A trial court's findings of fact on
disputed issues of fact will not be disturbed unless clearly erroneous (aka the «any evidence» standard of review)
The court clarified that committees could not decide
disputed issues of fact, and that a «prima facie» case as to what happened meant a case for allegations which, if believed, would be sufficient to justify a verdict, in the absence of an answer from the registrant.
[56] The court also quoted the view in Perry that a committee «must not and can not decide
disputed issues of fact in relation to the substantive allegations,» and «must also be extremely cautious about rejecting or discounting evidence on the basis that it is incredible or implausible.»
The court ruled that as long as there was
a disputed issue of fact concerning the plaintiff's claim, such as whether the road was reasonably safe at the time of the plaintiff's fall, it was inappropriate to dispose of the case without a trial.
Not exact matches
After initially dismissing the
issue of fake news and its role in distributing it, Facebook recently started working with third - party
fact - checking groups and is now flagging stories that have been called into question or whose accuracy has been
disputed.
Nobody
disputes that the removal
of David Dein was as big a blow for Wenger as it was for the supporters.They both worked together to the absolute benefit
of Arsenal Football Club.What did Wenger do when left on his own?Did he insist on a Director
of Football to handle all the
issues Dein dealt with?Did he not illustrate to his Board that they have just removed the conduit that made the partnership work to the benefit
of Arsenal Football Club?No.What did Wenger do?He took on everything himself including a massive pay hike on his next contract.Ken - do not be blinkered by the
fact Wenger has been paid a kings Ransom for his time at the club.The results and performances are not justified by the continued decline that you openly admit to.Wenger would have us all believe he is the only one capable
of getting us out
of the quagmire we are in while seemingly failing to acknowledge it was him that got us there.
The NCAA needed to convince the judge that no genuine and
disputed issues of material
fact remain, and when viewing the evidence most favorably to the players, that the NCAA would be clearly entitled to prevail as a matter
of law.
The New York State Public Employment Relations Board has appointed a three - member
fact - finding panel that will take testimony, hold hearings and
issue a report and recommendations in an effort to resolve the contract
dispute between the New York City Department
of Education and the UFT.
Regardless
of the type
of legal proceeding or which side uses scientific evidence, the forensic scientist must be able to write a report and testify under oath about: what
facts or items
of evidence were analyzed or tested; what tests or analyses were used; how valid or reliable those tests or analyses have been found to be by other courts; why and how the forensic scientist was qualified to conduct those tests or analyses; and, what the results
of the tests or analyses were and how those results are relevant to the
issues in
dispute.
Please include the docket number
of this Emergency Order in your petition, and state the material
facts at
issue which you believe
disputes the existence
of an imminent hazard and must include all evidence and exhibits to be considered.
Confronted with complex
issues with high decision stakes, uncertain
facts and values in
dispute, scientists may still aim to deliver truth, but often there are many competing interpretations
of the same problem (conflicting truths), none
of which can be refuted given the state
of knowledge — so that a consensus can only be an enforced reduction
of complexity into single «best
of our knowledge» claim.
If that's not true — if in
fact, individuals would rather be guided reliably to conclusions that fit the position
of «their team» than be right when they are evaluating
disputed evidence on
issues like climate change and the effectiveness
of the HPV vaccine — then what I'm up to is either pointless or (worse) a self - deluded contribution to public manipulation.
But I m a cataloger
of issues and in
fact each
of these three claims is
disputed by some scientists.
Appellate experts such as SCOTUSBlog's Tom Goldstein pegged the odds
of the Supreme Court hearing the appeal at «zero» because the
dispute is primarily about
facts rather than broad legal
issues.
Limoges appealed, arguing that that the court made an improper credibility assessment about the affidavit
of the Limoges expert and because the judge overlooked material
issues of fact that were in
dispute.
