at the instance of
defence counsel.
The lawyer you retain to defend such a
case must have extensive experience and be regarded
in the criminal justice system as a reputable and successful
defence counsel in order to properly and fully defend you.
We address
cases as coverage,
defence and subrogation
counsel in many diverse and expanding areas including:
Here, prosecutors and
defence counsel are NOT paid equally with the latter receiving,
in some
cases, less than half that of a prosecutor.
The appellate judge
in this
case imparted strong advice to
defence counsel at the end of the judgement — advice that can be applied equally to the entire legal bar, regardless of the area of practice.
«Detailed notes and written instructions... permit
defence counsel to confidently distinguish one similar
case from the next, and reliably explain how they discharged their important professional obligations
in each
case».16
In cases of the nature of R. v. Felderhof, it is not enough for
defence counsel to exercise his version of «zealous advocacy,» without limitations, to ensure that the defendant is fairly defended.
The circumstances of the Shofman
case led Justice Campbell to take the rare step of issuing a practice note for all
defence counsel, not just the trial lawyer involved
in the particular
case.
In this
case, the learned judge essentially concluded that, because
defence counsel believed they had a reasonable opportunity of beating the plaintiff's offers, they were not offers that ought reasonably to have been accepted:
Importantly, the court
in the
case was not persuaded that a plaintiff's privacy interest
in her medical records should give way to the «element of surprise» that criminal
defence counsel argued was so important to the
defence of accused clients.
Detailed notes and written instructions would helpfully later permit
defence counsel to confidently distinguish one similar
case from the next, and reliably explain how they discharged their important professional obligations
in each
case.
Your lawyer or duty
counsel will be able to give you legal advice about things such as difficulties the Crown could have
in proving the
case against you, or possible
defences you may have.
[50] This recommended practice would seem to be especially helpful
in circumstances where
defence counsel has a legal practice focused largely upon a particular type of
case (e.g. drinking and driving
cases), where it would be easy for
counsel to confuse one
case with another, especially where
counsel defends a high volume of such
cases each year.
Because of his negotiation skills, courtroom abilities and leading reputation, Mr. Filkow is highly regarded
defence counsel in drinking and driving, drug, theft, sexual assault and assault
cases across British Columbia.
The presiding judge decided to allow
defence counsel to attend the first stage hearing
in this
case, but ordered them to refrain from disclosing information revealed to anyone, including their clients, and to file written undertakings with the Court promising the same.
In this
case, my ongoing concern about the conduct of
Defence counsel crystallized at the end of the trial and shed new light back onto it.
As Toronto lawyer Leora Shemesh prepares to defend herself against charges of perjury and obstruction of justice, other
defence counsel say they've also been dealing with issues surrounding the existence — or not — of a video that surfaced
in a drug
case she acted
in.
Previously, Chris worked
in private practice
in both Family Law and Criminal
Defence and was
counsel on one of the leading
cases involving B.C.'s Child Protection Agency and a finding of Misfeasance
in a Public Office, one of only a few
cases in the country where such a finding has been made.
Topics include — the role of the prosecution and
defence counsel, «How can you defend someone you know to be guilty / unpopular defendants», overview of the rules of evidence designed to ensure a fair trial, the role and power of the jury, contempt of court laws and the recent verdict
in the PC Harwood manslaughter
case.
Hoang v. Vicentini was a motor vehicle
case that discusses the difference between litigation experts and participant experts (the former needs to prepare a report under the Rules of Civil Procedure, the latter does not) and also conflict of interest issues for
defence counsel acting
in a reservation of rights situation.
Although at the time this
case was heard, the majority of provincial and territorial appellate courts held that courts had jurisdiction to prevent
defence counsel from withdrawing due to non-payment
in fees, there was some division
in the
case law and differing approaches had been taken
in the codes of conduct established by provincial law societies.
Most importantly, where a
case could hinge on the credibility of the accused and can potentially be undermined by an e-mail statement,
defence counsel should consider challenging the admission of the e-mail
in a voir dire, even if the trial judge fails to take the initiative to do so.
In terms of one specific case, acting as sole counsel for the Ministry of Defence in the first full Deepcut inquest was a very significant logistical and forensic challeng
In terms of one specific
case, acting as sole
counsel for the Ministry of
Defence in the first full Deepcut inquest was a very significant logistical and forensic challeng
in the first full Deepcut inquest was a very significant logistical and forensic challenge.