It introduced a variety
of different voting systems for different tiers of Government, with no convincing explanation as to why this hotchpotch produced a principled system.
However, the complicated voting system - with Scots voting for constituency, regional and local councils simultaneously
using different voting systems - meant tens of thousands of votes have been rejected.
The report, written by elections experts, academic Prof. Roger Scully and ERS Wales» researcher Dr Owain ap Gareth, the report compares projections of what the results could have looked like
under different voting systems and questions the impact of the proposed Boundary Changes.
Your recent Last Word page details how
different voting systems produce different results without revealing the «best» result — that is, the fairest and most democratic one (26 July).
(That sounds contradictory, but who stands, how they campaign, and how voters choose how to vote will not stay constant
under different voting systems)
But the countries mentioned in the question have
different voting systems.
The report details what the results in the 2011 Assembly election could have looked like under
different voting systems.
The results in Scotland mean that they either need a collapse of the SNP or
a different voting system if they are to get into government again.
Because gerrymandering relies on the wasted - vote effect, the use of
a different voting system with fewer wasted votes can help reduce gerrymandering.
My question: has any deliberative body tried using
a different voting system here instead?
It is equally possible for
a different voting system to produce a totally unprogressive outcome.
Far from a sensible discussion of the merits of
different voting systems, we have seen torrents of what Jack Straw rightly described as «hyperbole and abuse» — how «old politics» is that?
However,
different voting systems are affected to a greater or lesser extent by IIA failure.
What would follow if the Labour leadership were to conclude that a change to
a different voting system — either Alternative Vote or some form of proportional representation — was now in the party's interests?
A Liberal Democrat amendment to hold a referendum earlier and on
a different voting system - the single transferable vote - was defeated by 476 votes to 69.
Now the U.S. employs five
different voting systems: punch cards, paper ballots, optical scans, lever machines and electronic voting machines, also called Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) machines.