Similar patterns of change in
earlier model simulations are described by Giorgi et al. (2001).
And if
earlier model simulations have been proven wrong, why should we take seriously all the dire predictions currently being offered, on the basis of similarly contrived models?
Julie Hargreaves has a new paper out on this precise question and shows that
the early model simulations had substantial skill compared to any naive model.
Not exact matches
In the Department of Meteorology at Stockholm University (MISU), researchers have done a series of
model simulations investigating tropical cyclone activity during an
earlier warm climate, the mid-Holocene, 6,000 years ago.
Research reported
earlier this year hinted that events in the stratosphere might directly affect the oceans, but those findings were based on a single climate
model and a computer
simulation that
modeled the stratosphere for a relatively short 260 years.
«Agent - based
modeling is like a video game in the sense that you program certain parameters and rules into your
simulation and then let your virtual agents play things out to the logical conclusion,» said Crabtree, who completed her Ph.D. in anthropology at WSU
earlier this year.
Applied in combination with crop
simulation models, it is also possible to evaluate local adaptation strategies as successfully shown in an
earlier study for barley in Finland.
This
simulation of the
early universe shows matter arranged in filaments; a new observation supports this
model.
Earlier versions of the
model treated the interface region as a uniform, or completely charged, plasma, but the scientists knew something was missing because they never saw spicules in the
simulations.
Such enhanced
modeling and
simulation capabilities held the potential to dramatically accelerate future product development cycles and could provide GE with new insights into turbine engine performance
earlier in the design process instead of after testing physical prototypes.
In research published this week in Astrophysical Journal Letters, Dr Zoe Leinhardt and colleagues from Bristol's School of Physics have completed computer
simulations of the
early stages of planet formation around the binary stars using a sophisticated
model that calculates the effect of gravity and physical collisions on and between one million planetary building blocks.
«Using observations and
model simulations, we've demonstrated that rising Pacific - Atlantic temperatures were the major driver of rapid Arctic warming in the
early 20th century.»
Consequently, in the past 20 years his research has evolved from an
early focus on prioritizing the effects that humans have on coral reefs and the role that marine protected areas play in conserving biological diversity and ecological processes, to developing theoretical and
simulation models of coral reefs that will help predict and suggest alternatives to reduce detrimental effects, to developing practical means to restore degraded reefs through manipulation of the food web and management.
The authors built a statistical
simulation model to estimate the 25 - year incremental costs per quality - adjusted life - year (QALY) for Oncotype DX testing in order to evaluate the cost - effectiveness of GEP testing among patients with
early - stage ER - positive / HER2 - negative breast cancer treated in community oncology practices.
For the
earlier generation of
models, results are based on the archived output from control runs (specifically, the first 30 years, in the case of temperature, and the first 20 years for the other fields), and for the recent generation
models, results are based on the 20th - century
simulations with climatological periods selected to correspond with observations.
Most of the
modelling groups that contributed output to the current MMD at PCMDI also archived
simulations from their
earlier models (circa 2000) as part of the Coupled
Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP1 & 2).
In an ensemble of fully coupled atmosphere - ocean general circulation
model (AOGCM)
simulations of the late Paleocene and
early Eocene, we identify such a circulation - driven enhanced intermediate - water warming.
Because this issue continues to affect all coupled ocean - atmosphere
models (e.g., 22 — 24), the warming (Fig. 3) represents the expression of positive biotic feedback mechanisms missing from
earlier simulations of these climates obtained with prescribed PI concentrations of trace GHGs.
«The apparent contradiction between verification statistics is thus fully resolved: the cross-validation R2 of approx 0.0 demonstrates that the MBH98
model is statistically insignificant; the new
simulations, implementing the variance rescaling called for by Huybers and newly - revealed in the MBH98 code, confirm our
earlier finding that the seemingly high MBH98 RE statistic is spurious.»
«By comparing the response of clouds and water vapor to ENSO forcing in nature with that in AMIP
simulations by some leading climate
models, an
earlier evaluation of tropical cloud and water vapor feedbacks has revealed two common biases in the
models: (1) an underestimate of the strength of the negative cloud albedo feedback and (2) an overestimate of the positive feedback from the greenhouse effect of water vapor.
