Baroness Hale and Lord Carswell
delivered concurring opinions and Lord Bingham dissented.
Baroness Hale and Lord Brown
delivered concurring opinions and Lord Hoffmann and Lord Carswell dissented.
Lord Carswell, Lord Mance and Lord Neuberger
delivered concurring opinions.
Lord Hope, Lord Scott, Lord Walker and Lord Carswell
delivered concurring opinions.
Lord Hoffmann, Lord Rodger, Baroness Hale and Lord Brown
delivered concurring opinions.
Lord Bingham, Lord Hope, Lord Rodger, Baroness Hale and Lord Brown
delivered concurring opinions.
Lord Bingham and Lord Rodger
delivered concurring opinions.
Not exact matches
Justice Elena Kagan
delivered the court's majority
opinion, which was joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, and Sonia Sotomayor (Thomas also filed a separate
concurring opinion).
Justice Samuel Alito
delivered an
opinion that
concurred in part and dissented in part with the majority
opinion.
Acting Presiding Justice Robert L. Dondero
delivered the
opinion, with Justice Kathleen M. Banke and Judge Diana Becton (sitting by assignment)
concurring.