Buck argued that even in that context
the determination of the preliminary issues was in the interests of the scheme beneficiaries as a whole, and relied on its representative role to support that position.
Not exact matches
So let's give Mr Justice Coulson an eight per cent over base increment in his salary for venturing into the Late Payment
of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 (LPCD (I) A 1998) in Ruttle Plant Hire Ltd v Secretary
of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs [2008] EWHC 730 (TCC), [2008] All ER (D) 191 (Apr) which involved the
determination of 17
issues in the second round
of preliminary issues in the case.
The Hungarian Kúria (Supreme Court) had reservations over the interpretation
of the DPD and the
determination of applicable law so referred the
issue to the CJEU for a
preliminary ruling.
Now that Judge Pender has made this remand initial
determination on the narrow
issues the Commission asked him to revisit, the parties can petition for review
of that
preliminary ruling (they already requested that the Commission review the original initial
determination), and unless the Commission now decides to adopt Judge Pender's recommendations as the final ruling, the parties will then get to submit briefing on the
issues key to the review.
[115] It is not the Court's role to dictate procedure; however, in the circumstances that unfolded in this case, it would be expected that once the ACO received the ACFN's Statement
of Concern from the AER, and understood that, contrary to the ACO's
preliminary determination, the ACFN believed there was a duty to consult, the ACO should have provided notice to the ACFN that the ACO would be making a final
determination on the
issue.
The Third Circuit reiterated the requirement that district courts engage in rigorous analysis
of the elements
of the claim in analyzing Rule 23 class certification
issues, including conducting a
preliminary inquiry into the merits as necessary to make the
determination.
This appeal arose in the context
of a dispute between insurers with respect to the payment
of statutory accident benefits («SABS»), and the
determination by the arbitrator
of a
preliminary issue.