Expert witness statements can facilitate case decisions in the face
of highly
disputed issues and
facts Read More >
The court continued, explaining that «a genuine
issue of material
fact exists where
facts concerning an
issue that would dispose
of the litigation are in
dispute or where the undisputed material
facts are capable
of supporting conflicting inferences on such an
issue.»
While I am a U.S. attorney, the U.K. and U.S. are essentially the same on these
issue in practice: «reasonable wear and tear» is a classic
issue of fact to be decided by the judge (unlike the U.S. there are never juries in U.K. landlord - tenant
disputes) based upon the evidence presented to him and his or her good judgment if the case goes to court.
Furthermore, as with all
disputed matters, the court can do no more than decide the
issues on the relevant
facts of each case: the «primary search must always be for what the parties actually intended, to be deduced objectively from their words and their actions» (para 46).
Family law is a unique species
of civil law for many reasons, but primarily because
of: the frequency with which
disputes brought to court concern social, psychological and emotional
issues rather than legal; the almost complete absence
of circumstances in which a specific legal conclusion invariably and inevitably results from a particular set
of facts; and, the range
of other areas
of the law that may be concurrently applicable, such as contracts, tax, conflicts, real property, negligence, torts and trusts.
«The matters to which the court must have regard include --(a) the financial value
of the claim and the amount in
dispute, if different; (b) whether it would be more convenient or fair for hearings (including the trial) to be held in some other court; (c) the availability
of a judge specialising in the type
of claim in question; (d) whether the
facts, legal
issues, remedies or procedures involved are simple or complex; (e) the importance
of the outcome
of the claim to the public in general».
The
issue then becomes how sensitively online procedures can handle
disputes of fact.
The
facts are not in
dispute nor is the Board
of Governor's Student Discipline Review Committee in a better position to decide the matters at
issue.
At that time,
disputes involving numerous contested
facts, and particularly cases where credibility
issues existed between the parties, would rarely be dealt with by means
of summary judgment.
However, Rule 29 (3) also includes sensitive subjects such as the
issues in
dispute and admissions
of fact that also arise in the court form that defence lawyers must file, prior to the conduct
of all pretrial conferences, under Rule 26 (1).
In
fact, many
issues and
disputes arise in matters
of probate.
To maximize your compensation, retain a car accident lawyer who can investigate the
facts of your accident, contact all responsible parties, handle any insurance
issues including coverage
disputes, and gather the necessary records and supporting documentation
of the nature and extent
of your injuries.
Whether the at - fault driver is clear, or whether there are
disputed issues as to whom the at - fault driver is, my job is to gather the
facts and make an argument on behalf
of my clients to best protect their rights.
We don't lose sight
of the
fact that estate
disputes are first and foremost human
issues.
The factum summarize the
facts of the case, the
issues in
dispute, and the law being relied upon (with the addition
of «overview» and «relief sought» sections at the beginning and end
of the factum,... read more
The Appellant appeals on the basis that, since material
facts and the credibility
of the parties are
disputed, there are genuine
issues for trial.
The reason for such
disputes is due to the pool
of experienced claims handlers being shallow and loss adjusters not fully examining all
facts that will permit a claims handler in determining coverage
issues.
On an application, the court may direct a trial
of an
issue or convert the proceeding to an action, especially where there are
facts in
dispute.
In the event global settlement is not reached, the program would provide the parties with a summary
of the
facts inputted, the terms
of any agreements reached that could potentially be incorporated into a separation agreement or consent order, and the legal
issues remaining in
dispute, again without revealing the parties» positions on those
issues.
Let's put aside
issues of evidence and what can be proved and assume these
facts are not in
dispute.
We will glean the basic
facts and clarify the
issues of the
dispute.
The buyer had evidence
of disputed fact issues on whether the seller's real estate broker had committed fraud or was negligent in handling the real estate transaction where the square footage
of the property was inaccurate.
Arbitration Worksheet: This worksheet is intended to assist hearing panels in identifying relevant
issues and
facts in determining questions
of entitlement to
disputed funds.