Let's take a look at the evidence People sometimes ask me why I disagree with trying to train or manage
dogs using dominance techniques.
Not exact matches
Full of insights into both
dog and human behavior, Victoria convincingly argues against
using force and
dominance, and lights the way to the relationship we all want with our best friends.»
Some
dog fanciers describe this behavior in terms
used by biologists to explain wolf interactions — they toss around terms such as «pack dynamics» and «
dominance hierarchy» to explain how
dogs see the world.
If you are not having problems with
dominance with your
dog, then they can simply be
used occasionally.
Both leadership and
dominance have to be enforced, sometimes
using corrections, to have a well mannered
dog.
An «Alpha Procedure» or «Alpha Rollover» is
used to assert
dominance using dog language.
It is also
used by the top male
dog in the pack (the alpha male) to assert his
dominance over all
dogs in the pack.
We don't
use dominance for forced based training methods I hope you understand how important this is to your
dogs future.
Michael taught us patience, yet firmness,
using rewards / positive reinforcement methods (as opposed to negative based
use - of - force methods to establish
dominance over our
dog, as suggested by others).
The
dominance theory has been discredited by many, including American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior, Marc Beckoff (who has written a lot about this),
Dog Professional Associations, David Mech who studies wolves and many other scientists have debunked the dominance theory, yet it's still widely used by many dog trainers, tod
Dog Professional Associations, David Mech who studies wolves and many other scientists have debunked the
dominance theory, yet it's still widely
used by many
dog trainers, tod
dog trainers, today.
Dog trainers who are still steeped in using punitive training methods are often known to use outdated terms such as «dominance,» «pack leader,» and «alpha dog,» all of which have been proven by canine behavior scientists and specialists to be inappropriate and inaccurate in their application to pet do
Dog trainers who are still steeped in
using punitive training methods are often known to
use outdated terms such as «
dominance,» «pack leader,» and «alpha
dog,» all of which have been proven by canine behavior scientists and specialists to be inappropriate and inaccurate in their application to pet do
dog,» all of which have been proven by canine behavior scientists and specialists to be inappropriate and inaccurate in their application to pet
dogs.
a.) He lacks credentials; b.) He hasn't titled
dogs in either obedience or in the show
dog ring; c.) He
uses «old methods» such as leash corrections, e-collars,
dominance techniques, the alpha roll; which they claim induces «learned helplessness»; d.) The
dogs are stressed when his methods are applied; e.) Some behavioral problems are medically related, are not going to be addressed by any kind of behavior modification program, and Cesar Millan doesn't clarify this in his writings or on his TV show; f.) He doesn't
use the accepted behavioral terminology, and makes up his own behavioral vocabulary; and g.) He and his company are being sued by a former customer for allegedly injuring a
dog; inferring or charging this is evidence he is a cruel and inhumane trainer.
Therefore, the
dog may or may not
use it as a way to gain
dominance.
a.) a considerable amount of exercise, including the
use of treadmills and backpacks, as a way of relaxing
dogs to prepare them for counter-conditioning exercises; b.) packs of
dogs to rehabilitate unstable, fearful or aggressive
dogs; c.) Leashes and chain collars to block jumping, whining, possessiveness, biting, aggressiveness, excessive barking, mounting, fighting, active
dominance challenges; d.) Redirection to get
dogs doing alternative behaviors in play areas, obstacle courses, a pool, a feeding area, a sleeping area, and an eating / drinking area; e.) calming techniques
using hand feeding; f.) a limited amount of obedience training, such as teaching the
dogs to heel on a loose lead at the handler's side; g.) a «claw» technique, his own version of the «alpha rollover», and a pursuit technique to deal with
dogs that don't show submission to other
dogs or people; h.) «flooding» for phobias; i.) «calm / assertive» handler techniques; j.) touch and sound techniques to interrupt, correct and / or redirect behaviors; k.) a variety of traditional manners rules, which are implemented with the «no free lunch» type of approach; l.) a variety of games and other «mental challenges»; m.) human intervention; and n.) electric collars (not mentioned, as I recall, in the book)
Combine these concepts with the awareness that
dogs are not wolves trying to dominate us to achieve «top
dog» status, and therefore do not need to be controlled
using dominance - based punishment techniques, and you have the recipe for positive training.
Perhaps some
dogs do
use humping as a form of
dominance, but until we see concrete evidence to back up this claim we wouldn't want to speculate!
The focus on
dominance is overblown, and over
used, and I've seen people who were bitten by their own
dogs trying this stuff.
Here's a video that will explain the
dominance myth: == > https://twitter.com/382b288b8e8327261/status/742623739800653824?nid=45b5987e-0f57-4f86-a42a-b1ead65997ee How to Potty train your
dog to
use the toilet 1ï» ¿
Since then, scads of books have been published that explain how to train a
dog and deal with behavior problems
using reward - based training and other principles of operant conditioning, while also discarding the idea of «
dominance.»
a.) a considerable amount of exercise, including the
use of treadmills and backpacks, as a way of relaxing
dogs to prepare them for counter-conditioning exercises b.) packs of
dogs to rehabilitate unstable, fearful or aggressive
dogs; c.) Leashes and chain collars to block jumping, whining, possessiveness, biting, aggressiveness, excessive barking, mounting, fighting, active
dominance challenges; d.) Redirection to get
dogs doing alternative behaviors in play areas, obstacle courses, a pool, a feeding area, a sleeping area, and an eating / drinking area; e.) calming techniques
using hand feeding; f.) a limited amount of obedience training, such as teaching the
dogs to heel on a loose lead at the handler's side; g.) a «claw» technique, his own version of the «alpha rollover», and a pursuit technique to deal with
dogs that don't show submission to other
dogs or people; h.) «flooding» for phobias; i.) «calm / assertive» handler techniques; j.) touch and sound techniques to interrupt, correct and / or redirect behaviors; k.) a variety of traditional manners rules, which are implemented with the «no free lunch» type of approach; l.) a variety of games and other «mental challenges»; m.) human intervention; and n.) electric collars (usually not mentioned in their marketing materials or websites)
While it may
use up a lot of space in the book, all that explanation of how
dogs and wolves are different ultimately helps us to fully understand why
using the «pack mentality» and
dominance approach to how one deals with their
dog is not appropriate or necessarily productive.
that are fixed lose their healthy as you think he to foresee any should be
used first to look after their
dog their
dog have table gives him feel like an exercises as well as staying and fleas daily once it same place numerous
dominance.
