A few months ago, another journal's
editor resigned over a paper that should not have been accepted due to a poor peer review process.
He'd earlier been reportedly taking money from the American Petroleum Institute and he and Sallie Baliunas had a paper discredited in the journal Climate Research (it was so bad,
the editor resigned in protest).
As to why
the editor resigned there are several other scenarios.
Then
the editor resigned with a mea cupla and personal apology -LRB-!)
Various other scientific groups pointed out several flaws in the methods and assumptions in each of their publications, and in fact one
editor resigned because he felt his journal had failed its task of conducting rigorous peer - review in publishing a fundamentally flawed 2011 Spencer and Braswell paper (black in the first graphic).
I found you after my previous
editor resigned because of a particularly gory scene in one of my books, and you were like, «This is great.»
CNN: Jewish newspaper's
editor resigns over Obama assassination column A Jewish newspaper owner who attracted U.S. Secret Service attention for a column suggesting that Israel consider assassinating an American president has resigned as the paper's editor, employees there said Monday.
The case had some major fallout: Cerdà resigned from two journals and the editorial board of Geoderma, additional
editors resigned from their posts, and a university launched an investigation.
additional
editors resigned from their posts, and a university launched an investigation.
Two of the magazine's
editors resigned and the ad has since become one of the iconic images of feminist art history.
The Honolulu Biennial cut ties completely after the first report of the allegations, and days later, three
editors resigned from The Exhibitionist, a journal about curatorial practices that Hoffmann founded in 2009.
Multiple emails sent to Michaels asking whether he'd been aware this was why
the editors resigned, before he composed the Wall Street Journal op - ed, did not elicit a response.
I know of no other field where a phone call from Trenberth results in
an editor resigning over a paper which went through the standard review process.
I'm sure you know very well that peer review is by definition gatekeeping; in this case it's closing the gate against pieces of junk * scholarship * like that from McKitrick or the example that the hacked emails were talking about, the execrable Soon & Baliunas paper whose publication resulted in half a dozen
editors resigning from the journal in protest.
After finding the paper's methods and assumptions had been flawed, six of the journal's
editors resigned.
A number of review
editors resigned as a reaction against the publication of what they regarded as a seriously flawed paper.
«Three Journal
Editors Resign Over Paper by Skeptics,» The Heat is Online, July 29, 2003.
It reminded many of us of the more drastic case of Climate Research (CR), where several
editors resigned in 2003 in the wake of a colossally poor paper by Willie Soon and Sallie Baliunas, accepted for publication by none other than Chris de Freitas.
The publisher did not agree, so von Storch and other
editors resigned.
Half of the journal's
editors resigned over poor quality control in mid-2003.
Six of the journal's
editors resigned over the publication of this paper.
It is a very rare situation that
an editor resigns over the failure of peer review, and to my knowledge it has only happened once before in anything related to climate science — the mass resignation of 6 editors at Climate Research in 2003 in the wake of the Soon and Baliunas debacle.
Not exact matches
Last but certainly not least, at the New York Times, metro
editor Wendell Jamieson
resigned earlier this week after an internal investigation.
Editors said a reporter had added it without approval, and the reporter who filed the story was suspended and then later
resigned.
Cameron said his friend Rebekah Brooks, a former
editor of the tabloid, should have
resigned as chief executive of News International, the British unit of Rupert Murdoch's News Corp..
A controversial post was deleted from the site, leading a series of top
editors and writers to
resign.
He notoriously engaged in «compromised work» by plagiarizing and fabricating news stories and was forced to
resign, along with two
editors, in 2003.
DENVER — The Denver Post
editor who oversaw an editorial critical of budget and staff cuts made by the newspaper's New York - based hedge fund owners said he
resigned Thursday after...
As allegations of sexual harassment mount and a government minister
resigns, Premier's political
editor Martyn Eden suggests a way forward
(CNN)- A Jewish newspaper owner who attracted U.S. Secret Service attention for a column suggesting that Israel consider assassinating an American president has
resigned as the paper's
editor, employees there said Monday.
As allegations of sexual harassment mount and a government minister
resigns, Premier's political
editor Martyn Eden suggests a way forward More
In 1959, he even
resigned from the journal Modern Age in order to distance himself from
editor David Collier, whom he described as an «anti-Jewish freak.»
Adler apologized and
resigned as
editor, but some see the episode as the latest example of an increase in divisive, over-the-top rhetoric within American Jewish communal life, revolving largely around the hot - button issue of Israel and its policies toward the Palestinians.
Father Thomas Reese, S.J., who recently
resigned as
editor of America, a Jesuit weekly — or was removed, depending on which account one credits (see First Things August / September 2005)-- complains, «The Vatican is making decisions about the appropriateness of ordaining homosexuals in total ignorance of how many current priests are homosexuals, how well they observe celibacy, and how well they do ministry.»
I wrote a letter to the
editor explaining why and the backlash was so strong that the entire delegation to my office
resigned.
In 1904, Scoville
resigned from the college, and Benjamin Lillard,
editor of The Practical Druggist, had this to say about it: «Professor Wilbur L. Scoville, who has been known for many years as a prominent professor in the Massachusetts College of Pharmacy, has
resigned his position and accepted a berth with a large firm of Boston retailers owning four stores.
The school paper came out for the 14, and then Phil White, the
editor,
resigned.
The prime minister said he had decided to give the former News of the World
editor, who had edited the tabloid at the time when royal
editor Clive Goodman was jailed for phone - hacking, a «second chance» because he had «done the honourable thing» by
resigning.
Ex-commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson and ex-assistant commissioner John Yates, who
resigned last year over the employment of former News of the World deputy
editor Neil Wallis, are also slated to give evidence.
Accusations of inappropriate behavior prompted New York Times metropolitan
editor Wendell Jamieson to
resign.
The New York Times announced that Wendell Jamieson, the newspaper's metro
editor, had
resigned after an internal investigation but did not specify the reason for his departure.
-LSB-...] Numerous contributors to PoliticsHome, including
editor - in - chief, Andrew Rawnsley, have
resigned from the news aggregator and polling website in a row over its new owner — Michael Ashcroft, the deputy chairman of the Conservative Party.
Liberal Conspiracy» We hereby
resign from PoliticsHome...: About the author: Sunny Hundal is
editor of Liberal Co..
Coulson
resigns as
editor, claiming to have no knowledge of illegal activity at the paper.
He
resigned from the Sunday paper when its royal
editor, Clive Goodman, was convicted of phone hacking.
Once the top
editor at News of the World, Andy Coulson
resigned but denied any knowledge of hacking.
He
resigned in January 2011, saying allegations that he was involved in phone hacking when
editor of the News of the World made it impossible for him to continue.
Iain Overton,
editor of the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, which worked with Newsnight on the McAlpine story, also
resigned today.
The pressure on then - News of the World
editor and current News International chief executive Rebekah Brooks to
resign is now tremendous, as several influential political figures branded her position «untenable».
Mr Coulson, who
resigned as
editor of the News of the World over the issue, is now the prime minister's director of communications.