In Baker, the Supreme Court noted that the purpose of the participatory rights contained within
the duty of procedural fairness is, among other things, to provide an opportunity for those affected by the decision to put forward their views and evidence fully and have them considered by the decision - maker.
Did the Ministry breach
the duty of procedural fairness owed to Kaberwal by failing to hold an oral hearing before making its decision?
The Federal Court of Appeal held that whether an adjudicator has a legal obligation to consider an argument is part of his or
her duty of procedural fairness — which is assessed by the courts on a standard of correctness.
A recent Alberta decision has rejected the province's argument that it does not owe
a duty of procedural fairness to First Nations in determining whether the Crown's duty to consult is triggered.
[112] In conclusion, I am satisfied that the RFP process followed was sufficient to discharge
the duty of procedural fairness owed to the Community Groups.
[116]
The duty of procedural fairness would also require the ACO to outline what procedure it would undertake in making its determination, what evidence is required to meet the trigger test, as well as to convey the deadlines applying to the ACO's procedure -LSB-...].
In some cases,
a duty of procedural fairness may be owed to an individual if the decision is sufficiently particular to that individual.
While the content necessary to satisfy
the duty of procedural fairness varies from case to case, it may require that the affected individual be given an opportunity to respond or to submit evidence for the decision - maker's consideration.
Most often, decisions about which medical services should be funded will be policy decisions, involving the apportionment of resources among competing groups, and thus
no duty of procedural fairness will attach.
The NDP could have framed this debate as one of protecting Alberta jobs and an Alberta - based company, rather than just about cancelling a contract with a giant Australian company (it was later announced that an appeal panel determined that Alberta Health Services breached
its duty of procedural fairness in the RFP process in a substantive manner).
Not exact matches
In this case, having regard to: (i) the origin
of Ofsted's
duty of fairness; (ii) the general purpose
of the JAR together with its
procedural arrangements; and (iii) the unique circumstances and timescale in which the JAR had been directed, the Court
of Appeal found that Shoesmith's appeal against Ofsted should be dismissed.
«Fundamental to any concept
of procedural fairness must be a judicial
duty to do whatever is possible to provide a fair and impartial process and prevent an unfair disadvantage to self - represented persons.»
Except where there is a «red flag» prompting further inquiry, such as an obvious error in the material or where information has come to light which casts a doubt on the reliability or integrity
of the facts or opinions in the underlying material, there was no
duty to examine the
procedural fairness of investigations upon which facts and opinions in a reference were based.
The First Nations are relying on the established administrative law principle
of procedural fairness to argue that the
duty to consult is not necessarily confined to cases involving s. 35 Charter rights.
[There] may still be a
duty on the part
of a Visa Officer, in certain situations, to provide an applicant with the opportunity to respond to his or her concerns, in accordance with the rules
of procedural fairness.
However, his fifth alternative
of devising a notional cross-motion for partial summary judgment by the respondents for their claim
of breach
of fiduciary
duty, which was never raised with the parties, amounted to a denial
of procedural fairness.