SAT observations and
model simulations indicate that the nature of the arctic warming in the last two decades is distinct from the
early twentieth - century warm period.
I haven't got to the bottom of this yet, but there are several plausible explanations: (i) some of the
simulations in the downloaded
models from the CMIP3 ensemble stop
early, affecting the whole envelope of results, (ii) the use of common EOFs fail to capture large - scale temperature patters that are too different from the past.
Most of the
modelling groups that contributed output to the current MMD at PCMDI also archived
simulations from their
earlier models (circa 2000) as part of the Coupled
Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP1 & 2).
My own perspective on this is that it would be a significant departure from
earlier work by Trenberth if he really came with empirical evidence (i.e. data based on actual physical observations, rather than simply
model simulations) to support his position.
Judith, I think falling best estimates for aerosol offsets in the SOD (compared to AR4) and simultaneous continued use of
earlier (larger) aerosol offsets in the climate
model simulations borders on daft.
As mentioned
earlier, the DICE
model accounts for the impact of CO2 emissions on warming by computing Monte Carlo
simulations based on certain assumptions about temperature sensitivity to CO2 emissions.
Earlier we had carried out
simulations of Jupiter with the same
model (Schneider and Liu 2009), but with slightly different choices of dissipation parameters (which are poorly constrained by data).
Interpretation of climate
model simulations has emphasized the existence of plateaus or hiatus in the warming for time scales of up to 15 - 17 years; longer periods have not been previously anticipated, and the IPCC AR4 clearly expected a warming of 0.2 C per decade for the
early part of the 21st century.
Over the next few years these GCM
simulations will be extensively evaluated, problems will be found (as seen in some
early evaluations1, 2), followed hopefully by solutions that lead to further
model development and improved
simulations.
Whereas most proxy - based reconstructions point to an
early - middle LIG climatic optimum with reduced summer sea ice concentrations between 126 and 116 ka, the results of our
model simulations only support a pronounced reduction in summer sea ice concentration for the LIG - 125 and LIG - 130 runs (in both time slice as well as transient runs; Figs. 8 and 9), but also indicate that sea ice was still present in the central Arctic Ocean even under climatic conditions significantly warmer than today (Fig. 4).
Just looking at the AR4 and
early AR5
simulations, it looks as if the different climate
models give a wide range of answers.
Santer et al. have laid down the gauntlet with this paper in terms of providing a method for falsifying climate
model simulations for the purpose of attribution of 20th and
early 21st century temperature variations.
Your point 4: «The
early onset of sustained, significant warming in palaeoclimate records and
model simulations suggests that greenhouse forcing of industrial - era warming commenced as
early as the mid-nineteenth century and included an enhanced equatorial ocean response mechanism.
The deliberately exaggerated nature of some
early simulations produced exaggerated
modeling results, including significant changes in regional rainfall such as disruptions to Asian and African monsoons.
This scale factor was based on
simulations with an
early climate
model [3,92]; comparable forcings are found in other
models (e.g. see discussion in [93]-RRB-, but results depend on cloud representations, assumed ice albedo and other factors; so the uncertainty is difficult to quantify.
A
model - data comparison for a multi-
model ensemble of
Early Eocene atmosphere — ocean
simulations: EoMIP
The climate
model simulations also suggest that Earth's climate was in a «typical» greenhouse state, with temperatures similar to more recent, and better understood, greenhouse intervals in Earth's climate history, like the late Mesozoic and
early Cenozoic eras.
We conclude that
model overestimation of tropospheric warming in the
early twenty - first century is partly due to systematic deficiencies in some of the post-2000 external forcings used in the
model simulations.
Their scenario B, which had climate forcing that turned out to be close to reality, led to four of the six dice sides being red
early in the 21st century, based on their climate
model simulations.
The 0C - 10C range for 2xCO2 climate sensitivity encompasses ALL the published estimates I have seen, from the Spencer and Lindzen lower end of 0.6 C (from CERES and ERBE satellite observations) and the Forster and Gregory range of 0.9 C to 3.7 C (based on «purely observational evidence» — see
earlier thread) to IPCC's range of 2.0 C to 4.5 C (from
model simulations based largely on theoretical deliberations rather than physical observations).