Down is a
dominance - oriented command, and avid beginner
dogs will probably ignore its
use.
Dominance - based training techniques, such as yelling, hitting, yanking on the leash and forcing the
dog to lie down (also known as «alpha roll») are not recommended; one should be
using positive reinforcement based techniques, instead.
I have had several
dogs over my lifetime, and I've always learned from trainers who taught
dominance with the
use of pinch and snare collars.
Just as with the practice of hanging
dogs up by their leashes was once
used as a corrective «training» tool, we now must deal with the legacy of
dominance training, its array of bad ideas for
dog training and how they impact development of the bond of trust we should have with our
dogs.
If you are having no problems with
dominance with your
dog they can simply be
used occasionally.
compulsive grooming, wool - sucking),
dominance aggression as well as inappropriate elimination (urination or defecation) Most often
used in
dogs, but may be
used with caution in cats.
It
used to be thought, that
dogs reaching maturity may seek to exert their
dominance over their owners, and refuse to comply with commands as a way of displaying their status.
Use Positive Reinforcement Reward instead of the principles of the
dominance theory to train your
dog.
I've written a lot about
dogs and
dominance and my take on this topic hasn't changed at all, namely, dogs display dominance but dominance should not be used in training / teaching dogs to coexist with us or with other dogs [please see «Social Dominance is not a Myth,» «Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
dominance and my take on this topic hasn't changed at all, namely,
dogs display
dominance but dominance should not be used in training / teaching dogs to coexist with us or with other dogs [please see «Social Dominance is not a Myth,» «Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
dominance but
dominance should not be used in training / teaching dogs to coexist with us or with other dogs [please see «Social Dominance is not a Myth,» «Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
dominance should not be
used in training / teaching
dogs to coexist with us or with other
dogs [please see «Social
Dominance is not a Myth,» «Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
Dominance is not a Myth,» «
Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
Dominance and Pseudoscience: Making Sense of Nonsense,» renowned primatologist Dr. Dario Maestripieri's outstanding essay called «Social
Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links
Dominance Explained: Part I» (in which he mildly takes me to task for trying to accommodate the deniers), and many links therein.]
Use methods that will solve the
dominance problems without making your
dog hate you.
Meanwhile,
dog trainers and behavior consultants who are still steeped in
using punitive training methods commonly
use outdated terms such as «
dominance,» «pack leader,» and «alpha
dog,» all of which have been proven by canine behavior scientists and specialists to be inappropriate and completely inaccurate in their application to pet
dogs.
«Linda brings tremendous academic credentials and extensive training to her work, but what really makes her special is her passionate devotion to helping the
dog - owning community understand the benefits and effectiveness of
using positive training methods as opposed to flawed compulsion and
dominance - based techniques.»
I do not advocate the
dominance theory or
use a prong collar bit do I love and respect him less for what he has done to help society value the life of
dogs?!
The idea of
dominance in
dogs has been so misunderstood by some trainers in popular media for so long that it has now become a dirty word, such that even when trainers and behavior experts
use the word correctly, they risk a backlash from people that are — let's face it - exhausted from having to continually reeducate the public about what
dominance really is and what it isn't, particularly when so much damage has been done because of the way the word has been
used by some people in the
dog training world.
It's understandable that people in the
dog training world get so agitated when the word «
dominance» is mentioned, even when
used in the right context.
Learn from the experts in
dog behaviour why fear,
dominance or aversive training is not the best method to
use when working with your
dog.
A «check» collar should never be
used for puppies, and should only be considered as a training method for
dogs that pull or exhibit
dominance issues as they get older.
As an aside, numerous studies have also shown a clear correlation between aggression in pet
dogs and the
use of P - / R - training methods employed by owners and trainers, for example «alpha roles» in
dominance reduction programmes (see for example Casey et al. 2013; Herron et al., 2009; Rooney and Cowan, 2011).
Rich started working with
dog many years ago, in the days when
dominance theory prevailed and
using fear, force, intimidation and painful punishment was the supposedly the only way it could be done.
Like most adolescents, puppies in this period are highly influenced by their playmates (both
dogs and people), and during these 2 months they'll begin to understand and
use ranking in terms of submission and
dominance.
A couple of common methods
used to correct a
dog are the «alpha roll» (rolling a
dog on its back and holding it down to assert
dominance) and «scruff shake» (holding a
dog by the loose skin on its neck and shaking it).
They are against, or uncomfortable with,
using Dominance or Corrections when training a
dog.
Dominance Dog Trainers
use intimidation or force their
dogs to do what they want.
Dominance is really a concept that we wish people would stop
using when it comes to
dogs.
Based on these findings, medications that increase serotonin levels were
used to treat
dominance aggression in
dogs.
It also acts to calm the
dog as the pressure on the top of the nose is a maneuver
used in wild
dogs and wolves to assert
dominance.
The
use of
dominance and pack theory in explaining
dog behavior has come under a great deal of scrutiny as of late.
There are also some
dogs who
use jumping as a
dominance gesture - by physically guiding your movement, they very subtly control territory.